What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Should the Raiders take action against the NRL?

Bay56

First Grade
Messages
5,464
As Wayne Bennett said in the press conference … you’ve got to cop these things and get on with it. True, I agree, afterall we live in an environment where human judgement is part and parcel of the game and therefore mistakes will be made. But how much must you take was not made clear by Bennett and I’m quite sure if the Broncos received the same treatment as the Raiders do week in week out his comment might have been structured differently.

It is an opinion of mine that if Raiders management do not take action regarding the treatment we have received this season from the officials (especially video refs) they could be considered to be derelict in their duty.

There cannot be any doubt that the Raiders have been on the wrong end of more than their fair share of 50-50 calls (even 60-40 calls have often gone against us). One only has to hear the reaction from the TV commentators to gauge whether we are ranting or have a legitimate reason to feel cheated.

Are we the victim of circumstances ? … in my opinion no.

Is there a mindset (some might say a campaign) that places Canberra in the “who cares” basket ?… in my opinion yes.

It has become too easy to rule against the Raiders and it will continue to be so unless Raiders management take action.

I think that Raiders management should now indicate to the NRL that if the situation does not improve next season that action will be taken in the courts. I think they have enough evidence to suggest that there is a mindset or campaign within the referring ranks that disadvantages us.
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
Oh my god.

Take the NRL to court hey? Who will be your lawyers? Dennis Dennuto and Lionel Hutz?
How about the NRL show footage of inept Raiders play...like dropped balls, forward passes, bad reads in defence, poor kick chase...etc etc

Court action.....hahahah

Its.....Its.....Its the vibe
 

nickraider

Juniors
Messages
738
How can video refs get it wrong time and time again?!!! Carney did not play at the ball - can't he see that?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

nickraider

Juniors
Messages
738
Mr Saab said:
Oh my god.

Take the NRL to court hey? Who will be your lawyers? Dennis Dennuto and Lionel Hutz?
How about the NRL show footage of inept Raiders play...like dropped balls, forward passes, bad reads in defence, poor kick chase...etc etc

Court action.....hahahah

Its.....Its.....Its the vibe

Nobody is saying we played that well mate, because we didn't. But, dropped balls and forward passes have got nothing to do with inept video ref calls.
 

sydraider

First Grade
Messages
5,704
Mr Saab said:
Oh my god.

Take the NRL to court hey? Who will be your lawyers? Dennis Dennuto and Lionel Hutz?
How about the NRL show footage of inept Raiders play...like dropped balls, forward passes, bad reads in defence, poor kick chase...etc etc

Court action.....hahahah

Its.....Its.....Its the vibe


Whats your problem dude?

You won the game yet you come into the RAIDERS forum and carry on like we have just humped ya cat without inviting you into the action.

Your comments reek of insecurity or is the fact that this will be the last win of the season and you dont want it marred with talk of 'inept decisions'

Honestly, If I was you, I would be chugging back a refreshing ale and enjoying the 2 points while you can, you sent off 5 of your players today with a win, WTF are you complaining about?
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
I am not complaining...i am laughing at the paranoia of some of you Raiders fans.
Take action against the NRL because of a percieved "vibe" against the Green Machine.

Wake up to yourself some of you. Really.
 

shear_joy9

Coach
Messages
13,743
Someone wear the Viking uniform and break Robert Finch's legs.

But seriously, the refereeing is a disgrace. I can actually see a disgruntled fan go as far assaulting an offical.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,108
Why don't you sue them over the Brad Thorn No Try? OH WAIT that was a call that went the Raiders way lets just forget about it....

FFS guys every team has a tough call here and there, it's apart of League.

Look at the Cowboys, they had a try disallowed for the exact same tackle Carney made et they carried on with it. Your lot on the other hand cannot stop complaining about it.
 

Bay56

First Grade
Messages
5,464
Big Pete said:
Why don't you sue them over the Brad Thorn No Try? OH WAIT that was a call that went the Raiders way lets just forget about it....

FFS guys every team has a tough call here and there, it's apart of League.

Look at the Cowboys, they had a try disallowed for the exact same tackle Carney made et they carried on with it. Your lot on the other hand cannot stop complaining about it.

Dude I'll give you the benefit of the doubt that you dont get around town on the tow of a seeing eye dog.

He clearly bounced the ball before the line and then was held up by the arms of Howell and Graham.

If that decision had been given in favour of the Broncs I'd be in absolute no doubt that Westie had a few dollars on the game.
 

Bay56

First Grade
Messages
5,464
Big Pete said:
Why don't you sue them over the Brad Thorn No Try? OH WAIT that was a call that went the Raiders way lets just forget about it....

FFS guys every team has a tough call here and there, it's apart of League.

Look at the Cowboys, they had a try disallowed for the exact same tackle Carney made et they carried on with it. Your lot on the other hand cannot stop complaining about it.

I have no problems at all with a dubious call "here and there". The fact is we get a fair share of them and some of them couldnt even be classifed as 50-50 ... the Todd Carney call today being a fine example where the TV commentators have made a call on the incident (similar to the call of most others) but the video ref comes up with a real clanger ... and those clangers much more than often cost us games.
 

Bay56

First Grade
Messages
5,464
Big Pete said:
Using a Raiders comeback, you're not a neutral fan so your view is BS.

Call it what you want mate ... I'll call it based on having seen that incident with the very same technology that the guy in the box has.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,108
Just like I did.

But oh no wait, I must be blind?

I love the double standards set out by the Raiders fans.
 

Bay56

First Grade
Messages
5,464
Big Pete said:
Just like I did.

But oh no wait, I must be blind?

I love the double standards set out by the Raiders fans.

confirmed then huh :lol:

dude your opinion around here is prob worth didly sqot .. I'd suggest you go to the Broncos forum and tell them what a great game they played.

You might also ask them who slipped the brown envelope under Westie's door
 

sydraider

First Grade
Messages
5,704
Big Pete said:
Just like I did.

But oh no wait, I must be blind?

I love the double standards set out by the Raiders fans.


Call it what you want.

You made the extra effort to come in here and complain about the complaint, makes you look sad.

f**k off and enjoy the win!
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
Its all about interpretation. He is not alone in the box, he has others there with him.
Are they wrong? In raiders eyes they are definately.

The Broncos copped a bad call vs the storm when Geyer dropped the ball over the line and Hampstead didnt go upstairs. Shyte happens. Dont see Bronco fans complaining about it and creating stupid threads like this.

If you are good enough you will overcome any percieved shortcomings from the referees fraternity. Just look at origin 3 2006.
 

sydraider

First Grade
Messages
5,704
Mr Saab said:
Its all about interpretation. He is not alone in the box, he has others there with him.
Are they wrong? In raiders eyes they are definately.

The Broncos copped a bad call vs the storm when Geyer dropped the ball over the line and Hampstead didnt go upstairs. Shyte happens. Dont see Bronco fans complaining about it and creating stupid threads like this.

If you are good enough you will overcome any percieved shortcomings from the referees fraternity. Just look at origin 3 2006.

Yep thats laughing at the complaint allright!
 

Latest posts

Top