Who Would Win?

[Tommy Smith]

Fullback
Advantage Team A

Wingers
Equal

Centres
Advantage Team B

Halves
Advantage Team A

Hooker
Advantage Team A

Props
Advantage Team B

Second Row
Equal

Bench
Advantage Team B


In summary, very even.

Inglis, the Burgess boys and our superior Halves would prove the difference.

LOL and LOL.

What a 'tard.

 

[some11]

Depends who the coaches are.

 

[Jobdog]

Team 2 easily.

 

[Different kind of Rabbit]

Would be better if Team A was made up of a few Souths players + players whose names were being thrown around for Origin / discards / don't want to play-

Team C:

Inglis

Merritt
Lyon
Idris
Taufua

Carney
Reynolds

Asotasi
Luke
Grant
McQueen
Te'o
S.Burgess

G.Burgess
Mason
Woods
Sutton

Now that would be a good match imo. Much stronger backline and bench.

 

[The Elephant In The room]

Team 2 has better halves, better forwards, better backs and Kurt Gidley. They win by 27

And if they didn't have Kurt Gidley they'd win by 50?

 

[Jobdog]

Isn't Isaac Luke a Kiwi, so therefore he's ineligible for a start?

 

[BranVan3000]

Why does this thread even exist?

 

[the dude]

LOL and LOL.

What a 'tard.

farrah better than luke? :lol:

 

[BranVan3000]

farrah better than luke? :lol:

Farah has a better kicking game, better passing. Luke has better scoots and more of an x-factor.

I'd say that comparison is a wash.

 

[YoungPanther]

Maybe they could play for a trophy like say a "Charity Shield".

Would have to be Team A.

 

[Ziggy the God]

Team 2.

Good try Bumble.

 

[MrAnonymous]

Team A:

Inglis

Merritt
Walker
Champion
Goodwin

Sutton
Reynolds

Asotasi
Luke
Lima
McQueen
Te'o
S.Burgess

G.Burgess
Tyrrell
Clark
Peats

---

Team 2

Hayne

B.Morris
J.Morris
Jennings
Ferguson

Maloney
Pearce

Tamou
Farah
Gallen
Lewis
Hoffman
Bird

Fifita
Gidley
Watmough
Merrin


---

I think Team 1 has a far stronger spine and a better forward pack. Team 2 has better centres and interchange. Wingers are all decent, Merritt the best of the four though.

Would be a close one but I reckon Team 1 would take it by 6-8 points.

Discuss.

 

[andrew057]

I understand Bumble trolling, but Souffs fans saying Luke is better than Farah? :lol:

 

[Tommy Smith]

I understand Bumble trolling, but Souffs fans saying Luke is better than Farah? :lol:

Yeah they're a special bunch.

 

[Jason Maher]

Poor souffs fans. Why won't the nasty old NSW selectors pick their shit players?

 

[Allstar Knights]

Wingers
Equal

:lol::lol::lol:

 

[Bumble]

I understand Bumble trolling, but Souffs fans saying Luke is better than Farah? :lol:

I'm shocked it took 3 pages to realize this btw.

But jokes aside, for the way we play, with so many playmakers already in the side, Luke suits us better than Farah would -with his acceleration and tackle breaking that Farah doesn't have, at least as much.

In a team I was starting from scratch, Farah would get the nod though.

 

[Bumble]

Poor souffs fans. Why won't the nasty old NSW selectors pick their shit players?

They picked your shit players for years, tbf

 

[BranVan3000]

I understand Bumble trolling, but Souffs fans saying Luke is better than Farah? :lol:

Luke was rated 3rd in the competition last year in CVR rankings.

Though I will admit Farah has gone up a whole new gear since midway through last year

 

[English Rose]

Bump - Couldn't beat a team that has Pommeroy in it!