Rumoured and Confirmed signings - Part 4

[jane the pain]

Tyrone Peachy is staying with the Panthers, the intricate details of the deal will be sorted post season but I am sure Gus and Garth have already agreed on who is heading North.

Please, refer to my previous comment.

 

[herbert henry1908]

Oh it does, my bad, and my apologizes, I have had a shit of a day.

I changed my post above because you are kinda right, the piece says it’s unlikely he’ll stay at Penrith because of the cap. It’s still a possibility though.

 

[Port Panther]

I for one am getting sick of developing juniors and players for coastal teams who dont put money into their own competitions .

 

[mxlegend99]

I figured that the Titans would respond this way. They need him

We release players to them early (including Peachey) and when someone has a change of heart they want to be merkins about it.

Good luck to them forcing a player to stay that doesn't want go be there. It sucks for them. But they only got him to begin with because we released him early to them anyway.

Aside from Moylan we havent released anyone wanting something in return.

 

[OldPanther]

Good a contract should mean something.

 

[Sime_11]

its not a good look but technically wouldn't his contract have a start date? that date is yet to pass so he should be within his rights to terminate shouldn't he?

 

[Kilkenny]

The NRL is a business and I don't see the Tyrone Peachy situation as a big deal.

He obviously want's to stay with us for any number of reasons, mainly personal I guess, and the Titans will do very well out of the situation.

At the end of the day whoever we trade to retain Tyrone Peachy will get an opportunity to play NRL which they may not get at our club on a regular basis. As just one example say Liam Martin. He is crying out for an opportunity and will deliver when he get's it. If he stay's with us he is still down the pecking order with the likes of Billy Burns, Shawn Blore and others capable of jumping him in the pecking order.

Tyrone Peachy is a great player, but I honestly believe if Garth Brennan plays his card's right and get's two or more for the price of one he is going to do really well out of the situation.

 

[franklin2323]

GC are just ensuring they get cash and a player or 2 for Peachey. No way he plays there next year

 

[franklin2323]

The NRL is a business and I don't see the Tyrone Peachy situation as a big deal.

He obviously want's to stay with us for any number of reasons, mainly personal I guess, and the Titans will do very well out of the situation.

At the end of the day whoever we trade to retain Tyrone Peachy will get an opportunity to play NRL which they may not get at our club on a regular basis. As just one example say Liam Martin. He is crying out for an opportunity and will deliver when he get's it. If he stay's with us he is still down the pecking order with the likes of Billy Burns, Shawn Blore and others capable of jumping him in the pecking order.

Tyrone Peachy is a great player, but I honestly believe if Garth Brennan plays his card's right and get's two or more for the price of one he is going to do really well out of the situation.

We need cap space for Peachey. So GC just works out to get players Brennan knows them anyway. Works for both parties really

 

[OldPanther]

its not a good look but technically wouldn't his contract have a start date? that date is yet to pass so he should be within his rights to terminate shouldn't he?

Short term cooling off period which is 10 days or something.

We need cap space for Peachey. So GC just works out to get players Brennan knows them anyway. Works for both parties really

Hope Peachey is happy playing as a utility forever.

 

[herbert henry1908]

I’d happily let May go if it means keeping Peachey.

 

[Kilkenny]

Hope Peachey is happy playing as a utility forever.

Tyrone Peachy for the most part has been an integral part of our top 17 in his time at our club, whether in centres, five eighth, lock, back row, hooker or occasionally off the bench. He is a top quality player no matter where you play him and whomever our coach may be he just has to find a spot for him he is that good.

 

[Kilkenny]

I’d happily let May go if it means keeping Peachey.

Very similar players but the one thing that May doesn't have is speed over the crucial first 20-40 metres.

It has been said before that Peachy is the quickest player in the club over these shorter distances and May while a natural footy player is not the quickest in terms of speed/acceleration.

 

[franklin2323]

Short term cooling off period which is 10 days or something.



Hope Peachey is happy playing as a utility forever.

He hasn't got a set position. So would always be one

 

[OldPanther]

Tyrone Peachy for the most part has been an integral part of our top 17 in his time at our club, whether in centres, five eighth, lock, back row, hooker or occasionally off the bench. He is a top quality player no matter where you play him and whomever our coach may be he just has to find a spot for him he is that good.

That's the thing. There are no positions to put him in other than with injuries.

 

[herbert henry1908]

He’d be our main utility off the bench.

Plus the first guy into the centres if there’s an injury.

 

[Panther Mick]

I’d happily let May go if it means keeping Peachey.

Slight problem value wise.
Peach's next contact is worth around $500k a year. Quite a bit of coin just to come off the bench. If he stayed here.
May would be on bugger all.

 

[Fangs]

As MX said, good luck keeping a guy who doesn't want to be at your club.

Same with Ivan Cleary. If the tigers fight to keep him then their priorities aren't straight.

Says a lot about our club and plenty about the rest. People want to be here.

 

[Panfa]

Peachey built a house in penrith his mrs doesnt want to go to gold coast but we cant afford him under the cap he may have to go to a rival nrl club in sydney

 

[herbert henry1908]

Slight problem value wise.
Peach's next contact is worth around $500k a year. Quite a bit of coin just to come off the bench. If he stayed here.
May would be on bugger all.

Sorry, I wasn’t talking from a contract value POV. I meant if the Titans wanted a player in return for letting Peachey go.