2019 R19 Sun - Panthers 18-30 Raiders @ Panthers

[gerg]

I though all theirs in the 2nd half came off dodgy calls and the sin bin was BS. Still we probably still lose the attack was very poor again

Can I borrow your crack pipe once you're done with it?

 

[bileduct]

Croker is easily the best centre in the team and top 5 in the NRL.

Yep, when the 31 other starting centres in the comp are out injured, sure.

 

[franklin2323]

Can I borrow your crack pipe once you're done with it?

So Mansour wasn't tackled in the air?

Sezar looked offside not even to the video ref?

How does a ball passed by Canberra into another players leg become a knock on against the team defenfing?

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Yep. All those 50/50 calls caused a deficit of 18 points.

 

[mongoose]

Yep, when the 31 other starting centres in the comp are out injured, sure.

With Leilua and Cotric we have the 2nd best 1-5 in the comp behind the Roosters.

Klokstad
Rapana
Leilua
Croker
Cotric

 

[AlwaysGreen]

With Leilua and Cotric we have the 2nd best 1-5 in the comp behind the Roosters.

Klokstad
Rapana
Leilua
Croker
Cotric

Best young backline

 

[Walt Flanigan]

Lol they won the penalty count, had equal possession and much better field position but blame the refs.

 

[bileduct]

So Mansour wasn't tackled in the air?

Sezar looked offside not even to the video ref?

How does a ball passed by Canberra into another players leg become a knock on against the team defenfing?

At worst Rapana had a hand on Mansour while he was in mid-air. Not long afterwards To'o actually did tackle Simonsson in mid-air and got away with it as well. Replay shows Sezer onside.

I'm pretty sure Croker was stripped of the ball in a 2 on 1 tackle, and that you guys won the penalty count 7 - 4 anyway.

 

[BadnMean]

I though all theirs in the 2nd half came off dodgy calls and the sin bin was BS. Still we probably still lose the attack was very poor again

I knew Pamfers would lose at half time because of the sheer amount of whinge coming out of them. Not even being a smart-arse, I recognised it from Raiders 2017-2018; too busy thinking the ref was the key to winning a game.

You're a one eyed muppet like all of us are with our own teams if you believe the refs cost you that game. As soon as I saw we were not even engaging with ref whinging but focussed on the game, I thought we'd get it done. It's a mental weakness thinking the ref has to hand it to you. Every one hates the calls they get.

 

[nick87]

So Mansour wasn't tackled in the air?

Sezar looked offside not even to the video ref?

Far less tackled in the air than Simonsen was only 2-3 sets latter
And Sezer was perfectly on side

Hit the bricks, clown
Your side was comprehensively out played on your own turf, in front of the home crowd. Credit though, the Panthers definitely won the sooking like bitches count and embarrassing coach blow ups... the last one is super impressive given the oppisition

 

[skeepe]

So Mansour wasn't tackled in the air?

Nope.

Sezar looked offside not even to the video ref?

The bunker checked it on the run and told Klein it was all good, that’s why he took so long to actually award it.

How does a ball passed by Canberra into another players leg become a knock on against the team defenfing?

Because Mansour touched it and knocked it forward.

 

[bileduct]

Yep, looking at the replay now. Referee is about two meters to Sezer's left when the ball is kicked and right in line with the play. Called onside.

 

[nick87]

I knew Pamfers would lose at half time because of the sheer amount of whinge coming out of them. Not even being a smart-arse, I recognised it from Raiders 2017-2018; too busy thinking the ref was the key to winning a game.

I felt the same way,
no kidding

We had em beat in the head, frustrated them into being sooky bitches focused on what others were doing and not what they were doing. And we saw plenty of that to know what it looks like.

We had em beat by half time, they were cooked thereafter.

 

[BadnMean]

So Mansour wasn't tackled in the air?

Sezar looked offside not even to the video ref?

How does a ball passed by Canberra into another players leg become a knock on against the team defenfing?

No, Rapana had an arm up trying to get at the ball- can't you accept Mansauce just dropped it ... twice... and then some idiot tried to scoop it not ground it- classic!

Sezar did not look offside even to the video ref. Try was called. He was alongside. happens every week- why are Pamfers special & need a 2m clearance not a foot alongside?

Not even sure what the last one is whinging about, sorry bro.

 

[BadnMean]

At worst Rapana had a hand on Mansour while he was in mid-air. Not long afterwards To'o actually did tackle Simonsson in mid-air and got away with it as well. Replay shows Sezer onside.

I'm pretty sure Croker was stripped of the ball in a 2 on 1 tackle, and that you guys won the penalty count 7 - 4 anyway.

The ref whinging began on here before the game- carried on up the tunnel at pamfers stadium (maybe should rename it pampers stadium?)- and now is carrying on. The level of entitlement is epic.

 

[nick87]

Franklin just channeling his inner Maloney. Sooky bitch.

 

[TheFrog]

No, Rapana had an arm up trying to get at the ball

That's how he wanted it to look. He pushed Mansour in the air. Try should have been disallowed. Rapana also tackled Edwards without the ball, denying him the chance to get out of the ingoal, just before the final Raiders try.

We didn't play well enough to win anyway. Defence too soft.

 

[gerg]

So Mansour wasn't tackled in the air?

Sezar looked offside not even to the video ref?

How does a ball passed by Canberra into another players leg become a knock on against the team defenfing?

The knock on call was the only one they got wrong out of those 3. Rapana had a hand on Mansour. C'mon. Nobody wants a penalty in that situation - you'd be howling if your boys were penalised for something that soft.

We won't mention the real tackled in the air miss, on Simonson. Or the Croker strip judged to be a 1-on-1 but clearly not. How about Maloney and co with the blatant Chicken wing (again) and then Crusher on Bateman.

 

[bileduct]

No, Rapana had an arm up trying to get at the ball

Nah, can't agree with that. Rapana definitely put a hand on Mansour and wasn't playing at the ball.

Still, not enough to constitute a tackle in my opinion. If they are both in the vicinity of the ball there's always going to be some risk of contact. The rule was brought in to stop blokes getting hammered in mid-air, and the To'o tackle on Simonsson in mid-air was closer to that.

 

[gerg]

That's how he wanted it to look. He pushed Mansour in the air. Try should have been disallowed. We didn't play well enough to win anyway.

When will you and Franklin share that crack pipe with the rest of us?