What's new
By:
Advanced search…
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Team assesment

Sharkie73

Sharkie73

Bench
Messages
2,884
DAVID PEACHEY; Show some of the old peach needs to be more invoved :)

HASSAN SALEH; Played ok nothing flash

RYAN McGOLDRICK; Not impressed at all, Might need time in PL :(

PHIL BAILEY; needs to be back in the fowards, to slow, Fraz in here next week :shock:

MATTHEW RIECK; played well no droped ball :D

GREG BIRD; Seems to be playing better than last year. :)

BRETT KIMMORLEY ©; Fairly quiet to his standards but had a good game. :D

JASON STEVENS; played well was running freely :D

DANNY NUTLEY; Worked hard until he got injured :shock:

ANDREW LOMU; Not one of his better performances. :(

PAUL GALLEN; Played well until he got injured :shock:

MATT HILDER; great game :D

Interchange
CHRIS BEATTIE; Back to his mungrel best. :D

KEITH GALLOWAY; played realy well :D

SAM ISEMONGER; Had a quiet game, I think he got injured also :shock:

MICHAEL SULLIVAN; played a great game should be in the starting line up. :D
Over all It was a better looking style of attack, I think once they all settle in and get there best side on the paddock things will improve.
 
cheese

cheese

Bench
Messages
4,013
Sullivan has definitely matured IMO. Last year he was prone to brain explosions, but tonight i thought he play controlled and within himself. Good stuff from the little fella. His darts out of the ruck are always going to trouble the oppositon
 
T

The Popper

Bench
Messages
4,353
That's a pretty lenient assessment, 73. I thought the performance was pretty much sh*thouse. Don't forget - Richards, Marshall, Lanfranchi and Covell didn't play for the Tiges. Lots of points there. Sure one or two of our blokes played reasonably well. But where was the penetration, where was the GO-FORWARD teamwork, where was the forward defence when the Tigers were making big yards up the guts.
I was very, very disappointed in the performance. I expected a lot better.
Who dominated play for us? Only two blokes I reckon gave the Tigers much to worry about were Sully and Galloway.
 
Docking

Docking

Juniors
Messages
204
The Popper said:
That's a pretty lenient assessment, 73. I thought the performance was pretty much sh*thouse. Don't forget - Richards, Marshall, Lanfranchi and Covell didn't play for the Tiges. Lots of points there. Sure one or two of our blokes played reasonably well. But where was the penetration, where was the GO-FORWARD teamwork, where was the forward defence when the Tigers were making big yards up the guts.
I was very, very disappointed in the performance. I expected a lot better.
Who dominated play for us? Only two blokes I reckon gave the Tigers much to worry about were Sully and Galloway.
Click to expand...

I couldn't agree more Popper, we had a pathetic performance against sub standard opposition, Raper had better turn things around VERY quickly.
 
B

bull shark

Juniors
Messages
344
Pretty fair assessment - except I thought that Peachey was better than you say. Lomu shoudl go back to P.L. Franze, Vagana and Merritt will make a difference.

Also, this year I beleive ther'll be a better work ethic - we know we've got to lift ourselves off the bottom. On the other hand I reckon the only easy beat team will be Souths
 
A

Anonymous

Juniors
Messages
46
My assessment:

Peach - a few good runs, but nothing too exciting.
Saleh - excellent game. Our best outside back by far. If he keeps it up, he can happily keep his spot in first grade.
Bailey - quiet game
McGoldrick - not great, targetted constantly by Elford
Rieck - nothing special, at least he didn't drop the ball.

Bird - A lot better running game. If he can work out his passing game then he might do okay. Nothing special.
Noddy - way too quiet, and his kicking game was off.

Beattie - not a bad game. The game wasn't lost in the forwards, so I can't criticize him too much.
Bosnich - some sloppy passing but not too bad overall.
Nutley - tireless.
Gallen - Did okay, until he came off.
Lomu - pass me the gun.
Hilder - usual tireless display.

Stevens - our best forward. Did some damage off the bench.
Galloway - Ran hard and wasn't out of place. Big things to come from him.
Isemonger - nothing special, but nothing too bad either.
Sullivan - best on the park. I'd keep him on the bench, if only because of the awesome impact he provides. He was shit last year, but if he keeps this form up I'll be extremely pleased.
 
millersnose

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
DAVID PEACHEY; Fails to live up to the hype as usual - outplayed by hogson


HASSAN SALEH; a fair game

RYAN McGOLDRICK; time will tell

PHIL BAILEY; a hog

MATTHEW RIECK; didnt see much ball cause of the hog centers

GREG BIRD; crap

BRETT KIMMORLEY ordinary - therefor dissappointing - good in defence

JASON STEVENS; ran hard but more needed

DANNY NUTLEY; a more disciplined performance than usual

ANDREW LOMU; went ok - good to see offloads in the forwards shame there wasnt any back up

PAUL GALLEN; ill disciplined

MATT HILDER; ordinary

Interchange
CHRIS BEATTIE; slow

KEITH GALLOWAY; might get a regular spot with the two tortoises up front

SAM ISEMONGER; ordinary

MICHAEL SULLIVAN; spark? - id hate to be starting a fire

Over all It was a bad performance and needs to improve

more runners of kimmorley in attack and the wingers need to see some ball
 
A

Anonymous

Juniors
Messages
46
Our backs were the problem tonight. Plenty of chances, but nothing to show for it. It was up to an eighteen year old prop forward to show them what a try is.
 
P

Poider

Juniors
Messages
12
Didnt go to the game but heard Stevens didnt do too bad, hopefully our attack will be more structured, overall very scrappy game
 
Sharkie73

Sharkie73

Bench
Messages
2,884
El Garbo, I agree the backs had nothing tonight. I think next week, Franz in for Bailey and Bailey in for Lomu and Merritt in for Saleh. this might fix that problem with the backs
 
SadShark

SadShark

Bench
Messages
4,049
That was an absolutely awful game. A Bad Moon Is On The Rise this year boys & girls. Lomu was a bumbling imbecile. Lots wrong. A long, long year ahead. See The Popper to refresh any other points from the game. Shyte :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil: #-o #-o #-o #-o #-o :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry:
 
T

The Popper

Bench
Messages
4,353
millersnose said:
GREG BIRD; crap
Click to expand...

Funny thing you should say that, Schnoz. I thought the same. Then I thought `No, Popper! You're being too hard on the lad.' Sure his tackling has improved, but where do you put him? I don't reckon he's a 5/8.
 
T

The Popper

Bench
Messages
4,353
cheese said:
I reckon ya put him behind the bar at sharks leagues
Click to expand...

A top move, Cheese. Or maybe doorman. He'd look good in black trousers, a long sleeved white shirt, and a light blue bow tie. :?
 
cheese

cheese

Bench
Messages
4,013
lol pop. I agree, though he'd be fumbling ID's all night ...better than dropping beers though i suppose
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Top