What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2024 R5 Sat - Manly 32-18 Penrith @ 4 Pines

Round 5: Manly v Penrith

  • Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles

    Votes: 1 5.3%
  • Penrith Panthers

    Votes: 18 94.7%
  • Draw after Golden Point

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    19
  • Poll closed .

KOMORI

Bench
Messages
3,640
Maybe not but DCE gets his own spot on the mantelpiece. He did it professionally.
It was a strange situation. Foran had pledged to stay with the club whilst he negotiated with Parramatta, and at that point we had chosen to keep Foran over DCE. He negotiates a contract, Foran f**ks us over, and we are almost forced to offer DCE a massive contract to keep him, given that the “backflip” contract has to be larger than the proffered alternative. Did Daly do anything wrong?? Not in any way shape or form. Did Daly unfairly cop a massive amount of criticism from the fans and media?? Absolutely, especially the filthy Queensland media that were incredibly butthurt about the whole situation…
 

reanimate

Bench
Messages
3,874
Panthers player knocked out. Manly penalty.

Manly player with a bit of blood out. Oh shit, better show a duty of care and stop the game while Panthers are on the attack (which is a fair decision, the first one wasn't)
Oh the adversity
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
13,950
It was a strange situation. Foran had pledged to stay with the club whilst he negotiated with Parramatta, and at that point we had chosen to keep Foran over DCE. He negotiates a contract, Foran f**ks us over, and we are almost forced to offer DCE a massive contract to keep him, given that the “backflip” contract has to be larger than the proffered alternative. Did Daly do anything wrong?? Not in any way shape or form. Did Daly unfairly cop a massive amount of criticism from the fans and media?? Absolutely, especially the filthy Queensland media that were incredibly butthurt about the whole situation…

Seems you know a fair bit more than me.

My memory was he was handshake + signed with the Titans then used then cooling off period to ink a bigger deal. It's legal but it stinks
 

Frank_Grimes

First Grade
Messages
7,023
Panthers player knocked out. Manly penalty.

Manly player with a bit of blood out. Oh shit, better show a duty of care and stop the game while Panthers are on the attack (which is a fair decision, the first one wasn't)
Despite the astonishing amount of bullshit your mob are getting away with in defence, (high shots, flops and wrestling) they're still leaving huge gaps.
 

KOMORI

Bench
Messages
3,640
Seems you know a fair bit more than me.

My memory was he was handshake + signed with the Titans then used then cooling off period to ink a bigger deal. It's legal but it stinks
I’d tend to agree, but yeah that’s what happened and Manly were in a position where the huge contract was our only option aside from losing two young gun halves at the same time. Foran was, in most respects, the villain of the situation, DCE was painted as the bad guy, Titans played the victim better than Jusset Smollet and the press had a field day. Foran was actually the biggest loser in the end, being forced to play for Parramatta for a few years nearly cost him his sanity and career lol
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
13,950
I’d tend to agree, but yeah that’s what happened and Manly were in a position where the huge contract was our only option aside from losing two young gun halves at the same time. Foran was, in most respects, the villain of the situation, DCE was painted as the bad guy, Titans played the victim better than Jusset Smollet and the press had a field day. Foran was actually the biggest loser in the end, being forced to play for Parramatta for a few years nearly cost him his sanity and career lol

Smollet takes me back. What a f**kwit he was.
 

taste2taste

Juniors
Messages
2,495
But everyone here was saying Panthers can win every week playing within themselves and not showing thier cards....

When are they going to start showing thier cards ?
 

Latest posts

Top