would we want sonny bill

[Father Ted]

Do we want Sonny bill even if available at a reasonable price

 

[Father Ted]

And before anyone starts it's only a bit of fun

 

[gypsy]

I like the 'only if cheap' option. It is Money Bill we're talking about here

 

[R&WTILLIDIE]

As a player..hell yes

But all the baggage and bullshit he would bring...no

 

[Hoekstra]

He would come with more baggage than Imelda Marcos. The Storm or Manly would be more fitting for the villain type role he would play on his return.

I don't understand why someone like David Gyngell would be crawling up his backside either. It makes me hate channel 9 even more than I already did.

 

[Inspector Gadget]

After 3 years in Rugby Union playing outside center and getting tackled twice a game, he would be injury free and fairly fresh you would imagine. So yep you would be mad not to snap him up. Great player when on his his game, draws three to four defenders every time he has the ball. the Bullcheats have never recovered from losing him.

 

[stg666]

billy big head, no f...ing way. i would rather have pat jarvis back.

 

[TheRev]

Cant see him coming cheap, its not like we would have any emotional pull over him.

But id love a year out of him if he was.. but I wouldn't pay top dollar for him.

 

[The Nick]

Once the Roosters express interest in a player, the other clubs have no chance of landing him.

But hyperthetically speaking, I would be happy to sign him to a heavily back-ended deal... On the proviso that he retires a couple of years into the contract.

In all honestly, with the exception of Big Dell, I haven't been overly impressed with a single player that's come back from Union. That boring game seems to blunt their skills.

I think the biggest impact SBW will have on Rugby League in 2013 is slightly inflated crowds and TV ratings for his first few games, and then the Roosters fans will crawl back into the woodwork when he fails to live up to the hype.

 

[Slippery Morris]

He would be an awesome buy for the club but one I can't see happening. I have never seen a player have so much impact in a game. When he is on the team wins. Simple. When he is not on, the team struggles. A freakish player.

As for baggage? I don't think so. His previous club treated him like rubbish and there is only so much he can take until he had enough. Especially making him go out public and tell the media he had a drinking problem which he clearly doesn't.

He would be brilliant at the Saints.

 

[The Nick]

He would be an awesome buy for the club but one I can't see happening. I have never seen a player have so much impact in a game. When he is on the team wins. Simple. When he is not on, the team struggles. A freakish player.

Last time I checked, the Bulldogs weren't doing so hot during his last run of games in Rugby League.

 

[Bring back choc]

Yes of course.

 

[dangerousdave]

Wouldnt loose Scott or Creagh for him

 

[Jersey No 14]

I'm disappointed boys. This topic shouldn't have never been breached.
SBW in a Red V NOT NOW - NOT EVER
DELETE THIS THREAD!!!!!!!!

 

[RedVDave]

SBW has,

No Honour
No Integrity
and
No Loyalty

and therefore...

No thanks!

 

[Father Ted]

And yet quite a few voted Yes

 

[Mr Red]

no such thing as cheap with $BW... therefore no thanks.
he causes more damage to a clubs integrity off the field then value he adds on the field.

would rather buy a half back if we had that much cash free to spend...

 

[Lovemedragons]

I'm disappointed boys. This topic shouldn't have never been breached.
SBW in a Red V NOT NOW - NOT EVER
DELETE THIS THREAD!!!!!!!!

Agreed! SBW never in a red V please!

 

[Minh]

SBW as a footballer is a very rare talent. No other forward as destructive and talented I remember fearing him whenever we came up against the dogs. If winning is everything then a player of the caliber of SBW is right at the pointy end, talk about "X Factor" this guy has it in spades. SBW as a talent rates right up there with the likes of Bradley Clyde(just my opinion) and has the running power of a Bobby Lidner.

 

[nrlnrl]

bouncer at the Leagues Club ?