2025 Match Review & Judiciary charges

[Captain Apollo]

Just what happened to Annesley’s Monday NRL ref review, veery Transparent bunch at the NRL at the moment.

It was announced in the pre-season that Annesley's Monday afternoon reviews would be discontinued -

‘Self-flagellation’: Why the NRL will no longer put up football boss to explain refereeing calls

Graham Annesley’s Monday briefings to explain the weekend’s refereeing controversies will become a thing of the past, amid growing feeling in league circles the sessions weren’t “a good look” for the game.

www.smh.com.au

 

[Someguy]

just be thankful latrell ain’t playing this weekend during this crackdown. I guarantee a sin bin on Friday.

Luckily radley is also out as he’d have been odds on favourite

The other big player in the sin bin shitshow warriors miss out on justice. Will be one week of hysteria then the next NRL will say it’s gone too far, some poor warriors player will cop the worst foul play of the season and it will be play on

 

[Fangs]

It was announced in the pre-season that Annesley's Monday afternoon reviews would be discontinued -

‘Self-flagellation’: Why the NRL will no longer put up football boss to explain refereeing calls

Graham Annesley’s Monday briefings to explain the weekend’s refereeing controversies will become a thing of the past, amid growing feeling in league circles the sessions weren’t “a good look” for the game.

www.smh.com.au

And thank god they did.

Talk about a useless review.

 

[gerg]

And thank god they did.

Talk about a useless review.

Only because he would just blindly support the referees, even when they got it completely wrong. When he first started doing it he would admit they got things wrong but at some stage he stopped doing that. I think it was last year or 2023, he spent 5 minutes talking about a forward pass that wasn't forward ... but clearly was.

 

[Fangs]

Only because he would just blindly support the referees, even when they got it completely wrong. When he first started doing it he would admit they got things wrong but at some stage he stopped doing that. I think it was last year or 2023, he spent 5 minutes talking about a forward pass that wasn't forward ... but clearly was.

Yes but what does anyone gain if they admit fault? Comfort? You'll never see the result of a match overturned.

Incorrect decisions in a round of football don't mean a whole lot to the overall picture. Its over 6-12 months of football you start to get a sense about the standard of officiating in the game. The weekly review hasn't done anything to renew confidence in the clubs of fans. It feels like a pointless exercise and time would be better spent by Annesley and the NRL working on other things.

 

[Valheru]

They did nail it in Round 1. They binned Tapine and then suspended him for 2 games for a standard shoulder charge. Since then I don't think any player has been sinbinned for a shoulder despite there being several that involved direct contact to the head.

Foketi hot binned in round 2 for an innocuous one that the bunker had to go out of its way to find from 2 plays prior. The tackles player didn't even complain.

Since then they have inexplicably not binned a few that were obvious.

 

[gerg]

Yes but what does anyone gain if they admit fault? Comfort? You'll never see the result of a match overturned.

Incorrect decisions in a round of football don't mean a whole lot to the overall picture. Its over 6-12 months of football you start to get a sense about the standard of officiating in the game. The weekly review hasn't done anything to renew confidence in the clubs of fans. It feels like a pointless exercise and time would be better spent by Annesley and the NRL working on other things.

Well originally Annesley would explain why decisions went a particular way. Sometimes explaining why a decision is made helps educate the fans with context. But it needs to be consistent and for me that is the biggest problem, the lack of consistency.

Saying the referees got a decision wrong makes them accountable and 'hopefully' leads to improvement.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Foketi hot binned in round 2 for an innocuous one that the bunker had to go out of its way to find from 2 plays prior. The tackles player didn't even complain.

Since then they have inexplicably not binned a few that were obvious.

Thats the only one this year thats seemed be reviewed the same as last season. Mahoney and Luais on the weekend were definitely sin bins, I thought Rikkis could have been a send off it was that bad and it wasnt even bined.

Looking forward to the total over reaction this weekend ruining some great games.

 

[Warrimoo3]

How come Papalii didn't get suspended for touching the ref. WK got a week for running into the ref trying to make a tackle

​

The biggest joke was Warbrick hitting Damien Cook in the head with his left shoulder then bringing down his left elbow onto Cook’s neck at the 30:40 mark of the 2nd half on the Fox coverage of Saints v Storm last weekend. Cook rightly stayed down. No penalty. Not even on report. Do they even watch these matches?

 

[dogslife]

It'll be funny when they deem Hudson Young's sin binnable offence as a $1500 fine.

Hope the wowzers are happy with these farcical interpretations

 

[League Unlimited News]

It'll be funny when they deem Hudson Young's sin binnable offence as a $1500 fine.

Hope the wowzers are happy with these farcical interpretations

$1800 with priors.

https://leagueunlimited.com/news/41979-nrl-match-review-and-judiciary-charges-2025-nrl-round-5/

Thursday​

Canberra v Cronulla​

Sebastian Kris (CAN)​

Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Sam Stonestreet (35 min)
Base penalty $1500
1st offence
- Early Plea - $1000
- Guilty at panel / no contest - $1500
PLEA: 12pm Monday

Hudson Young (CAN)​

Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Cam McInnes (58 min)
Base penalty $1500
2nd offence
- Early Plea - $1800
- Guilty at panel / no contest - $2500
PLEA: 12pm Monday

Billy Burns (CRO)​

Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Owen Pattie (67 min)
Base penalty $1500
1st offence
- Early Plea - $1000
- Guilty at panel / no contest - $1500
PLEA: 12pm Monday

 

[yobbo84]

Grade 1 careless should NOT be a sin bin.

They've twisted themselves into a pretzel with all this nonsense.

 

[Fangs]

Should have been 3 since bins missed opportunity there.

 

[skeepe]

They’ve lost the plot. I know Hudson’s shoulder made high contact, but he was literally just standing up and McInnes ran into him.

Kris and Burns absolutely worth a charge in today’s game, but Young’s was barely a penalty.

 

[dogslife]

They’ve lost the plot. I know Hudson’s shoulder made high contact, but he was literally just standing up and McInnes ran into him.

Kris and Burns absolutely worth a charge in today’s game, but Young’s was barely a penalty.

Yeah unfortunately when morons like yourself scream for send offs every time a bloke gets hit even remotely hard, there's consequences

 

[Maximus]

Yeah unfortunately when morons like yourself scream for send offs every time a bloke gets hit even remotely hard, there's consequences

It was the blatant favouritism shown to your team that caused this. If Mahoney was appropriately punished for his actions, nothing would have been said.

 

[dogslife]

It was the blatant favouritism shown to your team that caused this. If Mahoney was appropriately punished for his actions, nothing would have been said.

Nrl picked out 4 incidents from last weekend, and you pick out the only one that didn't cop a week.

Unfortunately it's mouth breathers like you that are part of the problem. Sprinting to the NRL facebook page so quickly to give them a gobful about concussions you practically trip over and give yourself one

 

[Maximus]

Nrl picked out 4 incidents from last weekend, and you pick out the only one that didn't cop a week.

Yeah that's the point. The worst and the only one that copped no real punishment.

 

[League Unlimited News]

Friday​

Penrith v North Queensland​

Reece Robson (NQL)​

Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Daine Laurie (25 min)
Base penalty $1500
1st offence
- Early Plea - $1000
- Guilty at panel / no contest - $1500
PLEA: 12pm Monday

Moses Leota (PEN)​

Grade 1 Crusher Tackle on Sam McIntyre (76 min)
Base penalty $2000
1st offence
- Early Plea - $1500
- Guilty at panel / no contest - $2000
PLEA: 12pm Monday

South Sydney v Sydney​

No charges