2016 Match Review Committee / Judiciary

[Pete Cash]

Wightons arms are clearly not tucked into his sides at contact ?

 

[skeepe]

Sure looks like he had his arms tucked. I mean what f**king vision were they watching?

 

[Timmah]

Repeat offenders???????????????

You mean like serial tripper Josh Reynolds who again tripped this year but recieved nothing?

You know he got charged right?

Not his fault the NRL grades tripping so lowly. 75 points base penalty

 

[Pete Cash]

It is clearly not a shoulder charge as the rules are written

 

[carcharias]

Oh Charch, that's really badly timed!
Not an ideal post to make when 2 posts above is a video of Ennis leading with the shoulder. Haha

it wont play for me.
but without looking I know which one looked worse.
without a doubt it was wightons.

 

[Tommy Smith]

So unless he gets off the comp is a two horse race between the Cowboys and Storm.

merkins have ruined the finals series.

 

[Apey]

Great call MRC.

 

[Mr Saab]

You know he got charged right?

Not his fault the NRL grades tripping so lowly. 75 points base penalty

75 points? well whooppeeee bloody doooooo.
He has been given a chopper read window to do what he likes without serious punishment.
Buettner needs to be dissmissed at the end of the season. He has been an abject failure

 

[Chief_Chujo]

What a f**king joke

 

[Pete Cash]

it wont play for me.
but without looking I know which one looked worse.
without a doubt it was wightons.

No one gives a shit mate there is literally a guideline for shoulder charges

From the video that Timmah linked. Which tackler is tucking their arm into their side here ?

 

[nick87]

I

That said, I can't agree with the point above. "Rubbed out"?

You guys have the best depth in the comp and can cover this. Barely skipped a beat with Austin out on Sunday.

We're already missing our 5/8th and now have to replace our fullback. Haha its easy for someone to sit there and say "ohh you've got depth, you can over come it!" but he's one of our most important players, he's vital in our attacking structure and defensively he's who sets up our line

and we've just seen the NRL let Ennis walk for laying someone out for a shoulder charge late, and then slapped our guy with a grade f**king 2 for the same god damn thing.

Raiders fans have every right to be absolutely furious about this.

 

[Dragon Slayer]

Yes great call by the MRC!

The guilt from Wighton after he did it was all to see.

Ricky has no case for a whinge other than he is a perpetual whinger.

 

[MilkShark]

Why the comparisons with Ennis? Wighton hit him like a freight train.

The storm player stayed down to get a penalty the soft c&ck.

 

[Pete Cash]

Why the comparisons with Ennis? Wighton hit him like a freight train.

The storm player stayed down to get a penalty the soft c&ck.

Again not relevant if Wighton didnt do a shoulder charge and Ennis did.

If Wightons arms are not tucked into his side it cannot be a shoulder charge.

 

[Generalzod]

It's an NRL conspiracy

 

[Pete Cash]

I dont think they conspire to be f**king morons its just worked out that way

 

[Chief_Chujo]

We f**king fight this hard. Sticky needs to call in a favour from merkin and have the terrorgraph plastered with comparisons. Make them look like biased corrupt fools if they go through with this bullshit charge.

 

[Tommy Smith]

Sharks fans think it's a great call on both counts, Wighton and Ennis.

What a surprise.

 

[Dragon Slayer]

We f**king fight this hard. Sticky needs to call in a favour from merkin and have the terrorgraph plastered with comparisons. Make them look like biased corrupt fools if they go through with this bullshit charge.

Temper temper! Lol

 

[Generalzod]

Sharks fans think it's a great call on both counts, Wighton and Ennis.

What a surprise.

It wasn't the Sharks fans that made the call....