'13 | R8 | Sun | Roosters 30-6 Panthers | Allianz

[neutralsupporter]

Lol at anyone saying the SBW was a no try. The ball never touched the ground

 

[MrAnonymous]

Humble is the worse player in the nrl, killed every attack and cant defend just a shit merkin please go away.

We played alright in patches today and were pretty unlucky but the Roosters are just to good this year.

 

[Nugget10]

How are Le Coq under the cap? It was like watching the Yankees vs the A's in Baseball today

 

[WaznTheGreat]

Panthers put in a gutsy effort today but the Roosters have too many guns in there side,too much class

 

[franklin2323]

Humble is the worse player in the nrl, killed every attack and cant defend just a shit merkin please go away.

This. Walsh doesn't run but atleast gives to ball to others. Humble makes Ben Roberts looklike joey.

 

[mxlegend99]

Lol at anyone saying the SBW was a no try. The ball never touched the ground

Sure it did. When he was tackled. Then again when he reached out and planted the ball in a second movement. Would have to be blind not to see the ball/arm carrying it touch the ground twice.

No way the video referee awards that try. Fortunately the Roosters dominated teh second half and it had no bearing on the result. If it was a 4 point game it would have been much harder to take.

 

[franklin2323]

Gus has ruined the Panthers.

It was that f**kwit Leary that ruined us. Paid overs for Lewis, Jennings, Coote, Gordon, McKendry, Grant.

We didn't claim the long serving player allowance (400k) at the time, Marquee player ($300k), 3rd party ($300k) there's $1m lost. Prob $500k if we paid the above players market value.

$1.5 on top of the 2010 team would of given us a great side. 2014 we will have the team we should of in 2011

Our offer to Carney is $500k. We have Coote, Grant, McKendry on more. For the price of Jennings we got Ellijah Taylor (test player), Soward (SOO & won a comp).

We have Jennings, Satini, Moss, Cartwright, DWZ all look better then any juniors I have seen (including Lewis & Jennings) coming through the grades.

Though our useless coach is doing us no favours.

 

[Babyface O'reilly]

Sure it did. When he was tackled. Then again when he reached out and planted the ball in a second movement. Would have to be blind not to see the ball/arm carrying it touch the ground twice.

No way the video referee awards that try. Fortunately the Roosters dominated teh second half and it had no bearing on the result. If it was a 4 point game it would have been much harder to take.

Judging by the lack of moans and groans at the ground which normally greet the big screen replay, nobody had any issues with it. To us it seemed a close thing but we just marvelled at the strength of SBW to make it to the line. Couple of Pennies fans near us didn't say anything either. Having said that, I probably wouldn't have argued if the decision had of gone the other way.

I wonder if the video ref was involved, how telling a 'cross' or 'T' signal from the ref would've been.

6 all half time score could've given us a different game.

 

[franklin2323]

Judging by the lack of moans and groans at the ground which normally greet the big screen replay, nobody had any issues with it. To us it seemed a close thing but we just marvelled at the strength of SBW to make it to the line. Couple of Pennies fans near us didn't say anything either. Having said that, I probably wouldn't have argued if the decision had of gone the other way.

I wonder if the video ref was involved, how telling a 'cross' or 'T' signal from the ref would've been.

6 all half time score could've given us a different game.

The replay when I got home it was worth a 2nd look. I assume to ref would of said try then gone up. Whether the ball looking like it touched the ground would of been enough is another story.

There was a few like that Jennings 1st so games gets called back for obstruction. I had no issue but I had no issue with the Symonds against Souths either. Hell even the bounce for Jennings 2nd try 99/100 that goes into touch. Had they went to other way might of been a different game but that's footy.

The fact is generally our defence was good. Add Coote, Roberts, Tighe in the backs we may of had some creativity to trouble the defence. So not too disappointed

 

[adamkungl]

Especially in the first half the Penrith defence held up well. Absolutely nothing doing in attack though, multiple sets on our line and nothing even looks like being created.

 

[murraymob]

Especially in the first half the Penrith defence held up well. Absolutely nothing doing in attack though, multiple sets on our line and nothing even looks like being created.

Adam you are being harse
Luke walsh run for over 100 meters on the day .Trouble is there all sideways.

 

[adamkungl]

A dazzling career in Super League awaits Luke Walsh if he keeps up this form.