SIMPSONS MAFIA (Game Thread)

[BDR]

I am talking about in the last game. Everybody plays the game differently.

The evidence against BDR is mounting. Don't you find it strange that he had already considered all possible repercussions of killing Hallatia, why would he need to think about that if he didn't have the power too?

Come on let's hear it! You keep saying it again and again and yet you still aren't pointing out all this "evidence". The reason you can't is because all you're doing is guessing.

All I said to Hallatia is "if someone were to kill you that would frame me perfectly". The mafia, being the obvious dopes that they are, then decided to do that straight away. If you are genuinely town then you should be able to use your brain and see what is happening.

 

[Cliffhanger]

I am not saying Whal is not guilty, I just BDR as a much bigger threat. The way he has changed his votes in the past, and his defensiveness right now!

I am insisting we kill him because I am a genuine townie. I know being wrong would me look guilty, but I am that certain that I am pushing for it.

 

[butchmcdick]

So can we have a total please

Also when does day finish ? How long do we have ?

 

[Cliffhanger]

9 votes for a lynch.

 

[Apey]

but the popular theory is that it is the mafia that are the push behind innocents being lynched.

I thought the popular theory was that the town is shooting themselves in the foot and that the mafia are letting them do so while they pick people off at night. That is what drew suspicion to the quiet people to begin with. Well, Bunniesman drew attention to them originally, but that's what gave the theory legs.

I've read the whole thread and that's the first real mention I've heard of that "popular theory" :crazy:

I have suspicions about Apey now seeing he is trying to steer us in that direction.

Hah! You can vote for whoever you like.

You will find that I am correct about some of the silent ones in particular eventually, whether I am dead or alive.

 

[Cliffhanger]

7 pm is when the vote closes.

 

[DB]

Vote: BDR

Same reasons I have used before.

 

[soc123_au]

THORSON1987 - 1 vote (HowHigh)
BDR - 5 votes (Cliffhanger, Ozzy, 9701, Whall15, DB)
CLIFFHANGER - 1 vote (Thorson1987)
WHALL15 - 3 votes (Rebel, Parra, Soc123_au)

Looks like it might be a lynch free day. No dead Mafia is a slippery slope. Cafeteria trays are not tobbogans.

 

[butchmcdick]

So the magic number is 9 to lynch

We have 16 people left alive and ten people have voted already. Is this correct ?

 

[Apey]

I'm torn about BDR for similar reasons as Cliff mentions.

On one hand, I genuinely suspected Bunniesman, Hala & JM (though JM was more of a bandwagon vote), so I'm practically 0/3 and don't want to take it to 0/4.

On the other hand, if he's mafia and I didn't vote for him, it looks bad.

However I'm learning towards taking that chance.

There are still 6 people who haven't voted including myself.

 

[soc123_au]

I've read the whole thread and that's the first real mention I've heard of that "popular theory" :crazy:

Its in there, the voting patterns back it up as well. How many quiet ones are dead? Most of the dead are town. A vote for Whall15 is a vote for freedom. The nurse is not dealing.

 

[Cliffhanger]

There's at least 7 bad guys left, possibly 8. How positive are you that Whall is guilty? I'm not convinced either way so let's lynch BDR, because I am sure about him.

 

[soc123_au]

There's at least 7 bad guys left, possibly 8. How positive are you that Whall is guilty? I'm not convinced either way so let's lynch BDR, because I am sure about him.

Its a bit of a conundrum really. A lot have been convinced of Whalls guilt from the begining. Rebel & Parra voting for him was the clincher for me.

The problem with me changing my vote for BDR is it would feel like jumping on the BM/JM lynch wagon. Apart from Hallatia riding him from the first post I cant see much else pointing that way. I could be wrong about BDR feel similar to Apey about lynching him. I am damned if I do and damned if I dont.

 

[butchmcdick]

Ok then

Look I just can't sit back and let a lynching go begging. It is the only opportunity we have to take out mafia members. A decision has to be made. Cliffy you seem very certain about BDR

I have suspicions about BDR but I also have them about others. In reality unless many other change their vote the choice is between BDR or nothing. On that basis I

vote BDR

 

[soc123_au]

could be wrong about BDR I feel similar to Apey about lynching him. I am damned if I do and damned if I dont.

Edit in bold.

 

[BDR]

Why re we still lynching people out of curiosity? It's not like it's served us well in the past.

There's at least 7 bad guys left, possibly 8. How positive are you that Whall is guilty? I'm not convinced either way so let's lynch BDR, because I am sure about him.

You have convinced me that you are at the very least an independent. Utter hypocrite who is trying to convince people to lynch me based on no evidence.

You guys will regret it, but whatever.

Vote: Cliffhanger

Probably in vain now but just so people will know who to target if I die.

 

[Cliffhanger]

I said I wasn't convinced about Whall. I am certain you are mafia.

 

[Frederick]

Why are you certain he's mafia?

 

[soc123_au]

I said I wasn't convinced about Whall. I am certain you are mafia.

I am not here on a fartball scholarship so I want my vote to count for something. Give us something more than you are certain. If you have something other than following Halla's lead I will help you swing BDR. I still have a lingering doubt it will be another BM style witch hunt. We can always swing Whall15 tommorow if need be.

 

[HowHigh]

Sounds like Cliffy is trying to set BRD up, perhaps the same way Sideshow Bob framed Krusty for robbing the kwik e mart?

Change Vote: Cliffhanger