2015 FFBRL Challenge Thread

[dragon4]

Benji Marshall challenge defense rating of 4.......to be rerated to a 6.

 

[dragon4]

Simon Mannering challenge defense rating of 8.....to be rerated to a 9. Best defensive forward in the game.

 

[dragon4]

Tyson Frizzel.......request rerate to 8/7 from 6/6.

 

[dragon4]

Bryson Goodwin rerate request from a 5 in defense to a 6.

 

[soc123_au]

You can only do 3 at a time. Probably want to show a few stats to back up your requests. Also keep in mind if you have 3 requests fail you dont get any more.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Benji Marshall challenge defense rating of 4.......to be rerated to a 6.

Agree.

Simon Mannering challenge defense rating of 8.....to be rerated to a 9. Best defensive forward in the game.

Disagree. Not in top 10 tacklers for 2014, but does make 29-30 regularly.

Tyson Frizzel.......request rerate to 8/7 from 6/6.

I want to agree but he hasn't proven it. 7/7 to be sure, but not 8/7 yet. Haven't looked at his stats this year but have watched his games and believe he is a possible 8/7 by end of season.

Bryson Goodwin rerate request from a 5 in defense to a 6.

... based on?

 

[Dutchy]

Valentine Holmes from 6/4 to 8/6.

http://www.totalfootystats.com.au/nrl-player-stats/cronulla-sharks/valentine-holmes#.VSEQmFZGzwI - Last season stats.

This season's are far more impressive.

 

[soc123_au]

8/5 for Holmes. Same as I got for DWZ.

 

[Bazal]

8/5 for Holmes
Benji 6 defence
Frizzell 7/7
Mannering 8 defence is right IMO

 

[Misanthrope]

7/5 for Holmes.

6 defense seems fair for Bunji.

Frizzel 7/7

Mannering seems spot on.

 

[dragon4]

Mannering is top tackler in the NRL after 4 rounds with 205....14 more than McCullough in second.

 

[whall15]

Josh McGuire is currently an 8/7, seems way underrated for mine.

Attack
Josh McGuire - Attack 8 - 125m/game - 9.02m/run
Matt Scott - Attack 9 - 159m/game - 9.47m/run
Aiden Tolman - Attack 9 - 121m/game - 7.15m/run
James Graham - Attack 9 - 124m/game - 7.78m/run
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves - Attack 9 - 103m/game - 8.69m/run
Andrew Fifita - Attack 9 - 133m/game - 7.31m/run
Trent Merrin - Attack 9 - 142m/game - 9.35m/run

Seems easily deserving of a 9 in attack to me.

Defence
Josh McGuire - Defence 7 - 911 tackles - 95% tackle rate - 38 tackles/game
Trent Merrin - Defence 8 - 686 tackles - 95% tackle rate - 33 tackles/game
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves - Defence 8 - 766 tackles - 92% tackle rate - 29 tackles/game
Aiden Tolman - Defence 8 - 698 tackles - 98% tackle rate - 33 tackles/game
Matt Scott - Defence 8 - 554 tackles - 96% tackle rate - 28 tackles/game
James Graham - Defence 8 - 982 tackles - 95% tackle rate - 35 tackles/game
Nate Myles - Defence 9 - 644 tackles - 90% tackle rate - 36 tackles/game

Again, easily an 8 in defence. I'd be tempted to push Myles down to an 8 and move McGuire and Graham up to a 9 frankly.

Seems to have been lost.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Mannering is top tackler in the NRL after 4 rounds with 205....14 more than McCullough in second.

Four good games does not a 9 make when he didn't register last year for tackles in the top 10.

 

[Misanthrope]

8/8 for McGuire seems fair. A few overrated props running about.

 

[afinalsin666]

Yep, always need to run off the previous year of stats. Otherwise you get ridiculous ratings like a 9 attack McManus :lol:

Risky putting Benji up, isn't he still a 9 attack?

 

[Bazal]

Difference between McGuire and say, Tolman or Graham or Merrin or Fifita particularly, is that he has zero ball skills. He's a wrecking ball but he doesn't have the extra dimension they have. 8/8 for me

 

[Misanthrope]

Yep, always need to run off the previous year of stats. Otherwise you get ridiculous ratings like a 9 attack McManus :lol:

Risky putting Benji up, isn't he still a 9 attack?

Not for long :sarcasm:

 

[soc123_au]

McGuire 8/8
Wobbie 9/9
Bunji 7/6
Frizzell 7/7
Mannering stays the same

 

[afinalsin666]

Am I good with 9/9 for Farah?

 

[Drew-Sta]

I'd like to get Koroboite rerated to 8/5. Has been huge since emerging; runs on average 200 metres per game, has scored 22 tries in 32 games (which is a 66% strike rate) and is generally hard to handle in tackles.