Rumoured and Confirmed signings - Part 4

[OldPanther]

Then you will have 2 chins.
Merrin is a slug, but dopey Maloney is worse...that was proved last week.

Yes Ivan and Nathan. Maloney was a prank this year to lure the rest of you into a false sense of security. It clearly worked.

 

[OldPanther]

No Idea how we are in cap trouble while others around us aren't but seems we are stuck with what we have

Merrin leaves, fish to prop, May to lock. Bench of Tamou, Leota, Hetherington or Tui Loso

 

[herbert henry1908]

The Katoa V Egan thing

It’s not really about that, it’s about neither of them being the consistent contributor we need from such a vital position.

Maybe they’ll both be that eventually, but at the moment if one of them isn’t performing we have no option than to go to another inconsistent performer.

The squad would look much better with a seasoned hooker in it.

 

[jane the pain]

The Katoa V Egan thing

It’s not really about that, it’s about neither of them being the consistent contributor we need from such a vital position.

Maybe they’ll both be that eventually, but at the moment if one of them isn’t performing we have no option than to go to another inconsistent performer.

The squad would look much better with a seasoned hooker in it.

So how can Katoa, and Egan, gain experience with the season hooker? Leave them be.

 

[herbert henry1908]

So how can Katoa, and Egan, gain experience with the season hooker? Leave them be.

The seasoned hooker would be back up come round 1, but if neither of them progress then he’d be available.

 

[franklin2323]

Merrin leaves, fish to prop, May to lock. Bench of Tamou, Leota, Hetherington or Tui Loso

Meanwhile Roosters add 3 rep players. Sharks add Morris and making a play for Munster in 2020. Knights and Cowboys getting stronger too. No wonder we don't improve

 

[OldPanther]

The Katoa V Egan thing

It’s not really about that, it’s about neither of them being the consistent contributor we need from such a vital position.

Maybe they’ll both be that eventually, but at the moment if one of them isn’t performing we have no option than to go to another inconsistent performer.

The squad would look much better with a seasoned hooker in it.

Who would we get? Good Hookers isn't exactly in abundance. Also what Jane said would be a concern. They need game time.

 

[betcats]

Meanwhile Roosters add 3 rep players. Sharks add Morris and making a play for Munster in 2020. Knights and Cowboys getting stronger too. No wonder we don't improve

Sharks are getting worse not better. They are losing holmes for one, they are already old and signing a 30 yo winger doesn't add much.

 

[herbert henry1908]

Who would we get? Good Hookers isn't exactly in abundance. Also what Jane said would be a concern. They need game time.

I’m not sure, just a solid type, not a star.

Someone who can provide consistent, good quality service. Doesn’t need a kicking or running game.

You can’t just stick it out with young guys if they’re not improving, it’s just such a vital position.

 

[franklin2323]

Sharks are getting worse not better. They are losing holmes for one, they are already old and signing a 30 yo winger doesn't add much.

You do realise we play them in the Flegg GF on Sunday. While their NSW Cup team plays in the GF? So still have talent coming in. Munster is a handy replacement for Holmes.

 

[betcats]

You do realise we play them in the Flegg GF on Sunday. While their NSW Cup team plays in the GF? So still have talent coming in. Munster is a handy replacement for Holmes.

You do realise they haven't signed munster yet and probably wont.

 

[Tiger Woody]

Yes Ivan and Nathan. Maloney was a prank this year to lure the rest of you into a false sense of security. It clearly worked.

sure did..
only missed 126 tackles this year..
You guys WILL NOT win a comp with him in the side...

 

[Tiger Woody]

Who would we get? Good Hookers isn't exactly in abundance. Also what Jane said would be a concern. They need game time.

Pierre Gotitnot is available......
We flicked him after 1 year...

 

[OldPanther]

Meanwhile Roosters add 3 rep players. Sharks add Morris and making a play for Munster in 2020. Knights and Cowboys getting stronger too. No wonder we don't improve

I'd sign Taupau

 

[OldPanther]

Pierre Gotitnot is available......
We flicked him after 1 year...

Great example of good experience.

 

[OldPanther]

sure did..
only missed 126 tackles this year..
You guys WILL NOT win a comp with him in the side...

That was the prank mate. Keep up please.

 

[Tiger Woody]

That was the prank mate. Keep up please.

Keep up????

your the Riff supporter , not me

 

[jane the pain]

The seasoned hooker would be back up come round 1, but if neither of them progress then he’d be available.

You totally missed my point.

 

[jane the pain]

Pierre Gotitnot is available......
We flicked him after 1 year...

Why isn't this oxygen thieving moron still on here? Time for it to be banned.

 

[OldPanther]

Keep up????

your the Riff supporter , not me

Kind of hard for Panthers fans to keep up with a fanbase whose team is lower on the ladder every year and less premierships.