2016 Rerates Thread

[Misanthrope]

Rerates are now open.

Each side has five rerates per season. These are not replenished, so use them wisely.

 

[afinalsin666]

Actual Stats ripped from here: http://www.rugby-league.com/superleague/stats/player_stats

Games played ripped from here: http://www.loverugbyleague.com/

Firstly, Denny Solomona. Currently an 8/5, looking for an upgrade to 9/5.

Denny Solomona

16 played
20 tries/1.25 pg
56 TBs/3.5 pg
3 TAs/.19 pg
167 Carries/1611m/9.65mpc/100.69 mpg
30 LBs/1.88 pg
69TK/4.32 pg

10 more LBs than next highest

30 linebreaks and 20 tries is monstrous in 16 games.

--------------------------

Secondly, Adam Walker. EDIT: he has played 13 games, not 9, i just went through all KRs match reports to check. About half from the bench.


ADAM WALKER

13 played
219 carries/1535m/7.01mpc/118mpg
425 TK/ 33.2 TKpg/27 MT/2.1 MTpg

I think an 8/7 or 8/8 seems reasonable. Those are pretty solid numbers.

------------------------

Also forgot my boy Kyle Amor. His stats are even better.

KYLE AMOR

12 played
257 carries/1950m/7.59mpc/162.5mpg
395 TK/32.9 TKpg/29 MT/2.4 MTpg

Probably looking for the same 8/7 or 8/8. Hopefully he keeps it up so i can possibly boost him again later on.

 

[Misanthrope]

Posting for Voldemort

Kyle Feldt
Currently 6/5/4/4/5.
12 matches.
8 tries
11 runs for 105m per game, almost at 10m per run.
2.5 tackle breaks per match.
Very good under the high ball, very good positionally. Not the worst defensive winger out there.
Kicks off, handy GKer, but third in line.
I think 8/6/6/6/7 is a fair rating.

-----

For the record, myself and another nameless member say 'yes'.

 

[afinalsin666]

Old Voldy's vote on my guys:

Denny 9/5 (just) Walker 7/8 Amor 87

 

[afinalsin666]

Also from our banished brethren:

Ryan James

Currently at 7 , 8 , 1 , 1 , 6

3 tries 1 assist

125m per game at 8.33m per run.
1.6 TB and 1 effective offload per game
5 errors made this season
401 tackles from 411 attempts - 98%
That’s 36.45 tackles per game and 0.9 missed pg.

8 attack, 8 or 9 def (can make a case regarding technique and hitting merkins hard if need be.) And a rise in temp.

 

[Misanthrope]

8/8 for James.

Agree with Voldemort's ratings for AFS' guys.

 

[Bazal]

Danny Wicks

Currently 7/7, ASRL raters agreed the downgrade was a mistake after I got him an 8 earlier in the season....

2015 Stats

16 games
1703m (106m per game, and 9.7m per run)
470 tackles (A bees dick under 30 tackles per game)

2016 Stats

11 games
1155m (105m per game, 8.5m per run)
325 tackles (29.5 a game)

Looking for 8/7/1/1/7

Chris Sandow

Currently 8/5

2016 Stats

11 games
9 tries
18 try assists (2nd in Superleague, but easily first on an assists per game basis)
33 tackle breaks
11 line breaks

Sadly the ESL site doesn't record line break assists, but he'd be well up there for those as well. His defence hasn't gotten any worse, mostly because it would be hard for that to realistically happen :lol:

Looking for a 9 in attack. And before anyone bemoans the standard difference, the dude was a 9 in the NRL at one stage as well (with lesser stats, I might add). He was the comfortable leader in Man of Steel polling prior to his injury.

 

[Bazal]

Also I vote;

Solomona 9/5
Walker 7/8
Amor 8/7
Feldt 8/6/5/7/7
James 8/9/1/1/8

I justify the 9 for James because when the work needs to be done, he invariably leads the Titans count and he misses f**k all while being a genuine stopping tackler.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Sam Mataora.

Currently 6/6 A/D and Temp of 5. Looking for 7/8 if possible, and temp of 6.

Averaging 30.89 tackles, 8.56m per hit up (averages 10 hit ups a gain, at 91.44 each game).

Seems to be doing the bulk of the defensive work for Newwy, who's forward pack is struggling. Also hits like a brick shit house but isn't a dickhead so gives away fewer penalties.

Thoughts?

 

[Misanthrope]

I would say 6/8 is a decent fit for big Mats.

Happy with 8/7 for Wicks and 9/5 for Sandow.

 

[Wizardman]

Corey Oates
*Currently an 8/6
*Made his Origin debut this year.
*9 games
*9 tries
*Ave 128m a game
*11 linebreaks
The man has been in great form on the wing for about a year now. Solid finisher and as strong as an ox. Im seeking a 9 attack for him.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Is Oates as good as Radradra or Koroibete?

 

[Wizardman]

Is Oates as good as Radradra or Koroibete?

Radradra...no, but I think Radradra should be a 10.
Koribete...in some ways yes, some ways no. I think Koro is quicker. Oates has better hands and finishes better than Koro. Both take big hitups in sets. I think there is not much between the two....both a 9 in my opinion.

 

[Misanthrope]

Radradra is a 10 btw

 

[Drew-Sta]

I think Oates is good. Just wanting the look for the comparison to ensure we line rate people properly.

 

[Bazal]

Oates is a comfortable 9/6 IMO. Arguably the second best winger in the game at the moment.

 

[Drew-Sta]

Cool. 9/6 him up then.

 

[Wizardman]

Glenn Stewart

Third most amount of tackles in super league. We all know that he has great technique as well.
15 games = 686 tackles at 45 tackles a game. That is an insane stat.

Some people might say....err, he defends in a weaker league. They would be absolutely right.

45 tackles in the ASRL would be the equivalent of a 10 defensive stat. In my heart of hearts, I'd give him a 9 because of the weaker comp.

In saying that, if you give him a 9....then give guys like Denny Solomona and Jodie Broughton an eight because there would be no way that they would score so many tries in Australia. They might go well in Australia, not nowhere near well as what they are doing now. If you are to rate them purely on their stats, then Stewart should be a flat out 10.

When you rate Stewart, keep my above point in mind. Rate the player on their field stats or rate the player according to the comp they play in. One or the other, keep it consistent.

 

[Misanthrope]

What are his offensive stats like?

 

[Wizardman]

Two tries, three try assists with 24 tackle busts. Meterage is on the low end with 78m per game.