What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Season 2026

Sime_11

Juniors
Messages
2,056
If Edgar is good enough he could even play wing. That is where Edwards debuted for Penrith.
if we lose To'o & Dylan to NSW - i can see Ivan playing Garns & Tago at centre with Alamoti and Jenkins on the wings
 

Fangs

Referee
Messages
21,571
if we lose To'o & Dylan to NSW - i can see Ivan playing Garns & Tago at centre with Alamoti and Jenkins on the wings

I like our backline depth right now. Not massive depth but Jenkins was extremely unlucky to miss out in the finals last year. His 2025 was outstanding.

9 was the worry. Options past Kenny last year were paper thin. We've recruited some cover in that area which is an upgrade on Schneider/Cogger but we will have to wait and see how they perform.

Too small

So was Laurie. Didn't stop him getting a run on the wing. And a debut from the bench too.

You know how it is. Sometimes you have a player who is too good for reserves. Coaches find a way. If Edgar is good enough he could play there.
 

Chins

First Grade
Messages
5,069
I like our backline depth right now. Not massive depth but Jenkins was extremely unlucky to miss out in the finals last year. His 2025 was outstanding.

9 was the worry. Options past Kenny last year were paper thin. We've recruited some cover in that area which is an upgrade on Schneider/Cogger but we will have to wait and see how they perform.



So was Laurie. Didn't stop him getting a run on the wing. And a debut from the bench too.

You know how it is. Sometimes you have a player who is too good for reserves. Coaches find a way. If Edgar is good enough he could play there.
He's a fullback only
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,726
Normally outside of resting in the last round

No he misses games every year mate. Personally im assuming Jaxson will be our back up full back which means hes definitely getting some nrl this year as our back up full back gets games every year.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,726
Until he isn't. Like Edwards, Laurie, Moylan etc.

Lets see what happens.

Exactly.

If hes to small for the wing hes just to small and we shouldnt be considering him for one of the highest paid position in the game if he cant survive in the lowest paid position in the backline.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,726
We've reached a point with the current team where our best players from the dynasty are mostly pushing 30, they arent all under 27 anymore. I think the clubs signings this past few months reflect them having an eye on the future. Guys like Edgar, Billy Scott who are potentially the long term options in the spine need to be getting a taste. We need to be developing the next players to take over now and we need to start seeing how they go at the NRL level to see if they are going to be the options, we cant start developing them once Dyl or Kenny is gone. Obviously they will need to show some form in cup and wait for opportunities but there is no way imo we are parking Edger and Scott in cup for the whole year.
 

Chins

First Grade
Messages
5,069
We've reached a point with the current team where our best players from the dynasty are mostly pushing 30, they arent all under 27 anymore. I think the clubs signings this past few months reflect them having an eye on the future. Guys like Edgar, Billy Scott who are potentially the long term options in the spine need to be getting a taste. We need to be developing the next players to take over now, we start developing them once Dyl or Kenny is gone. Obviously they will need to show some form in cup and wait for opportunities but there is no way imo we are parking Edger and Scott in cup for the whole year.
I'd love him to play but everything ive ever seen screams fullback only.
Getting smashed and held in a corner on the wing wouldn't do anything to help his game.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,726
I'd love him to play but everything ive ever seen screams fullback only.
Getting smashed and held in a corner on the wing wouldn't do anything to help his game.

I actually think that would be good experience for a full back tbh, If he cant handle that how is he going to play full back? Full backs get isolated an smashed more than wingers do. He is 100 percent going to have to take those runs as a fullback.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,726
I dont even want Edgar on the wing tbh and i think he will get picked on the bench at times and be the back up to dyl so hes going to play FB at some point this season, but the idea that we could have a full back that is unpickable on the wing bothers me a lot.
 

Luke Bowden

First Grade
Messages
8,428
We've reached a point with the current team where our best players from the dynasty are mostly pushing 30, they arent all under 27 anymore. I think the clubs signings this past few months reflect them having an eye on the future. Guys like Edgar, Billy Scott who are potentially the long term options in the spine need to be getting a taste. We need to be developing the next players to take over now and we need to start seeing how they go at the NRL level to see if they are going to be the options, we cant start developing them once Dyl or Kenny is gone. Obviously they will need to show some form in cup and wait for opportunities but there is no way imo we are parking Edger and Scott in cup for the whole year.
I don’t disagree they need game time but it’s a fine line. You don’t want to mess with their confidence if they struggle and you don’t want to put them in the shop window if they kill it….. all part of the game
 
Top