What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rd4: 615pm Eels v Dragons GAME DAY THREAD @ Commbank Stadium 3/4/22

eel01s

Bench
Messages
3,540
Good win off the back of our pack outmuscling the Dragons.

Nice to see Penisini's skill on the right. We can't just be a threat on the left edge.

Greig looks hard to tackle, they couldn't get him on his back.

Great team effort. Hope Blake is good to go next week, and Lane isn't out for too long.
 
Messages
18,429
Good win off the back of our pack outmuscling the Dragons.

Nice to see Penisini's skill on the right. We can't just be a threat on the left edge.

Greig looks hard to tackle, they couldn't get him on his back.

Great team effort. Hope Blake is good to go next week, and Lane isn't out for too long.
Penisini is a natural
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
64,970
This is my take.

Moses kicking game is another level. Clearys is more draining and controlling. He pins sides down. Moses is more attacking. Unsure who has the better one currently.

Waqa is playing better then he has in his career. More his attitude. He looks a leader and playing with mongrel.

Dylan's gone to another level which makes us dangerous.

Pensini is a real talent.

Mattersons defense is excellent but his attack isn't close to Lanes. We look so much better in attack with Lane.

At this point our key players in my eyes are the two halves and the two starting props along with Lane.

Gutherson and Mahoney are doing their jobs but their speed worries me once finals come. The top sides are very fast in those positions. Still they are playing well.

Simmonson again fails to impress me. It had me wondering when Russel is fit what happens? I assume Russel goes to NSW CUP and has to work his way into side. I see more upside in Russel. I also wonder when Sivo is back. Opacic has great defense but a turtle in attack. Sivo and Russel in that backline makes it far more exciting. Potential to be very potent. But perhaps that's the word. Potential.

Greig in his limited time shows me he does have potential. He will need 30 NRL games and atleast 25mins a game. More potential then Kafusi and Makatoa in his run game.

Mahoney dropping off tackles is also a worry when finals come around.

When everyone is fit we add Lane and Marata. Greig and most likely Makatoa will drop out. Its going to be one hell of a forward pack.

Bryce needs time also. Close to the line we look so much more potent with him on the field.
 

Bandwagon

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
47,264
What was good this game was that our halves were moving when they got the ball,

Get guth out of the Playmaking and leave it to dyl.

Guth just had to support
The more Guth stayed out of the way the better our attack looked.

Gutho's been a bit off to start the season as far as ball playing goes, but being there in position to ball play gives Drown more options and the defence more decisions to make.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
64,970
Gutho's been a bit off to start the season as far as ball playing goes, but being there in position to ball play gives Drown more options and the defence more decisions to make.


Gutherson has been very poor imo. This is a guy on 800k. He was exceptional against the Storm.
Tonight a pass into sidelines and a kick for a 7 tackle set. Keeping in mind his run game is very weak and he is slow as a turtle. This means he has to be top of his game in the other areas. He is either our highest or 2nd highest paid player. He got his big contract and can't be exempt of criticism.

Last week he was however exceptional.

Mahoney also has been hot and cold. The positive for mine is if these two get hot again and we inject Marata,Lane,Sivo into the side its a chance to take the title out.

I did expect Penrith and Storm to drop off however but it may not be the case. Panthers have unearthed even more young talent and look scary. Storm are just a brilliant side.
 

yy_cheng

Coach
Messages
18,734
This is my take.

Moses kicking game is another level. Clearys is more draining and controlling. He pins sides down. Moses is more attacking. Unsure who has the better one currently.

Waqa is playing better then he has in his career. More his attitude. He looks a leader and playing with mongrel.

Dylan's gone to another level which makes us dangerous.

Pensini is a real talent.

Mattersons defense is excellent but his attack isn't close to Lanes. We look so much better in attack with Lane.

At this point our key players in my eyes are the two halves and the two starting props along with Lane.

Gutherson and Mahoney are doing their jobs but their speed worries me once finals come. The top sides are very fast in those positions. Still they are playing well.

Simmonson again fails to impress me. It had me wondering when Russel is fit what happens? I assume Russel goes to NSW CUP and has to work his way into side. I see more upside in Russel. I also wonder when Sivo is back. Opacic has great defense but a turtle in attack. Sivo and Russel in that backline makes it far more exciting. Potential to be very potent. But perhaps that's the word. Potential.

Greig in his limited time shows me he does have potential. He will need 30 NRL games and atleast 25mins a game. More potential then Kafusi and Makatoa in his run game.

Mahoney dropping off tackles is also a worry when finals come around.

When everyone is fit we add Lane and Marata. Greig and most likely Makatoa will drop out. Its going to be one hell of a forward pack.

Bryce needs time also. Close to the line we look so much more potent with him on the field.
Gutho is excellent in many other aspects of the game.

He's toughness, fitness, safety at the back and support play is excellent. Plus he is willing to do the hard yards.

If you watch dyl come back in cover in defence, guth let's him do his work and will hold back and covers what will unfold
 

Bandwagon

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
47,264
Gutherson has been very poor imo. This is a guy on 800k. He was exceptional against the Storm.
Tonight a pass into sidelines and a kick for a 7 tackle set. Keeping in mind his run game is very weak and he is slow as a turtle. This means he has to be top of his game in the other areas. He is either our highest or 2nd highest paid player. He got his big contract and can't be exempt of criticism.

Last week he was however exceptional.

Mahoney also has been hot and cold. The positive for mine is if these two get hot again and we inject Marata,Lane,Sivo into the side its a chance to take the title out.

I did expect Penrith and Storm to drop off however but it may not be the case. Panthers have unearthed even more young talent and look scary. Storm are just a brilliant side.

................which means in those other areas he has to earn his keep, defense, support, and ball playing.

I've no reason to believe, despite his ball work being off to begin the season, that it won't come good. He's one of the better playmaking fullbacks in the comp.
 

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,922
100% and if Carty was there for more than 20m and the scores were close we'd would have been exposed.

Let's face it they have got two really good centres and Sims. The rest were outclassed.
You reckon that’s 100%? Did you watch St George’s tries? Drown’s an outstanding defender and even he got exposed tonight. It happens sometimes.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
64,970
................which means in those other areas he has to earn his keep, defense, support, and ball playing.

I've no reason to believe, despite his ball work being off to begin the season, that it won't come good. He's one of the better playmaking fullbacks in the comp.


Yes that's what I said. But his forms been average so far bar his game vs Storm. Remember he is on 800k and it may cost us the signing of Dylan Brown.

Honestly if we lost him id be very upset with the club. Surely we aren't hat hopeless and why we lets Papa and Mahoney go??
 

Latest posts

Top