What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

'11 | R18 | Sun | Sea Eagles 36-22 Rabbitohs | Brookvale #nrlmansou

R18: MAN v SOU

  • Draw after Golden Point

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    26
  • Poll closed .

Frailty

First Grade
Messages
9,458
We were the best team for the first 60 minutes. Against the best side in the comp. Lack of discipline let us down in the final 20. When we get a coach next year known for his discipline, structure and drill sargeant tendencies, we will fulfill our potential. As a team we have the potential to be the best in the comp as we've shown in our games against the top teams. I'm telling you now, with the right coach we could dominate next year.

50uff$ dominating next year means an improved effort to finish on top in 9th.
 

blaza88z

Coach
Messages
15,187
We were the best team for the first 60 minutes. Against the best side in the comp. Lack of discipline let us down in the final 20. When we get a coach next year known for his discipline, structure and drill sargeant tendencies, we will fulfill our potential. As a team we have the potential to be the best in the comp as we've shown in our games against the top teams. I'm telling you now, with the right coach we could dominate next year.


South Sydney "always next year" Rabbitohs
 

Billythekid

First Grade
Messages
6,848
Souths could have won today without turnstyle Sandow. I don't think i've ever see a player let in more tries than Sandow and Lui.
 

Walt Flanigan

Referee
Messages
20,727
Just saw the "try" that Souths were rewarded by the video ref that Merritt flicked back.

Merritt's foot was clearly out and and touching the ground while his hand was touching ball.

That was an atrocious decision. Lucky it didn't cost Manly the game.

The video ref has to go.
 

blaza88z

Coach
Messages
15,187
also, how can you say you were the better team for 60 minutes, it was 16-8 at half time, just because your team was in the lead at the 60 minute mark doesn't mean you were the better team for 60 minutes

what a clown this old chap is
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,738
@ everyone saying its always "next year" with us, yes we've had the squad to be optimistic the last 2 years like we will next year, but we haven't had the coach.Our coach is out of his depth in the modern game. The success Bennett, Bellamy and Hasler have had in the last 5 years proves that more than ever, a coach is so much more important than players.

Today we saw 2 teams that are equals in talent, but one had the discipline and defense of a top 3 coach, one had the traits that comes with a bottom 3 coach.

All that changes in 2012.
 

slamminsam246

Juniors
Messages
525
also, how can you say you were the better team for 60 minutes, it was 16-8 at half time, just because your team was in the lead at the 60 minute mark doesn't mean you were the better team for 60 minutes

what a clown this old chap is


And It should have been 16-4 at half time. Rabbits had moments of excellence in the first half and came out swinging for the first 12mins of the 2nd half. But Manly were all over them for 85-90% of the match despite not playing their best football. Lol@50uff$ are a long way off being a top 4 team. When they are hot they look like a top 8 possibily and when they are off they look like specials for the spoon. That's why they are where they are. I can't see them making the 8 after watching the Sharks last night.
 

slamminsam246

Juniors
Messages
525
]
@ everyone saying its always "next year" with us, yes we've had the squad to be optimistic the last 2 years like we will next year, but we haven't had the coach.Our coach is out of his depth in the modern game. The success Bennett, Bellamy and Hasler have had in the last 5 years proves that more than ever, a coach is so much more important than players.

Today we saw 2 teams that are equals in talent, but one had the discipline and defense of a top 3 coach, one had the traits that comes with a bottom 3 coach.

All that changes in 2012.


Lol. If the rabbits buy well, get better coaching and show a bit more heart next year, they will probably scrape into the 8 next year.
 

Cletus

First Grade
Messages
7,171
Just saw the "try" that Souths were rewarded by the video ref that Merritt flicked back.

Merritt's foot was clearly out and and touching the ground while his hand was touching ball.

That was an atrocious decision. Lucky it didn't cost Manly the game.

The video ref has to go.

It was a bizarre decision, there was no doubt whatsoever that he was still touching it when he was out of play. And it didn't look like he grounded it properly and I thought the ball bounced out of the field as well. How was it a try?
 

Beachy Eagle

Juniors
Messages
618
What about the kick off out on the full, should have been penalty on half way instead changed the momentum of the game.
How did the video ref and 4 onfield officials miss that.
Sh!t house.
 

mongoose

Coach
Messages
11,852
Souths could have won today without turnstyle Sandow. I don't think i've ever see a player let in more tries than Sandow and Lui.

Sandow's defence is hillariously bad. I think I counted 4 manly tries which were a direct result of Sandow either out of position or just incapable of tackling. Other than that he had a pretty solid game in attack.
 

bennoonthehill

Juniors
Messages
363
great crowd today, was an amazing atmosphere at the ground. ridiculous that it took 18 rounds for us to get a sunday arvo home game.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
101,006
It actually took three, you got one in Round 3.

And if I'm not mistaken you've got Sunday games (albeit some away) for the next few weeks :p
 

Daddycool

Juniors
Messages
513
We were the best team for the first 60 minutes. Against the best side in the comp. Lack of discipline let us down in the final 20. When we get a coach next year known for his discipline, structure and drill sargeant tendencies, we will fulfill our potential. As a team we have the potential to be the best in the comp as we've shown in our games against the top teams. I'm telling you now, with the right coach we could dominate next year.
I saw this as I was leaving the ground..... you're delusional if you think Souths were the better team for the first 60mins. The only reason Souths had any points at half time was because they were gifts from an equally delusional video referee. Souths did have a good 20min period after half time where they did score 2 legitimate trys but that was it.

In front of one of the best crowds at Brookie for a long time, Manly were just too good..... simple as that.
 
Top