What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The dawn of a new era!

Loudstrat

Coach
Messages
15,224
I think this week we turned the corner and possibly closed a f*cking bleak chapter stretching back to 1987.

FFS, all the whingers and doomsdayers here - its all habit from following a sh8t and grossly underachieving club. I remember a great club that smashed all - not just the 3 straight - but the 76-86 period when we 7 GF's in 11 years under 3 different coaches, including the only good thing Gerald Fitzdenis ever did - sign Jack Gibson. He dined on that sucess for 25 insipid up-himself years. After the 86 GF he f*cked up continually - buying sh*t players to replace legends : Price for Lindner, Cronin for Woolfe, Sterling for Galbraith. We churned through that many good crops of youngsters, like the last few years, the Hayne/Inu/Mateo crop, the Lyon/Cayless/Hindmarsh crop, even back as far as the Mahon/Woods/Bell crop - without the cattle, leadership or staff to make a difference.

What saved our arse - and Fitzy's, was the signing of the Canterbury 4, Aaron Raper, Adam Ritson and John Simon during Super League (done in the Hilditch era, not Brian Smith). That took us back to our 1975 rebuild. Grand finals and premierships should have followed. But near enough was good enough - seasons inexplicably died at the 70th minute of THREE consecutive prelim finals. We actually won the ast one, but were simply shitfully prepared mentally, physically and structurally for Newy in 01. Had we won that our 2001 side would have been looked back as the greatest of the modern era.

The source of our current shit lies a few days before that GF - when Smith got his 5 year extention. We performed insipidly for those years despite making the finals - some of you will recall the joy of Andrew McFadden at half, then Adam Dykes, and then that useless pommy who might have been OK had Smith not been obsessed with the plodder Wagon. Quite simply Smith was nothing better than an average coach with good game plans - made to look better because he inherited a gun side, an 3 budding legends in Hindy, Cayless and Lyon.

Since October 01 we have been f*cked save for 3 years when we suddenly kicked into life in July - 05 (Taylor), 07 (Hagan) and 09 (Ando). These 3 coaches did better than Smith in that JT debuted Hayne, and held the club together after Smith's tantrum, Hagan had us firing and not choking in September (F*cking Olympic Park being an inch wider and we win the comp - our backs were brilliant that year), and Ando took us within a sh*t penalty of the GF.

By then, Fitzgerald's unique ability to be hated was sealing his fate. Has there ever been a single CEO that has pissed off so many cub legends in RL history? So much so that the Price/Grothe/Kenny/Leadbeater backed 3p came into power on the back of hate rather than a plan.

How did they react? Punted Ando (admittedly he was crap in 10), but replaced him with the utterly clueless Kearney. Why? So we could get him before anyone else would!!!!! This for a coach that only achieved anything with Wayne Bennett holding his hand!

Thankfully Mooks was flicked - but for Ricky Stuart???? In hindsight, it was Spagnolo's ego trip to sign the last ex-coach with any major distant success to floss out his resume with. We saw how that ended.

Since them there has been a boardroom power struggle that has seen a Stalinist purge to through the club everytime the board changes.

To me, this week has potentially been a closure of those times. Despite the media pani, I think our board s working ok - check out Manly's, and then think about what we DONT see at Canberra, Melbourne, Canterbury, Cronulla or Newcastle et al in recent times. Forget board unity for a sec - the REAL unity needs to be between Chairman-CEO-Head Coach-Coaching staff-players. I think we have achieved that maybe for the first time since 1983.

As for Ray Price - he can f*ck off. He is our George Piggins. Of all those legends assembled under Jack Gibson, I now only have respect for 3 of them - Cronin (for actually getting off his arse and doing something rather than whinging), Sterling (For his contined media brilliance) and Ella (for his remarkable work in the indigenous community). It pains me to see the likes of Price, Kenny, Guru snr et al continue to be village idiots n the public eye - and work not for Parra but for themselves. I am certain that the old legends from Canterbury, Manly, Saints and bar Piggins, Souths, keep their differences private and unite behind their club publicly.

Denis Fitgerald created that environment.

This week, that environment ended. I hope anyway. But I believe it has. The Chairman got his CEO, Coaching director and coach against a hostile board. The latter 2 are blue blood Eels. Arthur is talking positive - for the first time since....? Ando has been a very good refs boss, and seems to have the people skills that the job requires. Add to that a positive vibe from the players, including the new boys.

I think we have turned the corner - and killed the black dog that has been living with is since 1987.

This is the beginning of our renaissance. Lets all be positive about our future.

Or f*ck off. Simple.
 

Someone

Bench
Messages
4,964
2006 was when taylor took over, and are you forgetting 2005 and 2002 (post 2001 era).
 

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
12,075
It's one thing to be positive - I'm all for it.

It's another thing to declare that this is the return to the glory days...

We're coming off back to back spoons - I think it's fair and sensible to take a 'wait and see' approach. That's not being negative, but being positive doesn't mean we have to celebrate the coaches signings as if we've won the GF.
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
53,965
It's one thing to be positive - I'm all for it.

It's another thing to declare that this is the return to the glory days...

We're coming off back to back spoons - I think it's fair and sensible to take a 'wait and see' approach. That's not being negative, but being positive doesn't mean we have to celebrate the coaches signings as if we've won the GF.

I agree with this.
 

Bigfella

Coach
Messages
10,102
It's also one thing to declare how much more positive you are than all the other fans then go on a forty page negative rant about who is to blame for everything since 87.
 

Delboy

First Grade
Messages
8,278
Great article that puts a true perspective on what happened

Interesting thoughts on Smith, but I look forward to 2014 with an anticipation not felt since Smithy signed all those players in 2004

Go the mighties
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
79,959
Nice post LoudStrat.

I'm pumped. Hope everyone gets behind BA & DA and puts their petty grievances aside for once and for all.
 

spiderdan

Bench
Messages
3,743
Quite simply Smith was nothing better than an average coach with good game plans
nice rant but.... i would've thought that a key part of what separates a good coach from the average ones is that a good coach can identify things to make good game plans.
made to look better because he inherited a gun side, an 3 budding legends in Hindy, Cayless and Lyon.
the side he inherited finished mid table the year before he took it over, despite having dean pay, jim dymock and jason smith in it. he managed to get that side to 3rd in the regular season in his first year at the helm. unfortunately the key players were playing injured for about the last month of the comp so we bombed out to norths and a shit hot knights despite leading both those games.

and those three budding legends were identified, brought to the club (well lyon was poached from under north's noses), and developed in the systems the coach you think is average put in place for success.

despite his faults, i think smith has shown he is better than an average coach. he may not have won the big pig but there's plenty of other coaches over the last 20 years that haven't made one gf let alone four, or made the finals as many times as smith has.
 
Messages
17,273
Wow, yep it is Misty Bee.

Having said that I am sure we can look forward to a new beginning starting from this off season.
 
Top