What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2015 R3 v South Sydney

Tiger05

First Grade
Messages
9,652
A couple of things from my perspective:-

1. Tedesco isn't in Inglis class yet and may not ever get there.
2. Brooks and Moses need to improve a lot. Reynolds was way better than both of them combined.
3. Lawrence and Halatau who tend to cop it are definitely first graders and deserve their spots.
4. Woods is a machine.
4. Galloway deserves a lot more respect than what he gets.
 

TimmyB

Juniors
Messages
2,332
I agree with all that and so to continue
5. Sue continues to improve
6. Sironen went missing and needs to dig deeper.
 

gronkathon

First Grade
Messages
9,266
Siro did his job.

Santi coming on changed that game.

We went from dominating the ruck to getting rolled through with quick PTB speed.

He is not a guy to defend in the middle effectively
 

TimmyB

Juniors
Messages
2,332
I don't remember Siro running the ball after his early drop in the second half. Thought he was going well before that.

Think Woods going off was the key as much as Santi coming on. From memory the Rabbitohs didn't score whilst Woods was on, other than that very late try.
 

magpie4ever

First Grade
Messages
9,992
Not bad, forwards were good.

Brooks and Moses combination disappointing. I can't remember either of them testing the defence line until Moses had a run in about the 76 minute.
 

hybrid_tiger

Coach
Messages
11,684
Woods will get all the plaudits but Galloway has been great.

Our halves have offered little to nothing for three games in a row now.
 

Tiger05

First Grade
Messages
9,652
Woods will get all the plaudits but Galloway has been great.

Our halves have offered little to nothing for three games in a row now.

Its great to see you say that. Woods was fantastic but Galloway was really good. Our halves have been below ordinary and they really need to improve.
 

moller

Juniors
Messages
498
Need to control the ruck 10x better. Souths slowed us down all game and were able to get quick PTBs at will. Brooks and Moses are definitely struggling, but they're facing defensive lines on the front foot far too often.
Bench lacking impact.
Sirro still has composure issues but looks a different player to last year. Missed his impact when he went off.

Glen Stewart was a helluva signing for Souths.
 

BuffaloRules

Coach
Messages
15,444
Just dropped too much ball at both ends of the field.

Forwards went OK...

No reason to be slashing wrists yet...
 

mepelthwack

Juniors
Messages
617
I think we played ok, the scoreline wasn't a fair indication.

However our attack seems lesser than its been for 10 years, at the moment it's a lot to do with Brooks and Moses who are yet to fire at all in 3 rounds. Having said that we must persist IMO.

On the flip side our defence seems the best it's ever been.

Considering these things I think there's a bright future there. No doubt in my mind Nofoluma will make a considerable difference like he always has so far.

Like others noticed, Galloway had a great game. Woodsy what can you say, he will be universally recognised as the number one prop in the world and he'll hold it for a decade.

Sironen looked better, in patches.

Our bench does lack impact compared to last year, no doubt about it, should we throw Cherrington in perhaps? Im not sure who else tbh. Maybe start with Halatau and bring Sironen on who could make an impact when fresh possibly.
 
Messages
14,975
We created plenty of chances and should have lead at the break, but a slack 5 minutes saw us go behind. Not a terrible performance by any means. There is plenty of improvement in this side.
 
Messages
1,175
3, 2, 1 - Taupau, Woods and Galloway excellent.
Sue and Siro average. No penetration.
Halves were crap. Lawrence ordinary.
Need Lodge in for Santi.
Buchanan is much improved.
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
3 Woods
2 Taupau
1 Galloway

If those 3 play like that every week, we'll win more games than we'll lose
 

gordsy

Juniors
Messages
2,118
A couple of things from my perspective:-

1. Tedesco isn't in Inglis class yet and may not ever get there..

He doesn't need to be Inglis good but with better halves he will look better too.
I wonder if Taylor has thought about swapping Moses or Brooks with Drinkwater so we don't have two 21 year olds trying to guide our team around the park. I think he could be a perfect foil for one of them.
 

Ron's_Mate

Bench
Messages
4,111
Wests Tigers coach Jason Taylor wants to see Marty Taupau control his aggression

Michael Chammas
Published: March 22, 2015 - 9:04PM

South Sydney coach Michael Maguire didn't have a problem with Marty Taupau's shot on an unaware Adam Reynolds but Tigers coach Jason Taylor wants the enforcer to err on the side of caution.

Taupau was involved in a number of contentious plays and altercations in a fiery battle against the competition heavyweights at ANZ Stadium on Sunday.

He had a series of verbal and physical exchanges with Kiwi teammate Issac Luke, but it was a shoulder charge on Adam Reynolds that seemed to rile the Rabbitohs the most.

From a kick-off, Taupau ran straight into the back of an unaware Reynolds, who struggled with a shoulder complaint

after the collision.

While Maguire said he didn't have a problem with the hit on his playmaker, Taylor admits he would like to see his giant-prop display some control when tempers flare out on the field.

"I was a bit concerned a couple of times because the last thing we needed to do was give penalties away in a game where we didn't have enough ball as it was," Taylor said. "They were my main concerns. I don't think there's ever been a question about Marty in that regard, I'm just keen for him to stay calm, that's what I'm keen for."

While the Tigers lacked the execution in attack to make a dent in South Sydney's defence, they still managed to stick with the reigning premiers for the majority of the match before a late Dylan Walker try sealed victory.

"Yeah that's exactly how we feel, disappointed," Taylor said.

"Very scrappy in attack, very scrappy. Way off. We have been for both games. But the fact we hung in there and were still in the game with 10 minutes or so to go was really encouraging.

"They wouldn't be happy with their game over 80 minutes but I think we played a part in nullifying what they were trying to do."

The Tigers had two tries disallowed before skipper Robbie Farah opened the account.

However Taylor believes his side should have added to their lead before the break, instead went into the sheds trailing 10-6.

"We didn't make the most of the opportunities we had," Taylor said.

Farah said his side lacked the composure to upset the

high-flying Rabbitohs.

"Effort good, execution poor," Farah said. "But we can take a lot out of it. There's nothing that happened out there that we can't fix. We went with them for a while there but the good sides, they play for 80. There were some patches there were we let ourselves down."


This story was found at: http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/...u-control-his-aggression-20150322-1m54g0.html
 

Latest posts

Top