2022 Round 20 Panthers V Eels

[snickers007]

Not really the point i was trying to make.

Seemed like you were using a yet to be determined light sentence for Carrigan to add weight to your argument that the MRC / Judiciary process is inconsistent.

Plenty of other concluded examples you could have used (including Burgess from this round).

Happy to be corrected if I misread.

 

[Girds89]

Seemed like you were using a yet to be determined light sentence for Carrigan to add weight to your argument that the MRC / Judiciary process is inconsistent.

Plenty of other concluded examples you could have used (including Burgess from this round).

Happy to be corrected if I misread.

I have posted on here many times over the years about how piss poor and inconsistent the mrc is and the judiciary. Its just a lottery..

My comments about carrigan just reflect a frustrated fan and how little faith i have in the judiciary and mrc to make the right calls.. even if they get this one right and rub him.out for 4-5 weeks... what about all the other ones they get wrong or dont even cite each round..

It really is a basketcase

 

[Crashtest]

And Nathan only got a 3/4 suspension, but his extra two weeks are for ‘loading’. I can’t remember if I said at the time or just thought, but we have to go to the judiciary and fight the fine; no downside as far as I can see but this is the long term impacts. It was a bullish!y charge anyway and we could have won it.

If the Panthers legal team thought they could of won, they would of fought it though. They wouldn’t leave sitting out extra games for nothing.

 

[hindy111]

Well said. Feels similar to the Panthers Knights game at the start of the season (when Newcastle were good). Great, even game ruined by an early (deserved) send off.

Penrith struggled in that game against 12 tbh.
Hasn't knights gone downhill since then

 

[hindy111]

Five cmon. We are the competition darlings.

Gotta get a downgrade. 2/3 weeks surely.

Bad tackle but NRL are making am example of him. That's clear. He has served one already by being sent off early. I'd say another 3 is fair. 5 is to many.

 

[hindy111]

Whose laughing now Parra?...Moses gone for 4 weeks

It's interesting. If Parra go well without him perhaps they don't have to offer him 1 million right? If they flop then they will.

 

[hindy111]

Requires surgery for a broken finger

He may of fingered himself at halftime. What a turd

 

[Murraymob1]

He may of fingered himself at halftime. What a turd

Well Hindy you did put a jinx on the team and said it comes in threes .parra can blame you for Moses injury .Walk a plank in to the parra river .you may find the last trophy oarra won there lol

 

[hindy111]

Well Hindy you did put a jinx on the team and said it comes in threes .parra can blame you for Moses injury .Walk a plank in to the parra river .you may find the last trophy oarra won there lol

Moses is a great player. But face it, he is not a born winner. I don't see it anyhows.
I'm hoping we win the next 4 without him and move in a new direction. Guthersons to slow for fullback. I feel 5/8 is his go and hand Dylan the keys.
With Moses and Mahoney gone our defense becomes rock solid.