Who would win new or old

[sallymay]

Who would win between a team a former storm players all who have played in our grand final appearences and a team of current ones


Steve Turner 1 Billy Slater
Matt Geyer 2 Dane Nielson
Matt King 3 Greg Inglis
Israel Folau 4 (Chase Stanley)
Will Chambers 5 Anthony Quinn
Scott Hill 6 Brett Finch
Russell Atkin 7 Cooper Cronk
Antonio Kafusi 8 Adam Blair
Nathan Friend 9 Cam Smith
Jeremy Smith 10 Brett Smith
Clint Newton 11 Sika Manu
(Wirangi Koopu)12 Ryan Hoffman
Dallas Johnson 13 Adian Tolman
Ben Cross 14 Jeff Lima
Michael Crocker 15 (Todd Lowerie)
Scott Anderson 16 Ryan Tandy
David Kidwell 17 Ryan Hinchcliffe

() chase hasnt played in a final.....wirangi was 18th man for the final and todd was in the final for the eels


So who would win

 

[Noa]

New team would give the x-playes a bath.

 

[kia ora storm]

Inglis v King would be interesting...new team would win easily.

 

[storm_man]

Sorry I changed the teams slightly, bold players are who I think would win against each other.

Steve Turner 1 Billy Slater
Matt Geyer 2 Dane Nielson
Matt King 3 Greg Inglis
Israel Folau 4 Chase Stanley
Will Chambers 5 Anthony Quinn (on recent form...)
Scott Hill 6 Brett Finch (not sure tbh...)
James Aubusson 7 Cooper Cronk
Ben Cross 8 Aiden Tolman (not sure...)
Nathan Friend 9 Cameron Smith
Antonio Kaufusi 10 Brett White (again not sure, probably White)
Clint Newton 11 Sika Manu (" ")
Jeremy Smith 12 Ryan Hoffman (could go either way)
Dallas Johnson 13 Adam Blair (could go either way)
Russell Aitken 14 Ryan Hinchcliffe
Wairangi Koopu 15 Todd Lowrie (not sure, probably Lowrie)
Michael Crocker 16 Kevin Proctor
Matt Cross 17 Ryan Tandy (not sure)

Lol I'm not sure about a lot of those players. Its hard to compare them

 

[Dan70]

1. Turner--------1. Slater
2. Geyer--------2. Neilson
3. King----------3. Inglis
4. Chambers-----4. Stanley
5. Folau---------5. Quinn
6. Hill-----------6. Finch
7. Kimmorley-----7. Cronk
8. Kaufusi-------8. Tolman
9. Friend--------9. C. Smith
10. B. Cross----10. White
11. Crocker-----11. Blair
12. J. Smith-----12. Hoffman
13. Johnson-----13. Lowrie

14. Aubusson----14. Hinchcliffe
15. Newton------15. Manu
16. M. Cross-----16. Lima
17. S. Anderson--17. Tandy

Very even starting sides, but the 1,6,7,9 of the current side gives them the points. The bench is where our current side smashes the oldboys though imo.

And I can't believe no one else has picked Kimmorley!

 

[storm_man]

I dont think it counts 1999 otherwise there would have been Bai, Swain, Moule, Ross etc.

 

[Dan70]

I dont think it counts 1999 otherwise there would have been Bai, Swain, Moule, Ross etc.

Except Kimmorley is still playing in the NRL.

 

[little_aza]

Sorry I changed the teams slightly, bold players are who I think would win against each other.

Steve Turner 1 Billy Slater
Matt Geyer 2 Dane Nielson
Matt King 3 Greg Inglis
Israel Folau 4 Chase Stanley
Will Chambers 5 Anthony Quinn (on recent form...)
Scott Hill 6 Brett Finch (not sure tbh...)
James Aubusson 7 Cooper Cronk
Ben Cross 8 Aiden Tolman (not sure...)
Nathan Friend 9 Cameron Smith
Antonio Kaufusi 10 Brett White (again not sure, probably White)
Clint Newton 11 Sika Manu (" ")
Jeremy Smith 12 Ryan Hoffman (could go either way)
Dallas Johnson 13 Adam Blair (could go either way)
Russell Aitken 14 Ryan Hinchcliffe
Wairangi Koopu 15 Todd Lowrie (not sure, probably Lowrie)
Michael Crocker 16 Kevin Proctor
Matt Cross 17 Ryan Tandy (not sure)

Lol I'm not sure about a lot of those players. Its hard to compare them

SIKS >>>>>>>>>>>> newton
SIKS >>>>>>>>>>>> arguably every other forward in the world, except blair lol

 

[Noa]

As good as Adam is Sika is probably better.

Can play prop better then Adam can as well as cause havoc out wide as well. His defence is probably a bit better as well though Adam has the edge in skill and agility.