What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Round 1 2015 Team

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
156,857
Well I am in fantasy land, as I am hoping for a top eight spot and reckon we can do it. I also reckon we will add another 1-2 decent players to the side with our cap space. Time will tell.
We couldn't make the 8 this year with the best player in the game having a Dally M season.


And lost

Sio
Fui
Smith
Kelepi
Tonga
And maybe Allgood and Mossop

After signing absolute plodders and maybe watmough.

Love your passion Josh but I'm over fantasy land.
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
1. Hoppa
2. Trailor
3. Champion
4. Izzy
5. Li

6. Norman
7. Sandow

8. Mannah
9. Peats
10. Junior
11. Watmough
12. Mau
13. Tepia

14. Edwards
15. Lussick
16. Gower
17. Mossop
 

emjaycee

Coach
Messages
14,666
We couldn't make the 8 this year with the best player in the game having a Dally M season.


And lost

Sio
Fui
Smith
Kelepi
Tonga
And maybe Allgood and Mossop

After signing absolute plodders and maybe watmough.

Love your passion Josh but I'm over fantasy land.

You are so right to be pessimistic, I mean taking Hayne out of the equation for a minute all of those players you mention that we lost have landed starting 17 spots in teams that finished higher than us on the ladder in 2014 - hang on a sec... oops.

That's right - the ONLY player in that list to get a contract with another NRL team is Kelepi who in his second year played 3 games with the team that came 10th and then couldn't force his way back into the starting 17 for the remainder of the year despite injuries to players in his position. He is going to the Cowboys who finished the year with 2 wins more than us.

So fess up Hineyrulz, where do you get your optimism from?
:crazy:
 

parra pete

Referee
Messages
20,711
1 Brett Stewart
2 Semi
3 Morgan
4 Hoppa
5 Robinson
6 Norman
7 Sandow...
8 Mannah
9 Peats
10 Wicks
11 Mau
12 Morea
13 Whatmough

14 Edwards
15 DeGois
16 Lussick
17 Gower
18 Pauli Pauli.
 

Pazza

Coach
Messages
11,011
Norman
Robinson
Hopoate
Mau
Radradra
Matterson
Sandow
Mannah
Peats
Lussik
Gower
Moeroa
Watmough (please)

Edwards
Mossop
Jnr Paulo
Pauli
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
Seeing Hayne not in the team is ok..

But seeing Norman at fullback and Robinson in the 17 makes me want to cry...


Also Wicks really?
 

Pazza

Coach
Messages
11,011
Seeing Hayne not in the team is ok..

But seeing Norman at fullback and Robinson in the 17 makes me want to cry...


Also Wicks really?

Norman played plenty of first grade at fullback.

Robinson has played some good footy in the past before Stuart went to Canberra.

Hopefully these are only one year stop gap solutions.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
156,857
You are so right to be pessimistic, I mean taking Hayne out of the equation for a minute all of those players you mention that we lost have landed starting 17 spots in teams that finished higher than us on the ladder in 2014 - hang on a sec... oops.

That's right - the ONLY player in that list to get a contract with another NRL team is Kelepi who in his second year played 3 games with the team that came 10th and then couldn't force his way back into the starting 17 for the remainder of the year despite injuries to players in his position. He is going to the Cowboys who finished the year with 2 wins more than us.

So fess up Hineyrulz, where do you get your optimism from?
:crazy:
You honestly think Reece Plodson offers more then Sio??? lol

McPherson more than Fui?? lol

Champion over Tonga??? Both are injury plagued but Tonga played some damn good footy before injuries got the best of him.

Smith while well past it in attack was defensively still a rock and it is no coincedence that the last two games with him out we leaked points like a sieve. Nelson could barely crack the Titans side with a mammoth injury toll.

Crooks who knows about him?? He could be boom or bust, then we have a drug cheat who hasn't played in 4 years and a bloke who retired from a broken neck and who we let go 7 years earlier lol.

Kelepi's season was ruined by injuries go on his efforts last season when he was ROTY.

Then we lose the best player in the game the man the whole side has revolved around for the last 6 years.

Sorry for being a realist, things are all sunshine and lollypops :?
 
Last edited:

Jodeci

Bench
Messages
3,513
You honestly think Reece Plodson offers more then Sio??? lol

McPherson more than Fui?? lol

Champion over Tonga??? Both are injury plagued but Tonga played some damn good footy before injuries got the best of him.

Smith while well past it in attack was defensively still a rock and it is no coincedence that the last two games with him out we leaked points like a sieve. Nelson could barely crack the Titans side with a mammoth injury toll.

Crooks who knows about him?? He could be boom or bust, then we have a drug cheat who hasn't played in 4 years and a bloke who retired from a broken neck and who we let go 7 years earlier lol.

Kelepi's season was ruined by injuries go on his efforts last season when he was ROTY.

Then we lose the best player in the game the man the whole side has revolved around for the last 6 years.

Sorry for being a realist, things are all sunshine and lollypops :?

Stop talking sense, people won't believe you.

McPherson has played 23 games in 3 yrs in the Superleague.

Cody Nelson made his debut at 26 and only did so do to the injury toll at the Titans

Tonga believe it or not has played more games than Champion in the past 4 years

Crooks played 12 games this year and scored 4 tries only

Reece Robinson, my mum is a better player than him.

Wicks hasn't played NRL in 4yrs

This is all Hayne's fault apparently.
 

I bleed blue & gold

First Grade
Messages
8,868
Stop talking sense, people won't believe you.

McPherson has played 23 games in 3 yrs in the Superleague.

Cody Nelson made his debut at 26 and only did so do to the injury toll at the Titans

Tonga believe it or not has played more games than Champion in the past 4 years

Crooks played 12 games this year and scored 4 tries only

Reece Robinson, my mum is a better player than him.

Wicks hasn't played NRL in 4yrs


This is all Hayne's fault apparently.

When you put all that together, wow. Does not look good at this point in time.
 

Craig Johnston

First Grade
Messages
5,396
the way i see that is that fui fui was zero chance of providing something of value to the 1st team as he was regressing.

mcpherson wicks and nelson may end up no better, but at least they have the potential to produce something at their age similar to david gower did this season.

similarly robinson and crooks could offer more than tonga and if they don't it ain't much missed.
 
Top