What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,255
Pretty hard to break up that core of players.
Bulldogs got Crighton out of there, probably by offering him stupid money to play fullback. Luai looks like he may be taking less to stay on.

I’m wondering how much Cleary is on. He’s probably ion unders himself(under the cap at least).

Cleary will own half of Penrith by the time he retires he will have his fingers in every new business out west...
 

T.S Quint

Coach
Messages
14,436
Dunster had done his ACL/MCL/PCL earlier than that time line though and Waqa has been hit an miss and I dont think anyone ever thought Loizou was first grade standard.

Opa was also leaving 11 months ago.

Russell is good he will be a fine winger and backup fullback he may develop into a center one day but not a for a few more seasons.

The club needs to prepare for this Penrith signed Alomoti recently why didn't we? He has more upside than Harper.

Like I have said Harper is only coming to our club as we are the only NRL side throwing a contract at him that's not the type of player I want.

I don’t know why we didn’t sign Alomoti. Maybe we tried. I’m sure we would have had some idea of how much he was asking from teams, and maybe we couldn’t fit it under the cap. Maybe we could pay it and would have made him an offer but he would prefer to go to Penrith.

Is he better than Harper. For sure. But I can’t say here and say “Why didn’t we just sign him” without having all the information.
 

Soto

Bench
Messages
4,205
Dunster had done his ACL/MCL/PCL earlier than that time line though and Waqa has been hit an miss and I dont think anyone ever thought Loizou was first grade standard.

Opa was also leaving 11 months ago.

Russell is good he will be a fine winger and backup fullback he may develop into a center one day but not a for a few more seasons.

The club needs to prepare for this Penrith signed Alomoti recently why didn't we? He has more upside than Harper.

Like I have said Harper is only coming to our club as we are the only NRL side throwing a contract at him that's not the type of player I want.
Or dumb enough to offer him one after he told us to bugger off earlier in the year...so we go again and sign him..gotta be happy with mediocrity
 

Soto

Bench
Messages
4,205
So 4664 pages today. Have we signed anyone yet? Are we there yet?
At this rate its gonna be a loooooong off season...I'm sure there will be plenty of good humoured banter (friendly too) to get us through til preseason training then Xmas and then the trials.
Relax we are Eels supporters we've seen this movie plenty of times before.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,184
So 4664 pages today. Have we signed anyone yet? Are we there yet?
At this rate its gonna be a loooooong off season...I'm sure there will be plenty of good humoured banter (friendly too) to get us through til preseason training then Xmas and then the trials.
Relax we are Eels supporters we've seen this movie plenty of times before.
Tbh our off season is already 6 weeks old.

We finished a week before spring had even started on a Thursday night.
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,784
In any case, @Stagger eel, which elite outside backs are still available in October? They were all free to negotiate 11 months ago.

well there aren’t many available now nor do we really need elite level outside backs but there were plenty available who could at least put pressure on the blokes who havent had to work hard for an nrl spot in the last 12 or so months..
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,255
I don’t know why we didn’t sign Alomoti. Maybe we tried. I’m sure we would have had some idea of how much he was asking from teams, and maybe we couldn’t fit it under the cap. Maybe we could pay it and would have made him an offer but he would prefer to go to Penrith.

Is he better than Harper. For sure. But I can’t say here and say “Why didn’t we just sign him” without having all the information.

True we may have tried to sign him but his asking price was too rich for someone who hasn't hit his straps in first grade.

The Roosters / Dogs have some decent Flegg centres we could be chasing.

Broncos too have some decent backs that may be enticed to leave early to come across..
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,255
well there aren’t many available now nor do we really need elite level outside backs but there were plenty available who could at least put pressure on the blokes who havent had to work hard for an nrl spot in the last 12 or so months..


My preference is not to waste a spot on Harper and train Simmonson in the offseason to play centre (he hasn't had a proper off season with us yet) along with Dick Penisini and Blaze Tualiga beefing them up and continuing their development..
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,024
I don’t know why we didn’t sign Alomoti. Maybe we tried. I’m sure we would have had some idea of how much he was asking from teams, and maybe we couldn’t fit it under the cap. Maybe we could pay it and would have made him an offer but he would prefer to go to Penrith.

Is he better than Harper. For sure. But I can’t say here and say “Why didn’t we just sign him” without having all the information.
Penrith might’ve offered him a starting gig. They are losing a centre.
 
Top