2017 R14 Sun - Wests Tigers 18-40 Roosters @ Campbelltown

[Clifferd]

If you're in front of the play the ball, you can't get involved in that play at all.

Ahhh didn't catch that, thought it was a shepherd but didn't see one

 

[Vic Mackey]

Tigers centre was offside

But he retreated back behind it, which makes him onside

Some extremely baffling calls. Roosters apparently didn't infringe for 37 minutes which is remarkable

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Lmao @ the chick in the stands taking a photo with an iPad pro

Pics are bigger than on a phone.

 

[Bowzy]

God we are a frustrating team, thought we would show up today and just win. Need to hold the ball instead of being Harlem globetrotters and actually make some tackles. We'll lose this if we don't pull our heads in.

 

[Clifferd]

Never thought I'd say tigers with a chance against the Roosters any time soon

 

[sensesmaybenumbed]

Chee Kam was in front of the play the ball then got the ball in that play.

So an offside attacking player can't run themselves back onside?

 

[horrie hastings]

Roosters hold the ball they will win easily but their handling is diabolical. Tiges are doing well holding in at the moment.

 

[roostersrule2]

Tedesco used one of his own players a shield and it was really quite obvious, why the ref let it play on for a while is the real question.

 

[blaza88z]

God we are a frustrating team, thought we would show up today and just win. Need to hold the ball instead of being Harlem globetrotters and actually make some tackles. We'll lose this if we don't pull our heads in.

So did your team apparently, hence the reason it's not as easy as you thought it would be

 

[Bowzy]

But he retreated back behind it, which makes him onside

Some extremely baffling calls. Roosters apparently didn't infringe for 37 minutes which is remarkable

I think on that play they were playing make up calls for the Shepard they didn't call on teddy.

Quite hard to believe roosters have only given away one penalty, expect to get a few in the 2nd half.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Doesn't matter.
He's out of play until the next play the ball.

No

If you retreat back the 10 you're onside. The video ref said that exact thing in a dragons no try against the tigers last week.

 

[cleary89]

So an offside attacking player can't run themselves back onside?

Apparently not. Whats the point of the rule? Stop bludgers getting involved. But if they run back far enough that their player gets in front then all good imo.

Should change the rule.

 

[OVP]

Roosters 61% possession, but 8 errors to the Tigers 3. Tigers playing good, will be interesting to see what they do with it in the second half.

 

[cleary89]

No

If you retreat back the 10 you're onside. The video ref said that exact thing in a dragons no try against the tigers last week.

Back the 10?

 

[Bowzy]

So did your team apparently, hence the reason it's not as easy as you thought it would be

Sorry typo, I ment to put they beforehand. They really need to start having a dig if their gonna come away with this.

 

[Danish]

We are giving the Tigers no respect at all, and it's showing up on the scoreboard.

We look slick in our set plays, and have shown hints of class, but so much dropped ball combined with the tigers simply wanting to get to those 50:50 balls far more than us has negated all that.

If we don't change our attitude tigers will come over the top of us in the final 15 of the second half

 

[Uncle Kraka]

But he retreated back behind it, which makes him onside

Some extremely baffling calls. Roosters apparently didn't infringe for 37 minutes which is remarkable

I didn't think you can be put back onside if you are in front of the play the ball

 

[Tommy Smith]

So an offside attacking player can't run themselves back onside?

Correct.

 

[Vic Mackey]

I think on that play they were playing make up calls for the Shepard they didn't call on teddy.

Quite hard to believe roosters have only given away one penalty, expect to get a few in the 2nd half.

Mate most of the time it doesn't matter as you beat us by 30. However the roosters get no penalties all year yet remarkably against the tigers the pea gets blown out of the whistle against us every time. It's like the NRL look to make up for all the non calls for you against us every year.

 

[Clifferd]

Roosters 61% possession, but 8 errors to the Tigers 3. Tigers playing good, will be interesting to see what they do with it in the second half.

We're lucky goosters are playing pretty shitty, feels like they should be up by another 2 tries