When Bani recovers from his injury...

[Harold Bishop]

Does he come back into the side?

Williams who is scoring a try a game at the moment and can break plenty of tackles ALA Chris Hicks.

Or Robbo who has been a rock in the backline for the last 3 years, is faultless under the highball, great defender and is at the top of the list for NRL tries scored.

Or does he play PL, and cover for injuries?

 

[gong_eagle]

real tough question that one, Des has a huge choice coming up

 

[icewind]

im sure he'll make the right decision. i mean look at his decisions as regards to 5/8

 

[CC_Eagle]

Bottom line : Robbo must stay.

 

[swoop]

Williams will stay in the team provided his form stays good.

 

[Jatz Crackers]

Very close between the two of them, but Des sticks by the incumbant unless poor form warrants it. Bani to retain his spot.

 

[Dutchy]

Bani > PL

 

[MSIH]

Williams has been great. However, Williams - PL

 

[Dave Q]

Bani is a gun.

 

[zombie jesus]

Bani back in first grade.

Williams is great but Bani seems a bit more dangerous and able to do something himself. Williams has a long career ahead of him though, hope we hang on to him long term.

 

[cb4]

bani to premiere league
williams is a gun

 

[Maroon and White]

Williams has not put a foot wrong and would be hard done by to be dropped. I wish that we had an embarrassment of riches at five-eighth instead of on the wing!!!

 

[jimmythehand]

from an outsiders point of view i've never really rated Bani too highly. I like the look of Williams more.

 

[Stizyler]

Manly has a nice dilemma on their hands really don't they, especially with the signing of Tony Williams for next season, very good depth in the backline now.

 

[RainMan]

Williams will be used in the backrow for Manly next year.

 

[zombie jesus]

We will see him in the backs at some point, Matai won't play a whole season.