You know what I hate

[SpaceMonkey]

What about Comfortably Numb or Imagine then?

Okay, better examples this time. I don't really mind Bohemian Rhapsody either, it's more just Robert Plant who shits me to tears. The resat of Zepplin were all amazingly talented by Plant was such a pretentious wanker.

 

[SpaceMonkey]

What about Comfortably Numb or Imagine then?

Okay, better examples this time. I don't really mind Bohemian Rhapsody either, it's more just Robert Plant who shits me to tears. The resat of Zepplin were all amazingly talented but Plant was such a pretentious wanker.

 

[Anonymous]

When post-modernism and music collide. Woo! Everyone is right.

 

[Alex28]

i have only seen them live once (bdo sydney 2003) but they were absolutely woeful. dave's rediculously out of place guitar solos and perry's wine swilling was not worth watching. circus at the back was interesting though.

 

[Evilgrowler]

I think you've missed the point of the original poster Ron.

 

[millersnose]

I agree. I think millersnose falls into this category too.

oh thats right

i am a nobody and cannot therefor have a valid opinion


you know what i hate

fan clubs and groupies who cannot stand criticism of their heroes


i think i will grow my hair long again and just say all bands are cool

even the ones that sound farging awful :lol:

 

[Dean Moriarty]

Good fishing, El Garbo!

 

[millersnose]

why dean

i kept it under 7 lines

that means i wasnt baited

 

[Samwise]

Ron you're comparing crap songs with great songs. The comparison i was making was to say who is the greater artist? lets say the Chili peppers are playing a concert, Frucianti misses a fret on stage, but he is the one who actually wrote the music, or the weeny in the crowd who has downloaded the music and can play it flawlessly, nevermind he can't actually create anything original?

Millers I can take criticism of my heros, but is at a concert really the place to do it?
But yes i do believe you fall into this category, you're defence as to why Hendrix is crap is that you can play all his songs too. The big question is can you write a piece of original music that is as good?

 

[millersnose]

But yes i do believe you fall into this category, you're defence as to why Hendrix is crap is that you can play all his songs too. The big question is can you write a piece of original music that is as good?

i dont remember saying "hendrix was crap"

i remember saying he is overated and certainly nowhere near the "greatest guitarest ever" status some attribute to him

12 bar bues and blues riffs are not incredibly hard to write

 

[fat_mike]

i used to idolise hendrix as a young lad. but as i have grown and learnt more about the instrument myself i realise his wasnt as good as i first thought. that not taking anything away from jimi because he has his place in rock history. he was a gopod guitarist but it also sounded like he was a sloppy guitarist. who knows this might have attributed to why i love the guy on the guitar.