Magic or foz

[baby faced assassin]

Johnson and foran both off contract at the warriors.
If you could sign one to your club which one would it be and why?

 

[TheVelourFog]

Which one is which

 

[Tommy Smith]

The one without the chronic hamstring problems. Or the gambling problems. Or a history of dogging his team and leaving mid year.

 

[The_Shield]

Yep I'd take Johnson. When he's on his game, there is nobody better to watch

 

[Fufu Andronez]

Really hoping we can keep both. They really complement each other and have the potential to be a great pairing

 

[baby faced assassin]

Which one is which

Johnson is the Asian guy and foran the skinhead

 

[Spot On]

The one without the chronic hamstring problems. Or the gambling problems. Or a history of dogging his team and leaving mid year.

Yeah, when you put it like that it's a no brainer.

IF none of those existed in Foran's life then Johnson would not get a look in imo. Johnson is a touch player, Foran is a footballer.

 

[Perth Red]

Forans a better player but Johnson is better bet to deliver longer term.

Keeping the two together, and Foran keeping his sht together, would be something special to see and would catapult kiwis on the international stage.

Come on nrl give the warriors a cap exemption

 

[Life's Good]

Would be happy with either. Both have carried plenty of baggage. Foran all the off field stuff including a friendship with Buzzzzzzzzz & SJ the Warriors.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Depends who the other half is.

If you've got a Milford then Foran is the best bet, if you've got a Pearce then SJ is the one to go for.

 

[Charlie124]

Id take Johnson in a heartbeat. Johnson/Morgan halves combo working behind a good pack under a great coach would see him shine (more consistently than he currently does)

 

[Hawkins]

I'd take Johnson, I think most clubs could find a bookie pretty easily so what use is Foran?

 

[muzby]

Johnson and foran both off contract at the warriors.
If you could sign one to your club which one would it be and why?

for the club i support or the club i play for?

 

[Jason Maher]

If we hadn't just forked out big money for Ben Hunt, I'd take Johnson.

 

[POPEYE]

As long as Johnson stays away from Melbourne I don't give a shit who takes him

 

[JD359]

I'd take Foran for his consistency (obv before las' yr & all the BS that came with him). He's a competitor (not saying SJ isn't) even when the rest of his team are struggling or not putting in. SJ seems to have trouble doing that when the chips are down in the same situation. You couldn't go wrong with either honestly...

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Foran's the best 5/8 in the comp, so I'd probably take him under normal circumstances. But considering we have a top notch 5/8 in Austin, I'd take Johnson currently.

 

[NrlVader]

I'll take Foz.

Apart from being arguably the best player in the NRL, then there are the freebies at his mate's brothel for the team.

 

[Nice Beaver]

I'd take Foran for his consistency (obv before las' yr & all the BS that came with him). He's a competitor (not saying SJ isn't) even when the rest of his team are struggling or not putting in. SJ seems to have trouble doing that when the chips are down in the same situation. You couldn't go wrong with either honestly...

You obviusly didn't see Foran's performances for Manly in his last 12 months.

 

[BM1979]

At the Dogs Foran is the better fit with the team we have.