2024 Match Review & Judiciary charges

[lockyno1]

Only Penrith could only get a week for taking a bloke out for the season

 

[lockyno1]

How the f**k do you watch those two incidents and come up with the same charge?

Host barely clips Schneider, who is perfectly fine

Tago injures Gray who is now out for 6-8 weeks

Same charge

NRL are a joke

least your useless coach might play Duncan! Host being out is a good thing!

 

[mxlegend99]

Only Penrith could only get a week for taking a bloke out for the season

Payne Haas copped a fine for a hip drop on Cleary in the grand final (that went unpenalised). His hip drop caused a Grade 3 PCL rupture on Cleary and he missed the international games as a result.

 

[lockyno1]

Payne Haas copped a fine for a hip drop on Cleary in the grand final (that went unpenalised). His hip drop caused a Grade 3 PCL rupture on Cleary and he missed the international games as a result.

He should have got WAY more as should Tago. It should be a month grade 1, in fact it should be sitting out the amount of weeks you take the injured player for

 

[yobbo84]

My complaint is more that Jacob Host got the same charge as Izack Tago. That's the ludicrous bit. Barely touched him, how the hell is that Grade 2?

 

[Danish]

Genuinely can’t even remember the Host tackle.

hip drop is the dumbest charge going around though so it’s a complete lottery what people will get

 

[skeepe]

Genuinely can’t even remember the Host tackle.

hip drop is the dumbest charge going around though so it’s a complete lottery what people will get

Host ran into the kicking leg of Schneider. He had plenty of time to pull out. Just because people think it's soft doesn't mean it's not against the laws as they stand.

 

[yobbo84]

Host ran into the kicking leg of Schneider. He had plenty of time to pull out. Just because people think it's soft doesn't mean it's not against the laws as they stand.

It's certainly a charge. Probably on the lowest end possible for that sort of thing. But Grade 2? Come on.

 

[mave]

It's certainly a charge. Probably on the lowest end possible for that sort of thing. But Grade 2? Come on.

Its consistent with the Aoloi charge.

 

[mxlegend99]

Genuinely can’t even remember the Host tackle.

hip drop is the dumbest charge going around though so it’s a complete lottery what people will get

He ran in to the legs of the kicker. NRL have to punish it because they threw the book at Freddy Lussick for essentially the exact same thing Host did last night.

Lachlan Ilias just happened to get injured which caused an overreaction in punishment and we’re now seeing it as the current crackdown.

 

[soc123_au]

Only Penrith could only get a week for taking a bloke out for the season

Yes, it's a joke, other clubs players get fines. Nice to see you have a bit of sympathy for our adversity though.

 

[Danish]

Host ran into the kicking leg of Schneider. He had plenty of time to pull out. Just because people think it's soft doesn't mean it's not against the laws as they stand.

Oh right. Yes that was indeed soft and an annoying precedent they’ve set with previous charges.

personally I think running into the kicking leg should be play on. The planted leg should be the only one protected since it’s a massive injury risk. If a kicker is worried about his leg - which he is deliberately swinging into harm’s way - he can always not kick or stand deeper.

This is all providing the defender stays on their feet though, not diving the legs Steve price style

 

[Captain Apollo]

Looks like no charges out of last nmight's games -

NRL Judiciary Report: No charge for Munster following GF

The match review committee has announced on Monday morning that there were no charges arising from the 2024 NRL grand final.

www.nrl.com

 

[Captain Apollo]

Looks like no charges out of last nmight's games -

NRL Judiciary Report: No charge for Munster following GF

The match review committee has announced on Monday morning that there were no charges arising from the 2024 NRL grand final.

www.nrl.com

Looks like I spoke to soon. NRL website at 11.00 am had that articleuypdated with no charges. Now it turns out there are players charged out of Friday's games

3 players charged out of the Sea Eagles v Raiders game (namely Morgan Smithies, Emre Guler and Nathan Brown) and one player from the Broncos v Roosters game (namely Deine Mariner).




Source: https://www.nrl.com/siteassets/2024...--round-9/round-9---friday-night-football.pdf

 

[League Unlimited News]

Manly v Canberra​

Emre Guler (Canberra)

• Grade 1 High Tackle - Careless on Tolutau Koula (20 min)
• Base penalty $1500
• His options
  $1500 - guilty / no contest
  $1000 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Nathan Brown (Manly)

• Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Josh Papalii (33 min)
• Base Penalty: $1500
• 3rd & Subsequent Offence
• His options
  2 matches - guilty / no contest
  $3000 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Morgan Smithies (Canberra)

• Grade 1 Crusher Tackle on Tolu Koula (49 min)
• Base Penalty $2000
• His options
  $2000 - guilty / no contest
  $1500 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Brisbane v Sydney​

Deine Mariner (Brisbane)

• Grade 1 Shoulder Charge on James Tedesco (54 min)
• Base Penalty $2000
• His options
  $2000 - guilty / no contest
  $1500 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

NRL Match Review & Judiciary Charges: 2024 Round 9 » League Unlimited

leagueunlimited.com

 

[skeepe]

Morgan Smithies (Canberra)

• Grade 1 Crusher Tackle on Morgan Smithies (49 min)

That’s quite a feat!

 

[Chins get the wins]

Only Penrith could only get a week for taking a bloke out for the season

It was a tackle honey. That's not what the hip drop rule was made for

 

[League Unlimited News]

 

[League Unlimited News]

Canterbury v Wests Tigers​

Sam Hughes (Canterbury)

• Grade 1 Contrary Conduct (contact with referee) on Kasey Badger
• Base penalty $1500
• 3rd+ offence last 12 months
• His options:
  2 matches - guilty / no contest
  $3000 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Reed Mahoney (Canterbury)

• Grade 1 Contrary Conduct on Alex Seyfarth (74 min)
• Base penalty $1500
• 2nd offence last 12 months
• His options:
  $2500 - guilty / no contest
  $1800 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Reed Mahoney (Canterbury)

• Grade 1 Dangerous Throw on Solomon Alaimalo (38 min)
• Base penalty $2000
• 2nd offence last 12 months
• His options:
  2 matches - guilty / no contest
  $2500 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Aidan Sezer (Wests Tigers)

• Grade 3 Dangerous Contact on Josh Curran (53 min)
• Base penalty 3 matches
• 3rd+ offence last 12 months
• His options:
  5 matches - guilty / no contest
  4 matches - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

David Klemmer (Wests Tigers)

• Grade 1 Contrary Conduct on Kasey Badger (74 min)
• Base penalty $1500
• 3rd+ offence last 12 months
• His options:
  2 matches - guilty / no contest
  $3000 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Alex Seyfarth (Wests Tigers)

• Grade 1 Striking on Reed Mahoney (74 min)
• Base penalty $2000
• His options:
  $2000 - guilty / no contest
  $1500 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Gold Coast v Melbourne​

Chris Randall (Gold Coast)

• Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Reimis Smith (32 min)
• Base penalty $1500
• His options:
  $1500 - guilty / no contest
  $1000 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Joe Chan (Melbourne)

• Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Phil Sami (61 min)
• Base penalty $1500
• His options:
  $1500 - guilty / no contest
  $1000 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

North Qld v Dolphins​

Felise Kaufusi (Dolphins)

• Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Griffin Neame (7 min)
• Base penalty $1500
• His options:
  $1500 - guilty / no contest
  $1000 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

Scott Drinkwater (North Qld)

• Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Euan Aitken (39 min)
• Base penalty $1500
• His options:
  $1500 - guilty / no contest
  $1000 - early plea
• PLEA: TBC

NRL Match Review & Judiciary Charges: 2024 Round 9 » League Unlimited

leagueunlimited.com

 

[yobbo84]

Again how the f**k did Tago only get 1 week