What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Would you support a Cronulla-Stgeorge-Illawarra Merger?

Cronulla-St Georgre Illawarra merger. Would you?

  • Support it?

    Votes: 10 18.9%
  • Not support it?

    Votes: 20 37.7%
  • Stop supporting any team in the NRL?

    Votes: 14 26.4%
  • Prefer we moved to the Central Coast?

    Votes: 9 17.0%

  • Total voters
    53

MightySharks

Bench
Messages
2,769
McSharkie said:
It won't happen. We would relocate before we merged with them. The new developement will see us stand alone comfortably.

You are probably right, but I would prefer they continued to play out of Toyota Park, and as we own our ground they would play some macthes there and the rest in Illawarra. If they move to the Central coast it is too far to go I would have to move there if I wanted to go every week.
 

andrew flap

Bench
Messages
4,184
Mr Angry said:
Well I know I'll be unpopular, but we should have merged with Illawarra and St.George with Souths.

.

Yeah, I thought that would work too. The horse has bolted and Illawarra for all intents and purposes, lost their team.

As for merging with the stains now, I'd rather eat my own leg.
 

grey_nurse

Juniors
Messages
9
I am pretty sure when St. George and Illawara merged that did so on the condition they would never be forced into any other merger with any clubs down the track.

So I don't think it will ever happen
 

gunnamatta bay

Referee
Messages
21,084
At least all those ex saints fans would have a home base they can be proud of for a change. Shark Park is ideally situated in the middle of the proposed area. No more unreliable train rides to Aussies, Telestra or Win Stadiums.
 

MightySharks

Bench
Messages
2,769
grey_nurse said:
I am pretty sure when St. George and Illawara merged that did so on the condition they would never be forced into any other merger with any clubs down the track.

So I don't think it will ever happen

Wests and Balmain were told that it would be a 14 team comp so they had to merge. So things have changed.
 

Mako

Juniors
Messages
1,060
Stuff that!

Build a bridge from Kurnell to La Perouse and merge Souths, Easts and Sharks in to the East Coats Sharks playing out of the now easily reached Shark Park.

Then slap a south bound toll on Tom Ugly's Bridge, the New Sharks Bridge and Alfords Point bridge with an exemption for all Shire residents - al money to the fottball team. If Stains want to go watch their team they pay or go via Tigers territory.

That way we have our team, our park and its paid for by those not fortunate enough to live here.

Hmmmm slap on a north bound toll as well - the pr!cks keep telling us they would pay to leave the Shire - let em!
 

Objective One

Juniors
Messages
433
Based on Souths continuing struggle to be competitve at the NRL level, our clever stitch up of the Newtown area from under their noses, the fact that everyone from Sydney seems to gloss over that the central coast will want their own team not some transplant, the obvious solution (should it ever become necessary) is for the Southern Sydney Sharks to be the combination. In fact, if the two clubs have any brains they would be doing just that right now. Train and road access to Toyota Park is good enough to beat the pants off atmosphereless Telstra, utilising the Redfern connection to the aboriginal community throughout NSW and Queensland to source the next generation Peaches and Preston's could be a master stroke in the same way that Essendon came to own that source of talent in AFL. It would be the Sharks because, let's face it, being a Rabittoh is about as threatening as being the Canterbury Berries, but in genuine deferrence to the great tradition of South Sydney, the guaranteed permanent away jumper is the red & green hoops but with a white Shark logo. I'd even roll over to the name being South Sydney Sharks if that's what it took. Also confirms the reality that the St. George area really supplies nothing to the Stains other than history and the merged team really owns all of southern Sydney because, let's face it, only soccer is played in the St George (as opposed to Bulldog) area these days. With the rapidly changing demographic of the South Sydney area given the apartment boom around Botany there is some real connection with the apartment/cafe side of the Shire represented by Cronulla.

Then we can leave South Coast United to continue alone in their rich 6 1/2 year old tradition of massive underachievement in the Gong and back at Okie Dokie Artichokie Stadium whenever the fans fancy a fresh Kebabs or some good Schezuan at Hurstville after a game.
 

gunnamatta bay

Referee
Messages
21,084
One thing I noticed in regard to the merger is the disdain the Kogarah mob have for the Illawarra mob. They really think they are a class above.
 

Latest posts

Top