What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

'11 | R18 | Fri | Eels 22-6 Tigers | Parramatta #nrlparwst

R18: PAR v WST


  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
the replay showed it was good... tv angle on the run makes those long passes seem forward


the replay showed he threw it well before the line markings on the ground and the player caught it on the line markings.
3 metres forward easy
 
Messages
33,280
Monste game from Burt.

Commentary was so much better without Gus aswell

Bulldogs and Eels fans pessimistically predicted that they're teams would lose by 20 points to the Tigers. We're the only ones who walk the talk. When I say the Tigers will lose by 20, I mean it! The club is cancer-riddled.

If we score more than two tries that game you can name your own reward aslong as you don't go Canberra on me and involve a dog.

Fair dinkum, you can't be worried about playing us.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
People still don't get the forward pass rule...

ill accept a line ball pass if its thrown backwards, but when the ball is caught, 3-4 metres from the point its thrown, its gone forward, its a forward pass, no question

this pass backwards out of the hand shite is nonsense... if you pass the ball on a the attacking 35 metre line and the winger catches it cleanly on the 30m line... its forward. Fullstop.
 

Parra Pride

Referee
Messages
20,452
ill accept a line ball pass if its thrown backwards, but when the ball is caught, 3-4 metres from the point its thrown, its gone forward, its a forward pass, no question

this pass backwards out of the hand shite is nonsense... if you pass the ball on a the attacking 35 metre line and the winger catches it cleanly on the 30m line... its forward. Fullstop.

That is not how the rule is written though, if it leaves the hands backwards it is not forward, it could travel 100 metres forward, but according to the rule as long as it left the hands backward it is a fair pass.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
That is not how the rule is written though, if it leaves the hands backwards it is not forward, it could travel 100 metres forward, but according to the rule as long as it left the hands backward it is a fair pass.

You're right, it is the rule and ruled correct as per the rule
i disagree with the rule
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
ill accept a line ball pass if its thrown backwards, but when the ball is caught, 3-4 metres from the point its thrown, its gone forward, its a forward pass, no question

this pass backwards out of the hand shite is nonsense... if you pass the ball on a the attacking 35 metre line and the winger catches it cleanly on the 30m line... its forward. Fullstop.


The only reason it is forward to you is because it was thrown by Hayne you Rtard..... Why do you and Skeep comment on eels games:lol:
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Nothing to do with Hayne... if i want to laugh at hayne i could laugh at him for his multiple mistackles, and hideous kicking game... the issue is a bloke threw it well before a line marking and the player caught it right on the line marking... thats forward, the rules are ridiculous, thats forward

As for why i comment on eels games is because i dont have Foxtel (f**king body corp in my unit) so FNF is something i try to watch... i watched part of the game and im commenting on what i saw... welcome to a public forum douchebag
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
Nothing to do with Hayne... if i want to laugh at hayne i could laugh at him for his multiple mistackles, and hideous kicking game... the issue is a bloke threw it well before a line marking and the player caught it right on the line marking... thats forward, the rules are ridiculous, thats forward

But you dont bring up the 3 other blatent forward passes that were not called forward in this game just harp on the Hayne pass...
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
Nothing to do with Hayne... if i want to laugh at hayne i could laugh at him for his multiple mistackles, and hideous kicking game... the issue is a bloke threw it well before a line marking and the player caught it right on the line marking... thats forward, the rules are ridiculous, thats forward

As for why i comment on eels games is because i dont have Foxtel (f**king body corp in my unit) so FNF is something i try to watch... i watched part of the game and im commenting on what i saw... welcome to a public forum douchebag

Sorry i must have got onto replying before you had a chance to rethink your post and have a crack at me :lol: and i am sorry you are to poor to actually live in a place that can get foxtel dont get mad at me for your cheapness...
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
I only saw limited footage, from the 55 minute onward... I will say im pretty solid on my hatred for forward passes, and im happy to say Tongue loves them too... Cam Smith is my biggest gripe, it happens all the time, and its very rarely called up... absurd

Smith throws 5-6 a game. I hate it. The refs need to crack down on it, but the hayne one was obvious.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Sorry i must have got onto replying before you had a chance to rethink your post and have a crack at me :lol: and i am sorry you are to poor to actually live in a place that can get foxtel dont get mad at me for your cheapness...[/QUO4TE]

$1300 a fortnight. You tell me... My issue is some f**king shite builder who didnt wire the f**king building properly and some other douchebag in body corp who wont ok a direct line into my appartment
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
I only saw limited footage, from the 55 minute onward... I will say im pretty solid on my hatred for forward passes, and im happy to say Tongue loves them too... Cam Smith is my biggest gripe, it happens all the time, and its very rarely called up... absurd

Smith throws 5-6 a game. I hate it. The refs need to crack down on it, but the hayne one was obvious.

The other 3 happened after Haynes which i think was forward.. If the ball goes forward like yaself i think it should be called forward this aint the NFL..
 

Y2Eel

First Grade
Messages
8,176
$1300 a fortnight. You tell me... My issue is some f**king shite builder who didnt wire the f**king building properly and some other douchebag in body corp who wont ok a direct line into my appartment

Ok your paying to much rent where you live Bloody Mosman?
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
No. I live in Woden, canberra rent is completely out of control. No question. Rent in any of the town centres is too much... such is life. In canberra if you dont live close enough to Civic to get there easily you might as well live in yass... the place id like to buy is Kingston, and to get in the game you're looking at 750k+... absurd but thats canberra, completely over priced. Lucky i can afford to live in an area that good and not out in a concrete soulless area like gungahlin
 
Last edited:

Walt Flanigan

Referee
Messages
20,727
$1300 a fortnight. You tell me... My issue is some f**king shite builder who didnt wire the f**king building properly and some other douchebag in body corp who wont ok a direct line into my appartment

Lol same deal here. New apartment in Kingston and the wiring in this place is f*cking terrible. Can't have foxtel unless we put the tv in the most cramped corner of the apartment. God knows who designed these places.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
f**king absurd isnt it? The highest rate of education in the country, the highest rate of salary in the country and we cant get a f**king building wired for foxtel... f**k me...hopeless
 

gronkathon

First Grade
Messages
9,266
Less than 50% completion rate.

Thats a new low even for Sheens.

If the Toyota Cup side were not going so well and Balmain just starting to gel I would love to see all the pea hearts like Fifita and Gibbs replaced for the rest of the season.

That and Sheens to get thrown into an active volcano
 
Messages
2,524
Less than 50% completion rate.

Thats a new low even for Sheens.

If the Toyota Cup side were not going so well and Balmain just starting to gel I would love to see all the pea hearts like Fifita and Gibbs replaced for the rest of the season.

That and Sheens to get thrown into an active volcano

No throw him into a dormant one with a deep crater. I'd prefer he went via asphyxiation/starvation/exposure. No team, not even St George, or the Hilter Youth ping-pong club deserve Sheens at the helm. He is poison.
 
Top