What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

'12 | R17 | Fri | Broncos 12-26 Sharks | Suncorp

Round 17 result: Broncos v Sharks


  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .

veggiepatch1959

First Grade
Messages
9,841
I like how these sharks nuffies are bigging themselves up over beating the broncos without 7 players and Reed and Hoffman on the bench.

No excuse....the Broncos just have no depth.

The whingers come out of the closet at Origin time, but then again, how many 7 day turnarounds have the Broncos had so far this year?

About 50% more than the next team.
 

Snappy

Coach
Messages
11,844
No depth hey ?

Dont ever bother posting again because you have just shown that you dont know shit.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,132
Got to admit some of our depth is pretty ordinary.

Both Dodds and Lui were useless for us and didn't intimidate the Sharks one bit.

But plenty of positives to take out of that game for us. Just hope our spine can find it's mojo. They've gone missing since the Chooks game.
 

Snappy

Coach
Messages
11,844
Come on Pete,

Our depth is better placed than most clubs IMO. Take 7 players out of any team and they will struggle.
 

wibble

Bench
Messages
4,661
Considering two of those penalties favouring Broncos were for high shots, and another for the kick off out on the full, this is pretty much a case of haters gonna hate.

The only obviously bad decision was the strip call.

Plus I (obviously) thought they were correct decisions, but our 2nd and 3rd tries definitely had some luck and the video referee could have (and would have on another day) denied them. And Graham was definitely offside on our last try, though the whole lead up play was bizarre.

Broncos had a string of decisions/non decisions go their way that got them back in the game, and that was frustrating, but they were still mostly 50/50 decisions, there weren't really any clangers (well, the no try, but the referees will defend that one and say it was right).

The strip call was the only (other) really obvious bad call, and that shows how bad the rule is, since you get one or two terrible, inexplicable strip ball decisions every game.

The speed of the ruck complaint is a bit hard to quantify, but the Sharks have consistently slowed opposition teams all year, so whatever the level the referees are allowing, we have found the right line to walk in terms of slowing the play. Plus we make a lot of dominant tackles, so that helps. And we make a lot of offloads too, so opposition teams find slowing us a bit harder.

Again, I'm obviously biased, but I think one of our strengths this year has been our forwards getting on top in virtually every match, and it looks like we are "getting away" with slowing the play, but we are also earning it with a powerful pack.

Anyway, 8-6 as an away team and you can't be too disappointed.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,132
Come on Pete,

Our depth is better placed than most clubs IMO. Take 7 players out of any team and they will struggle.

I agree.

However, I can't collectively congratulate the depth when Nami & Dodds (two of our more experienced depth players) let us down.

Otherwise, the rest of the second tier players were among our best and really did their best to make a game out of a difficult scenario. I was proud of the boys despite some disappointing performances.

The scary thing is, some of our better depth players were unlucky to miss the cut & we've got some fantastic prospects coming through in the 20s.

wibble - Really enjoying the posts mate. Keep it up.
 

snoozer

Bench
Messages
4,491
both sides got dubious calls.

wasn't even close to a double movement for the broncs try - momentum got him there easily.

not sure what to think about our guys on report - wade was unlucky but there def was contact with his head.need to look at the replay for smiths.


very happy with the win - if wallace had a brain i think it could've gone the broncs way.

the 1st 20 was awesome to watch for a sharks fan - really muscled up.

the stapler played his best game for the club last night.
ross and gibbs are very underated - led the way in that first stint.
wade g - played like an origin player last night.
 

Grapple

First Grade
Messages
5,014
Can't remember seeing a half make more poor decisions in one game than Peter Wallace did last night. Had a shocker. Shades of John Sutton...But Corey Norman should've also put his hand up and taken over, he's got the talent but like Shaun Johnson just seems to take a back seat in some games.
 

Frailty

First Grade
Messages
9,458
22733585.jpg

22733608.jpg
 
Last edited:

Snappy

Coach
Messages
11,844
Utter Fail regarding the use of the memes.

Cant see anyone saying that the reffs dudded the Broncos, rather saying that there was dubious calls for both sides, in resonse to people saying that in fact Sharks were dudded.

And, sure Cronulla could only play the team in front of them, but clearly half a team missing is a discussion point.
 

Frailty

First Grade
Messages
9,458
Utter Fail regarding the use of the memes.

Cant see anyone saying that the reffs dudded the Broncos, rather saying that there was dubious calls for both sides, in resonse to people saying that in fact Sharks were dudded.

And, sure Cronulla could only play the team in front of them, but clearly half a team missing is a discussion point.

Are you kidding me? The thread is full of Broncos supporters whinging about the referee.

And then they feel the need to constantly say 'but we were missing players'... It's Origin - get used to it. We have had to play 3 games (only other teams without a bye before Origin were Warriors and Panthers) without our two best players this season.

The fact remains they still had their no. 1 spine at kick off, the Sharks didn't.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,132
There's been just as much if not more whining from your lot despite the win.

We're used to Origin, it's affected us since day dot but that doesn't mean we can't acknowledge the effect it had on the result tonight. Unless something horrific happens, that Brisbane side isn't going to line up again.

Spine is useless without it's pack.

But that isn't taking away from Cronulla's victory. They were the better team on the night and deserved the win.
 

Frailty

First Grade
Messages
9,458
There's been just as much if not more whining from your lot despite the win.

To be fair most (yes, not all) of the whingers about the referees has come from non-sharks fans who are on board the 'referees favour broncos' brigade.

We're used to Origin, it's affected us since day dot but that doesn't mean we can't acknowledge the effect it had on the result tonight. Unless something horrific happens, that Brisbane side isn't going to line up again.

Spine is useless without it's pack.

And the backs rarely function without its dominant halves player. There is acknowledging the fact you guys were down on personnel, and then there is the crap that a fair few broncos supporters have carried on about.

But that isn't taking away from Cronulla's victory. They were the better team on the night and deserved the win.

Agreed, and Brisbane did well given the start they gave us.
 

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,132
Frailty said:
To be fair most (yes, not all) of the whingers about the referees has come from non-sharks fans who are on board the 'referees favour broncos' brigade.

And most of them are the same sad sacks you'll see try and deride the Broncos in any Brisbane related thread on here.

However, that still leaves all the Cronulla fans across the forum complaining about the reffing despite the win. There were some controversial calls both sides, of course both sets of fans are going to feel hard done by.

Frailty said:
And the backs rarely function without its dominant halves player.

Given the choice, I'll take forwards every day of the week.

They'll do more for your backs than just one half ever could.

Besides, Sharks didn't need TC with Wallace throwing them money balls. :lol:

Frailty said:
There is acknowledging the fact you guys were down on personnel, and then there is the crap that a fair few broncos supporters have carried on about.

Like what?
 

the dude

Juniors
Messages
1,230
Cronulla are eyeing a top 4 spot in the finals after that effort. I had them missing the 8 preseason.
 

Latest posts

Top