'12 | AAMI CvC | Sun | Country 22-24 City | Mudgee

[Y2Eel]

I just like the idea of Carney at fullback, it would piss Eels' fans and Raiders' fans off so bad. Also it would give us the opportunity to have a bonus play maker.

I like it too


1 Carney
6 Hayne
7 Pearce

That said i am Ricky Stuart............

 

[beave]

I love reading post city country threads.


There's not a bit of club bias or rivalrly hatred whatsoever by the majority of posters...............

By the way, Tariq, best on ground.

 

[mozza91]

So Farah has his first decent(at best) performance in how long? and is now the best hooker in NSW, the Tigers fans on here are deluded.

 

[Cliffhanger]

I like it too


1 Carney
6 Hayne
7 Pearce

That said i am Ricky Stuart............

Ricky should just get over his pigheadedness and put Hayne there, but if he doesn't he should go 100 per cent pigheaded and put Carney there to show how far he is willing to go before admitting he's wrong. I am surprised he didn't put Soward there last year to be honest.

 

[Ladmate]

So Farah has his first decent(at best) performance in how long? and is now the best hooker in NSW, the Tigers fans on here are deluded.

You are acting like Buderus has played brilliantly all year.

 

[skeepe]

He also got found out very easily with those first 2 tries to Turner.. Other than that he was solid.

So now it's Fergo's fault that King rushed in and left him with a 2 on 1 to defend? Ok.

 

[mozza91]

You are acting like Buderus has played brilliantly all year.

He's been much better than Farah, its been 4 years and nothing has changed.

 

[Tweed Titan]

WAY too much Buderus gherkin jerkin going on lately.

My take on the match (of the players with some chance of getting a blue jumper, or had obvious good/bad games)

Winners
Robbie Farah
Mitchell Pearce
Blake Ferguson
Todd Carney
Luke Douglas
Tariq Sims
Chris Lawrence
Aaron Woods

Losers
Josh Morris
Matt King
Jarrod Mullen
Ryan Hinchcliffe
Tom Learoyd-Lahrs
Jarryd Hayne (as a 5/8)

Meh
Brett Morris
Michael Weyman
Beau Scott
Ben Creagh
Greg Bird
Trent Merrin
Tim Mannah
Feleti Mateo

 

[Doga]

I did not watch the match but it is really amazing how some players can be seen as both the best and worst player on the park.

 

[Didgi]

Hinchcliffe was solid at worst, and I thought Bird was outstanding with his runs.

 

[user_nat]

I did not watch the match but it is really amazing how some players can be seen as both the best and worst player on the park.

The power of club bias.

 

[adamkungl]

Mullen's greatest talent is getting owned by Pearce year in year out.

 

[Sleep]

According to the guys on the Footy Show today Stuart is eyeing Wallace for Origin, not Pearce. He was good today but whether it's enough to change Sticky's mind...

I thought Coote did well for City even though he's no chance of playing for NSW. Hayne was quiet and is clearly not anywhere close to 100%.

Mullen was MIA at times. Carney must have the 5/8 wrapped up now.

 

[gronkathon]

Matt King really proved he is of Souff$ standard today

 

[dinko]

Farahs combination with Pearce was formidable. Their style complemented one another.
Farahs kicking game was sublime as was Pearce, Farahs D was solid and service from dummy half was crisp. They actually looked like they were enjoying it.

To all the Farah knockers(non-wests tigers fans), put your state ahead of your club allegiances for a moment please, as much of a merkin you may think he is, he most definitely is NSWs best option.

To all those Novacastrians, Bedsy was a great servant to NSW, but he's 34, he's been mediocore at best and he can't play 80 minutes anymore.

1. Hayne
6.Carnery
7.Pearce
9.Farah

Let's go you BLUES!

 

[mozza91]

Farahs combination with Pearce was formidable. Their style complemented one another.
Farahs kicking game was sublime as was Pearce, Farahs D was solid and service from dummy half was crisp. They actually looked like they were enjoying it.

To all the Farah knockers(non-wests tigers fans), put your state ahead of your club allegiances for a moment please, as much of a merkin you may think he is, he most definitely is NSWs best option.

To all those Novacastrians, Bedsy was a great servant to NSW, but he's 34, he's been mediocore at best and he can't play 80 minutes anymore.

1. Hayne
6.Carnery
7.Pearce
9.Farah

Let's go you BLUES!

Have you watched a Knights game this year? He's been very good certainly not mediocre.

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

Have the Knights supporters forgotten how ineffectual Buderus was at origin between 2006-2008? Farah and Ennis were pretty inept but they were just carrying on Buderus' legacy. The best NSW hooker in recent memory was Craig Wing with an honourable mention to Kidley.

 

[Cliffhanger]

You're an idiot.

 

[mozza91]

Have the Knights supporters forgotten how ineffectual Buderus was at origin between 2006-2008? Farah and Ennis were pretty inept but they were just carrying on Buderus' legacy. The best NSW hooker in recent memory was Craig Wing with an honourable mention to Kidley.

No just no, I can recall Queensland dominating us and scoring points whenever Murray took him off though.

 

[dinko]

Have you watched a Knights game this year? He's been very good certainly not mediocre.

I've watched all their games. I recall a few instances where Stirlo was being his usual self beating up Buderus for SOO only for Buderus to knock on only plays later lol, many simple errors on many occasions. Are you disputing the fact that he lacks any sort of creativity and that he can't play 80 minutes anymore?