What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Tony Kemp needs to check into a padded cell

LeagueNut

First Grade
Messages
6,982
http://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/league/9884771/Kemp-Warriors-must-sign-Benji-Marshall

OPINION: Here's an idea for you - Benji Marshall will leave the Blues and sign with the Warriors.

Seems a bit far-fetched, right?

Or does it?

Through the first seven weeks of the Super Rugby competition, it's become apparent to all that Marshall is not a union player.

Despite big plans in the pre-season to steer the Blues' campaign from the pivotal first-five position, he's struggled to even nail a starting spot in a fairly ordinary side.

Any faint hopes he had of playing in next year's World Cup for the All Blacks have also been well and truly extinguished.

The bench is no place for a player of Marshall's calibre. He is better than that and it might be time for him to cut his losses and return to the game that made him into a household name.

It's fair to say the recruitment at the Warriors has been poor for some time but even Blind Freddy could see there's a real opportunity right now to secure the services of a spectacular playmaker who just happens to be down on his luck.

For years, the Kiwi club has struggled to find a solution in the halves. Yes, they have Shaun Johnson but he's still developing and isn't yet a big-game player.

Marshall is.

With his wife, Zoe, making a name for herself as a media personality over here, I can't see the Marshalls wanting to move across the ditch any time soon.

Half the battle, then, is already won.

Just as it's become apparent Marshall isn't a rugby player, it's also pretty clear that Chad Townsend is not the answer for the Warriors in the halves.

If the club was hoping to uncover the next "James Maloney", they'll be sorely disappointed by his performances so far.

With Marshall struggling at the Blues and certainly not used to riding the pine, the Warriors have an incredible opportunity to sign an individual who could turn around their fortunes in a heartbeat.

It's time for owners Eric Watson and Owen Glenn to dust off the chequebook and lure him across town. What are they waiting for?

On another note, I was utterly gobsmacked to hear the New Zealand Rugby League has appointed Andrew McFadden as Stephen Kearney's assistant with the Kiwis.

I don't want to sound like I'm "Aussie bashing" here but to overlook a couple of strong New Zealand contenders - David Kidwell and Richie Blackmore - for the job was just plain wrong.

Both Kidwell and Blackmore, men who wore the black jersey with distinction, would have offered the New Zealand team more than the guy who got the nod.

Seriously, what is wrong with the NZRL? I mean, what sort of message does this appointment send to Kiwis hoping to get into coaching? Where are the pathways?

Does this appointment suggest that McFadden - Matt Elliott's Australian assistant at the Warriors - will ultimately be the man to take over from Kearney?

This is just madness and guys like Kidwell and Blackmore have every right to feel let down by rugby league's governing body.

I wish I could say I'm surprised.

I think I'd rather have Todd Lowrie back.
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
33,461
I am happy with Townsend at the moment - time will tell though.

The Tigers thought the bench was the best place for Marshall too - it is a shame he declined so early, I haven't written him off, but playing-wise it's foolish to give him the money he wants (guess that's where the Tigers ended), in saying that jersey sales and crowds might well increase...

not sure why these dubious characters keep getting paid to come up with this drivel tbh
 

ozbash

Referee
Messages
27,004
Benji may have suffered a drop in form (who doesn't) at the Tigers, but I think there was more to his leaving than that..
 

Shaun Hewitt

First Grade
Messages
6,897
I think we've seen the best of Benji tbh.
I think the best thing for him is to go to ESL now.
His All Blacks dream is over, and the way hes been playing (and not playing...), no NRL club would pay him what he was on at the Tigers.

If he dropped his salary, he may well be worth a punt, but not on current lack of form.
 

SpaceMonkey

Immortal
Messages
41,558
Benji may have suffered a drop in form (who doesn't) at the Tigers, but I think there was more to his leaving than that..

Our chance to sign Benji was two years ago when we were shopping for a coach- if we'd got Tim Sheens then I reckon Benji would've basically come knocking himself, they're basically a package deal.

I'd still look at him but only on an incentives based contract for the first year. Would love to see him back in the NRL and actually playing to his potential again.
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
33,461
Indeed, and you cannot sign players based on what they did 5 years ago...

For whatever reason Benji is a shadow of the player he used to be - I see Rattue is saying dump him now, I don't know, it is an adjustment so he needs time (see discussion on Tomkins)...

I am content with Townsend, but would have been great if they could have got Widdop...
 

JoeD

First Grade
Messages
7,056
Not sure why lots are hating on The Chad after 4 rounds. More than happy with him
 

Iron Lion

Juniors
Messages
1,216
Not sure why lots are hating on The Chad after 4 rounds. More than happy with him

I think Chad is coming along nicely and could turn out being a gem signing, he is showing leadership when the team is doing the hard yards and Johnson is quiet, Kemp comes across like a gimp.
 

tangalife

Juniors
Messages
530
Leuluai, Townsend, Johnson, we're pretty good in the halves ATM. A couple years ago, yeah i'd take Benji but we have good depth there atm, even if he took a paycut we'd still be paying 300k+ on a total gamble.
 

Dr Crane

Live Update Team
Messages
19,531
he's entitled to his opinion. however it just so happens his opinion is that of an insane, mentally deprived lunatic who didn't hear the giggling from the stuff editors when they had a look at this piece.
 

Latest posts

Top