v Parra

[Freak2]

i stopped reading when i saw you gave Burt a 7

Your opinion is not worth much. I will wait on an educated response.

 

[Mayor_Quimby]

Ok - i have gone away and though about an educated response.

You're an idiot.

 

[t-ba]

Anyone who gives Barry Dawson the same rating as Glenn Stewart is immediately disqualified from giving their opinion...

 

[fish]

Brett Finch is about 5 to high other than that not bad..

 

[Dutchy]

Hey Parra fans...Manly posts get deleted in Parra forum..Its obvious you hate outsiders posting in there...Theres a match thread on NRL forum...

 

[Y2Eel]

Hey Parra fans...Manly posts get deleted in Parra forum..Its obvious you hate outsiders posting in there...Theres a match thread on NRL forum...

seems ok for you to post directly into the swamp though...:roll:

 

[Twizzle]

Hey Parra fans...Manly posts get deleted in Parra forum..Its obvious you hate outsiders posting in there...Theres a match thread on NRL forum...

As you know they dont get deleted, you've only been told about half a dozen times but doesn't seem to sink in.

Its the biggest team forum here at LU and we get the most trolls so some get moved to the troll thread (The Swamp) to avoid disrupting and hijacking of threads created by Eels members.

 

[eagle rock]

to be honest i cant say i have watched alot of manly games, the ones i have watched chris hicks really has not stood out, eric grothe did last week and thats why i picked him, as for marsh and balin i was leaning towards even because both are good players, however i just think pj just gets him, not alot in it though

I was enjoying the banter until this post!.....get off the drugs!
! Hicks is on fire, and has been all year, with or without the jesus beard.
The only bloke I rate in the Eels side is Luke Burt. I've seen him do some pretty handy things this year, and of course Hindmarsh. After that it's a miss-match of huge proportions.

 

[big boppa eel]

Hey Parra fans...Manly posts get deleted in Parra forum..Its obvious you hate outsiders posting in there...Theres a match thread on NRL forum...

OFF!!!

Boo hoo

 

[Dutchy]

rightio..i'll just pop by and post ludacris bullsh*t all over your forum

 

[Dutchy]

Eela is the only one pf you tha posts things that actually relate to football.. the rest is all manly hating garbage

 

[Freak2]

I was enjoying the banter until this post!.....get off the drugs!
! Hicks is on fire, and has been all year, with or without the jesus beard.
The only bloke I rate in the Eels side is Luke Burt. I've seen him do some pretty handy things this year, and of course Hindmarsh. After that it's a miss-match of huge proportions.

Totally agree Chris Hicks has been "Over-Achieving"

For us I would suggest Cayless is in career best form as is Wagon.

 

[willvillain]

Let's look at class and rating players.

Seriously on form Manly win hands down. They are IMO over achieving and on top of the table.

Class
1 Luke BURT (7) v Brett Stewart (8)
2 Jarryd HAYNE (8.5) v Michael Robertson (6.5)
3 Ben SMITH (7) v Steve Bell (8.5)
4 Krisnan INU (8.5) v Jamie Lyon (9)
5 Eric GROTHE (8.5) v Chris Hicks (7)
6 Brett FINCH (8) v Michael Monaghan (7.5)
7 Tim SMITH (7) v Matt Orford (8.5)
8 Nathan CAYLESS (9) v Jason King (7)
9 PJ MARSH (8) v Matt Balin (7.5)
10 Aaron CANNINGS (6.5) v Brent Kite (9)
11 Nathan HINDMARSH (10) v Anthony Watmough (8.5)
12 Ian HINDMARSH (7.5) v Glenn Stewart (7)
13 Daniel WAGON (8) v Luke Williamson (7)
14 Blake GREEN (7) v Travis Burns (7)
15 Josh CORDOBA (7) v Glenn Hall (7)
16 Zeb TAIA (6) v George Rose (7.5)
17 Feleti MATEO (8) v Mark Bryant (6.5)

Parra = 131.5

Manly = 129.0

I have based on ratings on time in 1st grade / rep honours / finals appearances + potential.

I think the home ground advantage would be worth at least 3-5 points as well. I also believe Travis Burn / Glenn Stewart, and both the Manly wingers have had exceptional starts to the season and are currently playing much better than their current class ratings.

So all things considered I would suggest this one is going to be pretty close.

This post is hilarious. Finch 8? Hindmarsh perfect? Wagon a f*cking 8!! Mateo an 8! Inu an 8.5! The guys played like 5 games....

You fair dinkum have no idea.

 

[Harold Bishop]

Freak no offense but you are a bloody goose.
Hicks is a better all round Winger then Grothe.
How did you rate Finch above Monas and I.Hindmarsh above G.Stewart?

 

[Y2Eel]

Glenn Stewert needs to grow back the beard was crap last night.. he's a good player...

 

[Manly fLIP]

Parramatta is a better team than they are given credit for.

Thats why I think its was a big win for us last night.

Glen Stewarts just a bit tired I reckon. How many blokes can tear it up for 9 weeks straight? He was bound to have a quiet game somewhere along the line.