Cake or Death lofts a 40/20 towards the Bulls' end...
Saints and the Devil The Case of Ian Millward
Ian Millward, coach of St Helens Saints, is suspended as of the moment, and may wind up getting sacked this Monday. Not because of lack of performance (second in Super League this season to date, with five trophies in the Saints trophy case), but because of his intemperate nature.
But the question arises what will happen to Super League if Millward leaves Saints especially if he returns to his original home, St George-Illawarra Dragons, where his father holds an executive position?
The charges laid against Millward were not from Super League, but from Saints chair Eamonn McManus and chief executive, Sean McGuire. According to an article by David Lawrenson in the 8 May Observer, the Saints board was not involved in suspending Millward. Senior director Eric Ashton, with some 35 years tenure, and the only person whose coaching tenure at Saints has exceeded Millwards, remarked:
I am not being blamed for something I had nothing to do with. The directors have had a lot of stick but had no involvement whatsoever. I'm at my wit's end, it has upset me and my family
The first I got to know about it was a call from Bob Millward, Ian's father. This is a disgrace. I have not been asked my opinion
Him [Millward] and the chief executive have never got on. [1]
A Christopher Irvine article in the 6 May London Times details the three charges laid against Millward by the Saints executives:
1) Swearing at a Warrington Wolves press officer during a press conference in Warrington
2) Angrily ordering Brian Carney, the Wigan Warriors wing, from a closed training session he was attending with Sky Sport
3) Swearing at a fourth official during a Super League match earlier this season.
Irvine notes also that disagreements between Millward and McManus and McGuire havent helped matters. [2]
The fans want him to stay, as do his players, but that may not cut too much ice with McManus and McGuire, especially when their failure to consult with the other directors is considered.
Let us presume that Millward is sacked would he definitely move on to Dragons? Or would another Super League side try to sign him? Although he coached Leigh Centurions before being hired by Saints, I dont think he would want to take the immense task of helping a weak Centurions side avoid relegation, especially mid-season. Most Super League clubs have sufficiently stable situations where a new coach isnt warranted, for one reason or another.
There are two Super League sides that could use him now, sides that have ample player resources to make it worth his while to sign a contract, and need a spark immediately: Wigan Warriors, fighting through inconsistency caused by massive injuries to date; and Wakefield Trinity Wildcats, whose wild inconsistency indicates that either a psychiatrist or a taskmaster like Millward is needed. In addition, signing with Wigan would make their rivalry with Saints even more compelling than it is now.
But even massive rivals like Bradford and Wigan would shed tears if Millward returned home to Dragons. Why? Because, love him or hate him, Millward kept Super League in the media eye more than it would have been without him a priceless asset, considering that union, football, and cricket are better covered than Super League is in England.
Saints press conferences, as risky as they were to reporters and opposition press officers, were very entertaining with Millward at the microphone. And the Saints Warriors rivalry was taken to new heights with Millward on the Saints touchline. Even sides that werent rivals with Saints benefited, because attendances were higher when Millward brought the Saints to their pitch, and they had a better chance of getting games on television.
Saints would likely still contend without Millward as their coach their squad is one of the three best in Super League. But, if they dont, the Knowsley Road faithful wont be happy, as their protest after their Challenge Cup tie with York last Saturday showed.
Will Super League be ill served by a Saints sacking of Millward? Since blood is thicker than water, the odds would have to be in favour of Millward returning to Dragons (although I have heard suggestions that Newcastle Knights could use him as well). As Super League has precious little exposure as it stands now, even with Millward, perhaps they will not be affected. However, even as a Wakey fan, I would not want to risk finding out.
References:
[1]
http://observer.guardian.co.uk/sport/story/0,6903,1479189,00.html
[2]
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,19989-1600054,00.html
750 words, including title.