Who are the biggest underachieving and overrated players in the NRL?

[Albert Rosenfeld]

Victor Radley had a quiet game against Brisbane. But he is still the gun young player in the NRL.

 

[tumbidragon]

Euan Aitken.
Talked up by many pundits as a potential bolter for Origin last year. Yet has no spatial awareness, defensively geniused and has no idea that centres can indeed set up their wingers...
Only ace in his game is hard running.

 

[Exsilium]

Overrated: Most of the Penrith Panthers.

 

[Someguy]

Euan Aitken.
Talked up by many pundits as a potential bolter for Origin last year. Yet has no spatial awareness, defensively geniused and has no idea that centres can indeed set up their wingers...
Only ace in his game is hard running.

Was only talked up by people looking at his SC scores

 

[yobbo84]

Victor Radley had a quiet game against Brisbane. But he is still the gun young player in the NRL.

Poor man's Cam Murray.

 

[bull rider]

Was only talked up by people looking at his SC scores

He absolutely burnt GI early last year which added to the hype.

 

[JB04]

Moses Mbye

/thread

 

[mozza91]

Moses Mbye

/thread

Somebody rates Mbye?

 

[JB04]

Somebody rates Mbye?

Michael Maguire, apparently. So much so he made him captain!

 

[Perth Red]

Jake Granville, he looks a shadow of his former self. And yet he is still being talked up for an origin spot!

 

[Someguy]

Jake Granville, he looks a shadow of his former self. And yet he is still being talked up for an origin spot!

But seriously who else Mahoney? Hunt? Segeyaro? Turpin?

 

[Perth Red]

But seriously who else Mahoney? Hunt? Segeyaro? Turpin?

yeh the q'land hooking stocks are low at the moment.

 

[Someguy]

yeh the q'land hooking stocks are low at the moment.

If they had a surplus of halves I reckon Munster would make a decent hooker

 

[Albert Rosenfeld]

But seriously who else Mahoney? Hunt? Segeyaro? Turpin?

Segeyaro is from PNG.

 

[firechild]

Jake Granville, he looks a shadow of his former self. And yet he is still being talked up for an origin spot!

I like that this is where QLD origin is sitting at the moment.

 

[Someguy]

Segeyaro is from PNG.

Your understanding of eligibility criteria is limited I see

 

[Captain Apollo]

Segeyaro is from PNG.

That's in Qld (also it didn't stop Adrian Lam)

 

[veggiepatch1959]

If they had a surplus of halves I reckon Munster would make a decent hooker

Nah....

He wouldn't get ONE client.....