Johnny88
Juniors
- Messages
- 1,713
Newcastle Knights 2026 NRL season scouting report: Best 17, contract statuses, rookie watch
New coach, new CEO, new prized playmaker — is it a new beginning for the Knights? Or will the pressure for success get the better of them? We analyse their squad, rookies, issues and more.It’s a new era for Newcastle. New CEO, new coach and a new half.
With a bit of luck, it could spark a wave of success over the next few years, but talk is cheap and after years of disappointment, Knights fans will want results early after finishing last in 2025.
They’ve gone all in on Dylan Brown as the man to fix an ongoing halves dilemma, and if they’ve got it right, $1.3 million a season will look like a bargain.
But with great money comes great pressure, and it’s something the former Parramatta half will have to deal with every week as the highest paid player in the game. Brown hasn’t yet owned an NRL season but comes to the club off a spectacular Pacific Championships campaign with New Zealand.
Is this Newcatle's strongest 17?
Free agency wrap & rating
Dylan Brown was the big fish, but only time will tell if the Kiwis star was an astute buy or an overcommitment of the salary cap. Having so much money tied up in Ponga and Brown is a big gamble, but it could pay off if they get all the pieces around them right.The big issue is they’ve lost some crucial bodies in the forward pack, the most devastating of all being Leo Thompson (Bulldogs), who has been the Knights’ best prop over the past few seasons.
Kai Pearce-Paul (Tigers) and Jack Hetherington (Storm) have also left a big void in the pack, with Pasami Saulo and Trey Mooney, both from the Raiders, added to the forward stocks. Depth is a huge concern if one or two injuries take hold.
Jake Arthur gives them more options in the halves when things get rocky, while Sandon Smith is a handy replacement at hooker for Jayden Brailey and is expected to work in tandem with New Zealand No.9 Phoenix Crossland.
Rating: B
Coach status & safety rating
Coaching is a cutthroat industry but there’s two times within the lifespan of a career that are probably considered safest – immediately after a premiership and within the first year at a new gig. Justin Holbrook takes over the Knights after six years under Adam O’Brien and will be given time to get this squad right. And he’ll need it.Although he didn’t have a lot of luck in his last head coaching gig on the Gold Coast there’s high hopes the former Roosters assistant can get some improvement out of the talented squad.
Rating: A
Dylan Brown
The kind of money he’s earning as top dog in Newcastle comes with a lot of pressure to perform every single week, and an expectation to be a matchwinner. It’s something he’s been able to do sporadically in the past, but this is his year to announce himself as one of the best players in the game.
Three burning issues
Halves conundrumAll eyes will be on Dylan Brown and what position he plays for the Knights after his sensational form at five-eighth for the Kiwis in the Pacific Championships. Recruitment boss Peter O’Sullivan defended the signing of Brown in an exclusive interview with this masthead in March, backing him to play halfback when the Knights were under attack for signing the former Parramatta star to a 10-year deal worth $13 million.
“Those who are saying he’s not a halfback were probably saying the same thing about Cooper Cronk and Jahrome Hughes,” O’Sullivan said.
Brown was signed when axed coach Adam O’Brien was in charge, whether new boss Justin Holbrook sticks to the plan of playing the former Eel at halfback is yet to be decided.
Brown has indicated he’s happy to play wherever Holbrook wants him to.
Whatever they decide to do with Brown will impact the player next to him, whether it’s Sandon Smith at halfback or Fletcher Sharpe at five-eighth. It’s a major puzzle for Holbrook to figure out in the pre-season.
Brown has 13 million reasons to hope things work out in Newcastle. Picture: Brendon Thorne/Getty Images
Pressure for success
They couldn’t have been further from the finals this year after finishing with the wooden spoon. And while that’s bad enough, they have the longest grand final drought of any team in the NRL – their 2001 premiership the last time they made the grand final. That’s 25 years with no shot at the title, and while they’ve made finals on the odd occasion, there’s no fun in participation ribbons.
Holbrook’s return
Justin Holbrook is a likeable guy, and it seemed too harsh he was given the flick by the Titans while they were sitting ninth midway through the 2023 season. Now he gets a second chance as a head coach after two years working as assistant to Trent Robinson at the Roosters, with a stack of talent at his disposal.
It’s a big job. He’s got a new spine to work with and two of the highest paid players in the game in Kalyn Ponga and Dylan Brown, as well as a group of young stars that need developing in a town starved of success.
Holbrook is ready to turn the Knights around. Picture: Chris Hyde/Getty Images)
Crystal ball
There’s been so much turnover at the Knights over the past 12 months, and while they’ve refreshed their squad with young, dynamic players, they desperately need a bit of luck and stability. If they get it right, this could be one of the most exciting teams to watch in 2026.2026 odds
Premiership: $51Minor premiership: $126
To make grand final: $23
Top four: $17
Top eight: $6.50
Most losses: $4.25
Loading…
www.dailytelegraph.com.au
