What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Top 5 guitarists

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
Brian May has to be in there for sure.

I think theres already a thread about this. ;-)
 

Ron Jeremy

Coach
Messages
25,676
Here we go :roll:

Millwall, please explain how your top 5 are those 5, I’m very interested to hear??

Pink Floyd where one of my favourite all time bands, however I would never dream of putting Gilmour that high up, even though he was a wonderful guitarist & musician.

Eric Clapton, I’d have him in my top 20, however, I don't see what he brought to the guitar as being very prominent, a great guitarist who from what I believe started playing at 20??....so he obviously had great talent to learn & develop his guitar skills, practical & theoretical.

Jimmy Page, yeah he was a great, I’d have him in my top 5 ;-) , brought a different style to the guitar & his riffs, solo's & overall general skill influenced millions.

Jimi Hendrix, ummm, I don't know what he brought to the guitar besides over use of a wah pedal to distort his playing, a complete rip off of Chuck Berry yet for some reason gets more accolades then true musicians, struggled to play in time & his solos are just boring, out of time & just basically sounded horrible. As far as I’m concerned a great guitarist is one who actually knew the basics of the instrument as well as the complexity side of things, something Jimi's guitar playing didn't have much of.

Angus Young, maybe top 20, very good guitarist, great rhythm & sound lead work..... yep very good indeed, the only problem is we have seen many better guitarists, but I’d rate him as probably Australia's greatest.
 

SpaceMonkey

Immortal
Messages
40,570
Ron Jeremy said:
Here we go :roll:

Millwall, please explain how your top 5 are those 5, I’m very interested to hear??

Pink Floyd where one of my favourite all time bands, however I would never dream of putting Gilmour that high up, even though he was a wonderful guitarist & musician.

Eric Clapton, I’d have him in my top 20, however, I don't see what he brought to the guitar as being very prominent, a great guitarist who from what I believe started playing at 20??....so he obviously had great talent to learn & develop his guitar skills, practical & theoretical.

Jimmy Page, yeah he was a great, I’d have him in my top 5 ;-) , brought a different style to the guitar & his riffs, solo's & overall general skill influenced millions.

Jimi Hendrix, ummm, I don't know what he brought to the guitar besides over use of a wah pedal to distort his playing, a complete rip off of Chuck Berry yet for some reason gets more accolades then true musicians, struggled to play in time & his solos are just boring, out of time & just basically sounded horrible. As far as I’m concerned a great guitarist is one who actually knew the basics of the instrument as well as the complexity side of things, something Jimi's guitar playing didn't have much of.

Angus Young, maybe top 20, very good guitarist, great rhythm & sound lead work..... yep very good indeed, the only problem is we have seen many better guitarists, but I’d rate him as probably Australia's greatest.
Maybe some people's definition of "best guitarist" isn't as weighted towards technique over everything else as yours? At a guess your top 5 would include people like Malmsteen, Van Halen, Satriani and Vai, and while their all excellent guitarists technically, if you don't actually like what they produce with their instruments you're not going to rate them.
 

Evilgrowler

First Grade
Messages
6,401
Who ever can send a shiver up my spine, I rate. It's a personal preference really.

Yngwie Malmsteen.

Michael Schenker.

Gary Moore.

Ritchie Blackmore.

Mathias Jabs.
 

Quint

Juniors
Messages
1,399
Is the question' whom you believe are top 5 guitarists' or 'who popular perseption believes are the best guitarists' :?: :?:

My opinion is
Zakk Wylde
Tonny Iomi
Steve Morse
Eddie Van Halen
Andrew Webb
 

keeney

First Grade
Messages
6,640
frank zappa for sure, the man was a freak, and ron jeremy, he didnt start til he was mid 20's either
 

Anonymous

Juniors
Messages
46
Too hard to call.
My list in no particular oder
Jimi Hendrix
Stevie Ray Vaughan (Download his cover of Little Wing, most amazing piece I've ever heard)
Eric Clapton
Chuck Berry
Jimmy Page
 

miladi

Juniors
Messages
349
Any list without chet atkins in it is not taking this question seriously.

Chet Atkins
Carlos Santana
Stevie Ray Vaughan
Lester Perkins
Jimi Hendrix
 

hrundi99

First Grade
Messages
8,414
SpaceMonkey said:
people's definition of "best guitarist" isn't as weighted towards technique over everything else as yours? At a guess your top 5 would include people like Malmsteen, Van Halen, Satriani and Vai, and while their all excellent guitarists technically, if you don't actually like what they produce with their instruments you're not going to rate them.

Word!
 

Latest posts

Top