steerlerbab
Juniors
- Messages
- 284
With Ben Hunt, he had a dismal year last year last year, but if we take his overall career, he did have very good years.Appreciate your work to put all that together but I'd question your defensive stats for some of those guys. Ben Hunt is the worst defender in the comp which is a worry when you consider he's the Qld hooker. Amone and Bird are also quite poor in the defence dept. Kerr on the other hand is a very solid defender with over 95% efficiency despite what his detractors would have you believe and I'd also score his attack higher for his good metres and quickest play the balls in our team consistently, not to mention his off-loads. Liddle also is quite a good defender and I think you'll find Sullivan, though small will prove a much better defender than Amone, Hunt or Sloan by some margin, he has no sense of self preservation, he's a mini David Barnhill.
With Josh Kerr and Jacod Liddle obviously they did not play too much last year, only 7 and 10 games respectively (don't know id it was because injury or attitude). However, I must agree that their 2021 rate was good (44 missed/548 made for Josh and 68 missed/790 made for Jacob ). If they get back to their 2021 levels and play at least 20 games this year, I think they should be rated 4.5 in defence again.
Jack Bird I rated him 4 out of 5 (his efficiency was 87% and he went through a lot of tackles (600 made and 80 missed). So I think my assessment was fair with him.