What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2025 FW1 QF Fri - Melbourne (2) 26-18 Canterbury (3) @ AAMI

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    12
  • Poll closed .
Messages
196
With Xeri out hopefully Ciraldo is looking at a bit of a mild shake up. Bring Sexington back in, move Burton out to center where he's far better IMO and bring that niggly little prick Reed back in to the starting side. It's not do or die this week so I'd be trying something different this game regardless. Keep trying the same thing and they'll go out in straight sets.
 

Dogs Of War

Coach
Messages
13,822
With Xeri out hopefully Ciraldo is looking at a bit of a mild shake up. Bring Sexington back in, move Burton out to center where he's far better IMO and bring that niggly little prick Reed back in to the starting side. It's not do or die this week so I'd be trying something different this game regardless. Keep trying the same thing and they'll go out in straight sets.

With Kiraz and Monty likely to be back in the lineup. There is no need. Just about getting up for the game. I would consider playing around with Reed starting and having Haywood return to the 14 role.
 

Warrimoo3

Bench
Messages
2,656
All eyes will be on the teams sheets later today. Doggies will be desperate for Kiraz to play and mark up on Coates. If he doesn’t play it might be Tuala to left centre with Rinakama and Wilson on the wings. That would make the left edge vulnerable particularly with Kikau having sustained a nasty head knock last weekend. He didn’t look well in an interview on NRL tonight yesterday.

Kiraz’s injured ankle will get the ultimate fitness test jumping and landing v Coates on match day. Meaney’s defence at centre has improved a lot over the past couple of months and it needed to. He really frustrated the Dogs’ attack last time they met. I suspect Bellamy will go with Munster at fullback with Wishart and Pezet in the halves. Blore is a big loss as well for the Storm.

Will wait for the team sheets before making a prediction , although I expect some ducks and drakes . Will only find out what’s really happening an hour before kick off when the run on teams are named.
 

Someguy

First Grade
Messages
7,866
Storm extended bench says that there will be big shuffle come game day. That bench is putrid something has to give
 

Dogs Of War

Coach
Messages
13,822
That's on the list of the least important excuses to live somewhere.

Be around people you like? Have a listen to his podcast with Steve Gillis (I do recommend his podcast, interviews with people in the game, great insights).
 

ouwet

Bench
Messages
4,530
Being reported Reed will be dropped completely from the 17...
Sexton on the bench.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Bazal

Post Whore
Messages
110,176
Gus feeding rubbish out to find out who the leak potentially is at the club, and make Buzz look like a fool.

Gus looking for the leak like

giphy.gif
 

footy75

Bench
Messages
3,080
I think Storm but not with confidence.

Either way can´t wait. Will be great crowd and atmosphere.
 

Warrimoo3

Bench
Messages
2,656
I’m a bit betwixt and between with trying to predict this one. I had a close look at the Bulldogs v Sharks match from last week and the Bulldogs defence was great for the first 25 minutes. The Sharks were incredibly impressive for the whole game and their forwards were sensational , especially Hazeltown and Talakai when they came off the bench. This was the best overall forward performance from any team that I’ve seen this year.

The Bulldogs did very well to limit the Sharks to 4 tries , with one coming from a Tracey error from a kick return. But the Bulldogs’ attack remained a problem with the main threats being a Preston edge run or a left foot step from Burton.

With both coaches playing ducks and drakes we won’t know the run on teams until an hour before kick off. And in this match I think the selections will determine the winner. I can see where Bellamy is coming from with Meaney to fullback. Without Paps they need a bit of extra zing from fullback to exploit a likely novice Bulldogs left edge. And if Burton plays left centre he can be a bit vulnerable to a good stepper and his kicking game might not be as effective.

With Munster at five eighth they have an extra kicker with Grant , Wishart and Pezet(when he’s on the field) to launch cross field bombs or just little dinky little kicks to Coates and Warbrick. Kiraz can do a job defending these against Coates but Warbrick is almost as good as Coates in the air with his extensive AFL background. And Katoa presents yet another aerial threat to the Bulldogs.

If Grant and Meaney play well I think the Storm will win. If Burton plays well the Bulldogs are a chance. All depends how the Bulldogs recover from the physical hammering from the Sharks last week.

Without a great deal of confidence due to the run on teams remaining a mystery at this point in time:

Storm by 2.
 

Warrimoo3

Bench
Messages
2,656
Having re-watched round 15 Bulldogs v Souths this is what I think they will do :

Sexton halfback
Galvin five-eighth
Burton to left centre
Kiraz in to mark Coates
Tuala or Wilson to drop out
Turpin to the bench to relieve Hayward
Bench: Toupounua ; Mann ;Turpin ; Hayes or Curran ;
 
Top