Who is the most over rated player in NRL?

[Pazza]

Team of tossers

1.O'Davis (c)
2.Walker
3.Hodges
4.Tate
5.Tahu
6.Anasta
7.Kimmorley
8.Perry
9.Marsh
10.Mason
11.Tallis
12.Morley
13.Ricketson

14.Berrigan
15.Crocker
16.Howe
17.Beattie

Coach: Ricky Stuart
Assistant Coach: Andrew Gee

 

[Parraren]

Pazza you forgot Phil Bailey and I'd have Woolford ahead of Marsh.

 

[Pazza]

Oh damn, i hate Phil Bailey! He is so crap, i cant believe he is in the rep teams.

Nathan Hindmarsh for AUS and NSW #11

 

[hh]

LOL I can't believe some of the names that have been mentioned above......
Just because you have a disliking towards a player doesn't mean they are over-rated!!!!!!
Christ!!! I hate Tallis but I'd have him in my side anyday!!!!
As for Barrett..... He has had an injury prone last couple of seasons, but do we not remember what he is capable of when in form?????

 

[GoParra]

So what's your thoughts on Anasta HH ?

 

[hh]

I have mixed thoughts about him. I guess it depends who he plays with.
Ive seen him play some amazing footy, killer side step and handy with the boot.
When he first came onto the scene I saw a simliar game to fittlers in him......

 

[Y2Eel]

most over rated would be hodges crocker and soon to be added to that list will be sunny bill williams YEHaaaaaa :alcho:

 

[Parra_Boy]

I'd say Anasta, Barrett, Gidely, Hodges, Walker, Mason, Slater and Kimmorley.

 

[noosa-eel]

Fittler or Mason......take your pick :blahb:

 

[Iafeta]

How anyone could label PJ Marsh a tosser - I don't know. He's an absolute legend of a bloke. I think my fiance` liked him more than she liked me :roll: but a nice bloke as well.

Tosser, me thinks not.

 

[Chipmunk]

Team of tossers

1.O'Davis (c)
2.Walker
3.Hodges
4.Tate
5.Tahu
6.Anasta
7.Kimmorley
8.Perry
9.Marsh
10.Mason
11.Tallis
12.Morley
13.Ricketson

14.Berrigan
15.Crocker
16.Howe
17.Beattie

Coach: Ricky Stuart
Assistant Coach: Andrew Gee

That team would absolutely blow the current Parramatta team into oblivian!

 

[Chipmunk]

To me, this is not a topic that Parramatta Supporters should make alot of comments on. I think the saying "Those in Glass Houses Shouldnt Throw Stones" is pretty apt Statement in this instance.

 

[Parraren]

That team would absolutely blow the current Parramatta team into oblivian!

Would blow alot of teams into oblivion. Just about every player has played for their Country and the rest have all played Origin. You'd have a hard time keeping this side under the cap and an even more difficult task keeping their ego's intact.

 

[whoateallthepies]

Vella - No work rate or venom in his runs.
Kativerata - I have absolutely no confidence in him.
Mason - See Vella.
Johns - Not the best in the world, no even in my top 3 of Webcke, Lockyer and Gower.

 

[Et#1_supporter]

If u think Kimmorley is overrated ure a F*ckin joke.

He carries the sharks team. Watcha cronulla game closely and u will see not only the skill of kimmorley, but how much more he puts into the game than the anybody else. Watch who th eonly player chasing down steven price was after he did the charge down against cronulla

Remeber kimmorley at Melbourne, overrated my ass. He deserves the NSW and Australian halfback spot, gower could play off the bench or at 5/8

 

[Moggles]

Mick Vella and Willie Mason.
Probably more so Mason than Vella.. Everyone knows Vella has lost it, but heaps of people think Willie Mason is still a good footballer..

All Mason has to do is try and run harder, he would absolutley devistate defence if he tried harder..

One person he should learn off is Shane Webke.

 

[The Colonel]

I'll give Willie this much. The game on Friday night he was playing with a point to prove. Easily the best game I have ever seen him play. Even though his side was behind on the score board he still carted the ball back hard every time. I wouldn't normally give him good wraps however if he was able to play like that each week and not carry any excess personal baggage I'd be happy to have him at the Eels.

I don't think he can on either account so I doubt he will be playing for the Eels anytime soon but when he wants to play I think he can.

 

[Moggles]

I totally agree.. Everyone knows he can play if he put his mind to it.
But you can just see him go through the motions when he runs the ball up.

 

[GoParra]

i hope adam dykes dies a slow, painful death

Anyone sense a little bitterness here :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[Parraren]

i hope adam dykes dies a slow, painful death

Anyone sense a little bitterness here :lol: :lol: :lol:

I reckon just a tad :shock: Build a bridge, get some counselling, move on...