08 :: R13 Sat :: Eels 30 Raiders 12 @ Parramatta

[Sea Eagle Scuba]

Simultaneous at worst. Simultaneous means a try.

Yeah you guys definitely got dudded with that decision..

 

[VictorTheViking]

CHOMP! :lol:

It's funny cause Skeepe's whinge is valid - you on the other hand, are just a f*ckin cry baby :lol:

Hmmmm

 

[skeepe]

**** you Mateo you piece of ****. Referee should have penalised for time wasting. WHAT A ****ING JOKE.

 

[bileduct]

Well, I thought Inu had two hands holding the ball just before Monoghan had his hand on it, so Inu then had possession of the ball. Monoghan can't ground it if its in Inu's control first, unless he loses it.

I'll have to have another look at it. But it also seemed to me that Inu was picking up the ball and not grounding it. Might have to look at the rule book to see if grounding is described as an explicit downward motion.

I'm sure they'll look at it on the replay in a moment at half time break.

 

[mickdo]

Simultaneous at worst.

I guess we'll agree to disagree then

 

[gong_eagle]

Parramatta 10
Tries (2)
Joel Reddy 17m
Luke Burt 21m

Conversions (1/2)
Luke Burt 19m

Penalty Goals (0/0)


Goalkickers (1/2)
Luke Burt 1 from 2

Canberra 6
Tries (1)
David Milne 14m

Conversions (1/1)
Todd Carney 15m

Penalty Goals (0/0)


Goalkickers (1/1)
Todd Carney 1 from 1


Canberra in brackets
Errors: 4 (3)
Completions: 17/21 (16/19)
Penalties: 5 (3)
Scrums: 0 (0)
Tackles: 153 (152)
1 on 1 Tackles: 9 (7)
Missed Tackles: 6 (11)
Line Breaks: 1 (1)
Offloads: 7 (6)
Runs: 83 (74)
Runs Metres: 631m (544m)
Try Assists: 2 (1)
40/20s: 0 (0)
Line Dropouts: 2 (1)

 

[bileduct]

Err I didnt admit anything, I didnt respond, theres a difference, and yes, from the small amount of replays I thought there was a hand on him

Just saw the replay and yep, noone near him.

 

[Mick_63]

Its tough when the 70/30's don't go your way.
Good contribution off the bench from Butriss.

Inu tactic of holding on when tackled is paying dividends,2 penalties,whats the point of touch judges.

 

[bileduct]

I guess we'll agree to disagree then

Well, now that we've seen the replay I don't know how you can say that they both didn't touch the ball simultaneously.

Furthermore, it wasn't even a simultaneous grounding. Inu is clearly picking up the ball, not grounding it. Otherwise why does he start running out of his own end with ball in hand?

 

[skeepe]

I guess we'll agree to disagree then

Even if we were to agree that Inu had control of the ball... why the drop out? There's no way in the world Inu grounded that ball.

 

[VictorTheViking]

Well there you go, I didnt see more than one **** replay, so im happy to admit there was no-one near him now

 

[Sea Eagle Scuba]

Time back on second half....

 

[bileduct]

Hahaha, Mark Riddell got up to play the ball before he'd even been tackled and then looked at the ref to wonder why he wasn't getting a penalty for interference in the play the ball.

 

[VictorTheViking]

Another ****ing mistake.....christ

 

[bileduct]

Another ****ing mistake.....christ

Holy **** dude, did you see our completion rate and error count at half time?

You're ****ing hard to please.

 

[mickdo]

Well, now that we've seen the replay I don't know how you can say that they both didn't touch the ball simultaneously.

Furthermore, it wasn't even a simultaneous grounding. Inu is clearly picking up the ball, not grounding it. Otherwise why does he start running out of his own end with ball in hand?

I never said it was simultaneous grounding, I said Inu had possession first.

 

[VictorTheViking]

Bileduct....im sick of mediocrity...surely thats not hard to understand?

 

[skeepe]

The video referee is directly responsible for this result. ****ing rorted again.

 

[VictorTheViking]

While theres still time....we arent gonna go remotely close....****ing horrible

 

[Sea Eagle Scuba]

Cant wait to see Tony Williams in the Maroon and White next year.. Parra fans have every right to be ropeable!