What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Team v Sea Eagles

ozbash

Referee
Messages
26,922
Wade McKinnon makes his return from suspension for the Vodafone Warriors’ preliminary final against Manly in week three of the NRL play-offs at the Sydney Football Stadium on Saturday.
McKinnon (28) was today named in his regular position of fullback for just his fifth appearance of a season disrupted by a long lay-off after major knee surgery and then interrupted by a three-match ban on a contrary conduct charge.
Before the suspension, McKinnon had scored three tries in his first four matches back from injury.
His return results in Lance Hohaia reverting to the interchange role he filled when McKinnon came back into the side against Brisbane last month. In McKinnon’s absence Hohaia has again impressed at fullback.
“I can’t say enough about the job Lance has done. He’s been terrific for us all year in a position he was asked to fill when Wade was sidelined,” said Cleary.
“It’s really tough on Lance but Wade is our first-choice fullback and he showed what a quality player he is in that position the moment he came back from his lay-off.”
The McKinnon-Hohaia swap is predictably the only change to the starting line-up that won 30-13 last Friday night to eliminate the Sydney Roosters from the finals race.
Saturday night’s match will be poignant for captain Steve Price and fellow prop Evarn Tuimavave. They’ll both move within one match of landmark appearances, Price with his 299th first-grade match since his debut in 1994 and Tuimavave his 99th since his first in 2002. At the same time, Manly’s Steve Menzies will play his 348th match, one short of equalling Terry Lamb’s all-time competition record of 349.
Price is set to become only the 11th player in history to play 300 first-grade games – team-mate Ruben Wiki became the 10th earlier this season – while Tuimavave is poised to join 12 other players who have appeared in 100 first-grade matches for the Vodafone Warriors.
In the last month the Vodafone Warriors have won four consecutive sudden-death matches. They beat Penrith (42-20) and Parramatta (28-6) to claim a spot in the top eight before going on to account for Melbourne 18-15 and then the Roosters to move within one win of making the club’s second grand final appearance.
Having won two matches at home and two away in the last month, the Vodafone Warriors head into the 12th finals match in the club’s history with a 15 win-11 loss record so far this season. In finals matches they now have a record of six wins and five losses.
In winning 10 of their last 12 matches, the Vodafone Warriors have included successes against Melbourne (twice), Cronulla, Brisbane and the Roosters but they haven’t been able to beat Manly in three attempts this year, losing a pre-season trial on the Sunshine Coast, being humiliated 6-52 at Brookvale Oval in March and then dropping their home clash 14-20 in June.
“You look at Manly and you just can’t find weaknesses,” said Cleary.
“They’ve played extremely well this season and we’ll need a huge effort in all areas if we’re to be in contention against them. We played very well in the second half against the Roosters but we’ll need to be at that level from the outset to stay in the game with Manly.”
The Sea Eagles have had a week off since trouncing St George Illawarra 38-6 in week one of the finals series.
Vodafone Warriors winger Manu Vatuvei made it 16 tries in 16 matches this season with his touchdown against the Roosters, giving him 45 in 74 appearances overall (fourth behind Stacey Jones, Francis Meli and Clinton Toopi on the club’s all-time list). He is now fourth on the NRL’s 2008 try-scoring list with Manly fullback Brett Stewart leading on 20 in 22 games. Vatuvei also lies second on the list for most line breaks with 19, just behind Slater who has 21 but he has played 22 games.
With 27 tackles against the Roosters, loose forward Micheal Luck is once again the NRL’s leading tackler with 928, well clear of Parramatta’s Nathan Hindmarsh (909).

VODAFONE WARRIORS v MANLY SEA EAGLES
Sydney Football Stadium, Sydney
7.45pm, Saturday, September 27
VODAFONE WARRIORS
1
WADE McKINNON
2
AIDAN KIRK
3
BRENT TATE
4
JEROME ROPATI
5
MANU VATUVEI
6
MICHAEL WITT
7
NATHAN FIEN
8
RUBEN WIKI
9
IAN HENDERSON
10
STEVE PRICE (c)
11
SIMON MANNERING
12
BEN MATULINO
13
MICHEAL LUCK
Interchange (tqo to be omitted):
LANCE HOHAIA
EPALAHAME LAUAKI
SAM RAPIRA
GRANT ROVELLI
LOGAN SWANN
EVARN TUIMAVAVE

COACH: IVAN CLEARY

http://warriors.sitesuite.ws/plugins/newsfeed.cgi?rm=content&plugin_data_id=25002
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,816
Ivan is winning me over this year.

Good decisions.

Fien to half, Rovelli to reggies
Matulino over Swann.
Wade back straight away.

To top it off the bench would be

LANCE HOHAIA
EPALAHAME LAUAKI
SAM RAPIRA
EVARN TUIMAVAVE


All quality tough calls.
 

Scottey

Juniors
Messages
500
I think a winning side has to be rewarded... and I don't think Lauaki will make it on the bench over Logan.

Bench:
Hohaia
Rapira
Tuimavave
Swann
 

nzinmelb

Juniors
Messages
10
i agree, IMO not a great move to bring in lauaki over swan, esp. it being against manly and furthermore a semi-final

GO WARRIORS!!!
 

boxa777

Coach
Messages
12,388
McKinnon back in had to be done even though Lance has been awesome. Positive is Hohaia can now revert back to his roaming #14 role coming on and taking on the line..

f**k Matulino impresses me. He will become of the best backrowers in the comp in the next few years. Progress very similar to Lagi Setu.

It's all there for the Warriors. Team relatively injury free, momentum and an overwhelming incentive to send Wiki out a winner.
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
32,407
I think a winning side has to be rewarded... and I don't think Lauaki will make it on the bench over Logan.

Bench:
Hohaia
Rapira
Tuimavave
Swann


Hope so, TBH Lauaki and Rovelli suffer from the same problem, they're borderline first-graders... if push came to shove, and they needed another forward on the bench I'd hope they went for Packer or Fai before Lauaki
And to be honest Hohaia has been good, but defensively a big worry... much better off the nench
 

ozbash

Referee
Messages
26,922
Sea Eagles V Warriors
Referee: Tony Archer
Touch Judges: Steve Chiddy & Jeff Younis
Video Referee: Bill Harrigan
 

JoeD

First Grade
Messages
7,056
Lauaki can stay wherever he's been the last few weeks. Well away from the FG team. Can't believe we got Archer again, he's the one ref I can't stand. He just looks dim to me.
 
Messages
10,047
Sea Eagles V Warriors
Referee: Tony Archer
Touch Judges: Steve Chiddy & Jeff Younis
Video Referee: Bill Harrigan

Is a bit of confusion on this issue Oz

Official site of Manly, and i beleive also the Warriors, have listed Hayne as the referee for this match. Foxsports also
 

Skram

Juniors
Messages
489
No Lauaki, only if he'd been playing consistent good error-free footbal for some time would I want him in a finals game. Too much could go wrong. I hope/assume that Cleary will go for the Hohaia/Swann/Rapira/Tuimavave
 

Rovelli

Bench
Messages
4,384
Too much could go wrong with Hame, but he did dominate in R24 last season.

Hohaia/Swann/Rapira/Tuimavave is a good mix.

Rapira/Tuimavave - some go-forward against a tough pack

Hohaia - been getting involved and a real find of what could've been a poop season (until our late run)

Swann - as long as there aren't any overlaps where he has to pass it for a try to be scored
 

ozbash

Referee
Messages
26,922
Manly and Melbourne would have been cheering loudest at yesterday's appointment of referees for this weekend's NRL preliminary finals.

Leading whistleblower Tony Archer was handed the duties for the Storm's Friday night clash with Cronulla at the Sydney Football Stadium while Shayne Hayne will be in charge of the Sea Eagles' battle with New Zealand Warriors on Saturday.
It is the ideal allocation for the two competition front-runners based on their winning records with the referees.
The Storm have a 75 percent strike under Archer's control, winning 21 of 28 matches.
Their win-loss ratio under Hayne is 11-8 at just 58 percent.
Manly have won 80 percent of games (16 out of 20) with Hayne in charge and just 53 percent (nine of 17) under Archer.
Tellingly, the Sea Eagles have won all five matches away from Brookvale Oval when Hayne has refereed.
Cronulla's success rate under Archer's control is a more worrying 41 percent (10 of 24 matches), while the Warriors have won 43 percent of matches (10 of 23) with Hayne.
Both Cronulla and the Warriors have lost two of three games away from home under the referees in charges of their finals this weekend.

http://www.stuff.co.nz/4703793a10713.html
 
Messages
218
How scary is it that the two best refs in the NRL are thought to be Tony Archer and Shayne Hayne?

And count me in for a Hohaia / Swann / Tuimavave / Rapira bench too. :)
 

Latest posts

Top