'12 | R9 | Sun | Sea Eagles 18-12 Raiders | Brookvale

[VictorTheViking]

simple mate, Fensom didnt get to his feet properly before playing the ball. He tried to do it quicker than he was entitled to do. Which is why the Eagles player was still in the ruck
The knock on was the fair call

Ive seen it ruled the other way plenty of times but knock on is the right call

You watching a different game, as far as I was aware interference in the Ruck like that is a penalty, fensom was on his feet....

 

[Stagger eel]

Did George Rose just pat his teammate on the dick?

Manly played well. The Raiders looked very dangerous and Manlys defense really stood up. Entertaining game.

yeah I noticed big Georgey copped a feel...that bwould of been the higlight of his day.

 

[northwest9]

Lol@dugan, stop reading your own press champ, your average at best

I love a good lol@failders, but manly have a serious issue with urgency towards the loose ball. Why was the back three allowing the ball to bounce or roll so much. That stuff is coach killing complacency.

 

[skeepe]

simple mate, Fensom didnt get to his feet properly before playing the ball. He tried to do it quicker than he was entitled to do. Which is why the Eagles player was still in the ruck
The knock on was the fair call

Ive seen it ruled the other way plenty of times but knock on is the right call

All bias aside, I still disagree.

Held had been called, Fensom was on his feet. He is entitled to play the ball in that situation.

 

[Billythekid]

One of the games of the year and some really good signs for the raiders imo. Actually i thought they were very hard done by overall.

Dugan had an incredible game and really put up his hand for SOO. I also think the in some ways the raiders look better without Campese.

 

[skeepe]

Lol@dugan, stop reading your own press champ, your average at best

I love a good lol@failders, but manly have a serious issue with urgency towards the loose ball. Why was the back three allowing the ball to bounce or roll so much. That stuff is coach killing complacency.

You're off your head. Dugan was fantastic.

 

[Raider_69]

All bias aside, I still disagree.

Held had been called, Fensom was on his feet. He is entitled to play the ball in that situation.

Didnt look to me that he got to his feet properly
anyways, agree to disagree.


It was a decent crack from the raiders. Had to overcome quite a bit and were unlucky not to win. The Eagles defense was good, as was ours. You cant accuse the raiders team of lacking the right attitude of giving up on furner

 

[GAZF]

Our effort didn't lose us the game today, our stupid did.

 

[Raider_69]

Lol@dugan, stop reading your own press champ, your average at best

I love a good lol@failders, but manly have a serious issue with urgency towards the loose ball. Why was the back three allowing the ball to bounce or roll so much. That stuff is coach killing complacency.

:lol::lol:
jealous is a curse mate

 

[Spot On]

Dugan definitely specialises in killing his own team's attack at times. Takes the wrong option with men outside him. I'm sure he can't pass. Stewart has him easily covered for attacking skill. Hopefully Ricky makes the right decision.

Difference was the Feruson f**k up in defence. You would have thought a first grade player would know not to retreat the ten metres looking the wrong way!!!!! Furner should point that out to him this week and have him practise at training.

 

[northwest9]

:lol::lol:
jealous is a curse mate

Jealousy???

We've got slater. Dugan is barely fit to lace slaters boots

 

[Sea_Eagles_Rock]

Good game, Jared Maxwell's 6 point contribution and decision to only referee one side ultimately the difference.

:crazy:

Cry us a river. Manly won!

 

[northwest9]

Skeepe, can you please inform us what the refs got wrong when your self rated winger turned his back in defense?

Surely that was the refs fault right?

 

[VictorTheViking]

That sort of loss I can cop, because the effort was there

 

[Patorick]

Whew.

Raiders played well. Dugan justabout MOTM.

Manly's defence and a bit of luck just got us home.

 

[typicalfan]

Dugan definitely specialises in killing his own team's attack at times. Takes the wrong option with men outside him. I'm sure he can't pass. Stewart has him easily covered for attacking skill. Hopefully Ricky makes the right decision.

Difference was the Feruson f**k up in defence. You would have thought a first grade player would know not to retreat the ten metres looking the wrong way!!!!! Furner should point that out to him this week and have him practise at training.

Definitely Dugans big weakness. On the other hand Stewart did let way too many bombs go uncontested, a big no no in origin. I hope whichever they pick improves either side of their game.

 

[MSIH]

Nice tough game there. Canberra are a tough side and played much better than previous weeks. Manly made a some terrible mistakes, and were lucky they ended up with the penalty count the way it was.

Couldn't split Dugan & Stewart. They are two completely different fullbacks. Stewart's got him covered though, apart from kick returns and kicking.

 

[skeepe]

Whoever was the near side touch judge in the second half... wow. What is the point of him? Can't spot the ball bouncing on the line right in front of him. Can't spot Taufua's blatant knock-on right in front of him either.

He can't be in first grade next week.

 

[mongoose]

I liked our halves today, not so worried about losing Campese for the season now. Williams just needs to take a bit more control and stop standing offside at the play the ball.

 

[Generational Player]

Good tough game, Raiders have a monster pack. Both second rows had excellent games today. Thought Choc had his best game of the season. Matai was superb with those cheeky dummy half runs he always does. Liam Foran was a lot better this week than the last couple, Still not sold on Harrison though. Not sure what Brett Stewart was up to letting some of those balls bounce. A couple of uncharacteristic errors nearly cost Manly the game.