What Brother is the better player?

[Harold Bishop]

What brother do you think is overall the better player?
Anthony Minichello vs Michael Minichello
Michael Monoghan vs Joel Monoghan
Chris Walker vs Shane Walker vs Ben Walker
Kurt Gidley vs Matt Gidley
Ian Hindmarsh vs Nathan Hindmarsh
Jason Cayless vs Nathan Cayless
Glenn Stewart vs Brett Stewart
Henry Perenara vs Marcus Perenara
Adam Macdougall vs Luke Macdougall
Barry Berrigan vs Shaun Berrigan
Vinnie Anderson vs Louis Anderson
Frank Puletua vs Tony Puletua
Michael Witt vs Steve Witt

 

[Mr Saab]

anthony mini
Michael monas
no walker is a good walker
kurt gids
nathan hindmarsh
nathan cayless
brett stewart
henry perenara
luke macdougs
shaun berrigan
vinnie anderson
tony puletua
michael witt

 

[wittyfan]

Anthony Minichello
Joel Monoghan
Shane Walker
Matt Gidley
Nathan Hindmarsh
Nathan Cayless
Brett Stewart
Henry Perenara
Luke Macdougall
Shaun Berrigan
Vinnie Anderson
Frank Puletua
Michael Witt

 

[The Colonel]

Anthony Minichello vs Michael Minichello
Michael Monoghan vs Joel Monoghan
Chris Walker vs Shane Walker vs Ben Walker
Kurt Gidley vs Matt Gidley
Ian Hindmarsh vs Nathan Hindmarsh
Jason Cayless vs Nathan Cayless
Glenn Stewart vs Brett Stewart
Henry Perenara vs Marcus Perenara
Adam Macdougall vs Luke Macdougall
Barry Berrigan vs Shaun Berrigan
Vinnie Anderson vs Louis Anderson
Frank Puletua vs Tony Puletua
Michael Witt vs Steve Witt

Anthony
Michael
Kurt
Nathan
Nathan when fit
Brett
Marcus
Adam
Shaun
Tie
Tony
Tie

 

[gregstar]

why did you choose michael witt sullyfan? :lol:

 

[stubbsie]

Anthony Minichello
Joel Monoghan
Ben Walker
Kurt Gidley
Nathan Hindmarsh
Nathan Cayless
Brett Stewart
Henry Perenara
Adam Macdougall
Shaun Berrigan
Vinnie Anderson
Tony Puletua
Steve Witt

 

[choisir]

Which one has the best sister?

 

[Raider_69]

Anthony
icheal Monaghan
Shane Walker
Kurt Giddley
Nathen Hindmarsh
Nathen Cayless
Brent Stewart
Henry Perenara
Adam McDougall
Shawn Berrigan
Vinnie Anderson
Tony Puletua
Michael Witt

 

[SpaceMonkey]

Anthony Minichello vs Michael Minichello Anthony
Michael Monoghan vs Joel Monoghan undecided
Chris Walker vs Shane Walker vs Ben Walker Shane, the others are crap
Kurt Gidley vs Matt Gidley tie
Ian Hindmarsh vs Nathan Hindmarsh Nathan by a mile
Jason Cayless vs Nathan Cayless Jason (at least in the last 2 seasons)
Glenn Stewart vs Brett Stewart Brett
Henry Perenara vs Marcus Perenara Henry, although Marcus has potential
Adam Macdougall vs Luke Macdougall Adam
Barry Berrigan vs Shaun Berrigan Shaun
Vinnie Anderson vs Louis Anderson tie
Frank Puletua vs Tony Puletua Tony by the length of the straight
Michael Witt vs Steve Witt Michael

 

[SpaceMonkey]

Anthony Minichello
Frank Puletua

Sully obviously has a thing for bald men, I can't think of any other reason you could claim Frank was a better player than Tony.

 

[wittyfan]

Anthony Minichello
Frank Puletua

Sully obviously has a thing for bald men, I can't think of any other reason you could claim Frank was a better player than Tony.

I like my men to have hair!

 

[wittyfan]

why did you choose michael witt sullyfan? :lol:

Well, he's better than his brother in more ways than one. :lol:

 

[SpaceMonkey]

Anthony Minichello
Frank Puletua

Sully obviously has a thing for bald men, I can't think of any other reason you could claim Frank was a better player than Tony.

I like my men to have hair!

Really? I never took you for a North Sydney fan.... :lol:

 

[wittyfan]

Anthony Minichello
Frank Puletua

Sully obviously has a thing for bald men, I can't think of any other reason you could claim Frank was a better player than Tony.

I like my men to have hair!

Really? I never took you for a North Sydney fan.... :lol:

:lol: You know what I mean. ;-)

 

[SpaceMonkey]

I'va always thought the North Sydney Bears would make a great mardi gras float....

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Anthony Minichello
Michael Monoghan
Chris Walker
Kurt Gidley
Nathan Hindmarsh
Nathan Cayless
Brett Stewart
Marcus Perenara
Adam Macdougall
Shaun Berrigan
Vinnie Anderson
Tony Puletua
Michael Witt

 

[Chippo Raiders]

why has everyone chose Nathan Cayless....his form dropped of in 02 then has been injured a lot since...whilst Jason has been strong at all levels.....i go Jason Cayless but everyone else seems fine

 

[Hurriflatch]

Anthony Minichello vs Michael Minichello - Anthony
Michael Monoghan vs Joel Monoghan - Joel
Chris Walker vs Shane Walker vs Ben Walker - None all crap
Kurt Gidley vs Matt Gidley - Kurt
Ian Hindmarsh vs Nathan Hindmarsh - Nathan
Jason Cayless vs Nathan Cayless - When both in best form Nathan, currently Jason
Glenn Stewart vs Brett Stewart - Brett
Henry Perenara vs Marcus Perenara - Marcus (om potential) currently Henry
Adam Macdougall vs Luke Macdougall - Luke he is good minus drugs
Barry Berrigan vs Shaun Berrigan - Shuan even tho he isn't that good himself
Vinnie Anderson vs Louis Anderson - Undecided
Frank Puletua vs Tony Puletua - Tony
Michael Witt vs Steve Witt - See Walker.

 

[Sir Clifford GC]

What brother do you think is overall the better player?
Anthony Minichello vs Michael Minichello - Telstra is better by a long way
Michael Monoghan vs Joel Monoghan - Mick id like to think he would push for a bench spot in at least country this year
Chris Walker vs Shane Walker vs Ben Walker - all duds sorry Ben just because he can kick goals
Kurt Gidley vs Matt Gidley -- Kurt he can tackle
Ian Hindmarsh vs Nathan Hindmarsh -- Both very good but Buttcrack is a freak of a player
Jason Cayless vs Nathan Cayless - Jason , nathan is overrated
Glenn Stewart vs Brett Stewart - Brett atm but glenn is very very good watch him
Henry Perenara vs Marcus Perenara not sure havent seen enough
Adam Macdougall vs Luke Macdougall - Mad Dog hes a low merkin but if hes fit hes still one of the best
Barry Berrigan vs Shaun Berrigan - shaun
Vinnie Anderson vs Louis Anderson - Vinnie just and to think he was almost a seaeagle
Frank Puletua vs Tony Puletua - tony by a long way
Michael Witt vs Steve Witt - Mick for sure

 

[Dragon Fanatic]

What brother do you think is overall the better player?
Anthony Minichello vs Michael Minichello
Michael Monoghan vs Joel Monoghan
Chris Walker vs Shane Walker vs Ben Walker
Kurt Gidley vs Matt Gidley
Ian Hindmarsh vs Nathan Hindmarsh
Jason Cayless vs Nathan Cayless
Glenn Stewart vs Brett Stewart
Henry Perenara vs Marcus Perenara
Adam Macdougall vs Luke Macdougall
Barry Berrigan vs Shaun Berrigan
Vinnie Anderson vs Louis Anderson
Frank Puletua vs Tony Puletua
Michael Witt vs Steve Witt

Anthony Minnichello (And his brothers name is Mark not michael)
Even, but probably Joel Monaghan at a pinch
All the Walkers are shit but Shane
Matt Gidley
Nathan Hindmarsh
Nathan Cayless
Brett Stewart
Henry Perenara
Adam Macdougall
Shaun Berrigan
Vinnie Anderson
Tony Puletua
Michael Witt