2025 Match Review & Judiciary charges

[Apey]

Let the boys play and gouge away!

 

[Trifili13]

Different code table for Origin. Mostly fines til you hit Grade 3.

So different punishment depending if it's a H&A or rep game. We are still playing the same game aren't we? While gameday crowds and TV numbers are up and there are positive vibes around the game, the officiating, judiciary, etc are a joke.

 

[League Unlimited News]

So different punishment depending if it's a H&A or rep game. We are still playing the same game aren't we? While gameday crowds and TV numbers are up and there are positive vibes around the game, the officiating, judiciary, etc are a joke.

Correct. The NRL made these changes three years back here:

'Extra lifeline': Judiciary changes aimed at ensuring stars don't miss big games

Players will receive fines for all but the most serious offences in Origin but the judiciary changes aren't a green light for foul play.

www.nrl.com

 

[yobbo84]

It's a good change. Why should clubs be punished because the players grub it up in a game built on (and marketed on) players grubbing it up.

 

[Saxon]

Match Review & Judiciary​

Jarome Luai (NSW)​

Grade 2 Contrary Conduct on Reuben Cotter (22 min)
Base penalty 20% of match fee
1st offence
- Early plea: 13% of match fee
- Guilty at panel: 20% of match fee
PLEA: TBC Thursday

Off to a Decider as NSW nearly make history after QLD's first half rampage » League Unlimited

leagueunlimited.com

Pissweak.

 

[Saxon]

Correct. The NRL made these changes three years back here:

'Extra lifeline': Judiciary changes aimed at ensuring stars don't miss big games

Players will receive fines for all but the most serious offences in Origin but the judiciary changes aren't a green light for foul play.

www.nrl.com

"..but the judiciary changes aren't a green light for foul play".

Well, apparently they are!

 

[League Unlimited News]

NRL Match Review & Judiciary Charges: 2025 Round 16 » League Unlimited

leagueunlimited.com

Friday​

Wests Tigers v Canberra​

Hudson Young (CAN)​

• Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Alex Seyfarth (27th minute)
• Base penalty $1500
• Second Offence
• -- Early Plea: $1800
• -- Guilty at Panel: $2500
• PLEA: Monday 12pm

Morgan Smithies (CAN)​

• Grade 1 Striking on Fonua Pole (61st minute)
• Base penalty $2000
• First Offence
• -- Early Plea: $1500
• -- Guilty at Panel: $2000
• PLEA: Monday 12pm

Jeral Skelton (WST)​

• Grade 1 Contrary Conduct (hair pull) on Xavier Savage (73rd minute)
• Base penalty $1500
• First Offence
• -- Early Plea: $1000
• -- Guilty at Panel: $1500
• PLEA: Monday 12pm

 

[Chins]

Why no suspension for Harry Grant ramming his finger into Nathan Cleary’s arsehole?

 

[Vic Mackey]

NRL Match Review & Judiciary Charges: 2025 Round 16 » League Unlimited

leagueunlimited.com

Friday​

Wests Tigers v Canberra​

Hudson Young (CAN)​

• Grade 1 Dangerous Contact on Alex Seyfarth (27th minute)
• Base penalty $1500
• Second Offence
• -- Early Plea: $1800
• -- Guilty at Panel: $2500
• PLEA: Monday 12pm

Morgan Smithies (CAN)​

• Grade 1 Striking on Fonua Pole (61st minute)
• Base penalty $2000
• First Offence
• -- Early Plea: $1500
• -- Guilty at Panel: $2000
• PLEA: Monday 12pm

Jeral Skelton (WST)​

• Grade 1 Contrary Conduct (hair pull) on Xavier Savage (73rd minute)
• Base penalty $1500
• First Offence
• -- Early Plea: $1000
• -- Guilty at Panel: $1500
• PLEA: Monday 12pm

Players being charged in games against the tigers but not penalised, iconic

 

[skeepe]

Players being charged in games against the tigers but not penalised, iconic

I can’t even remember the Smithies one. And seriously, Hudson Young being charged for that is ridiculous. If Seyfarth wasn’t holding down, Young wouldn’t have been thrashing around.

 

[nick87]

I didnt notice the Smithies one live either, but having seen the replay... he's very fortunate to only get a fine for that.
Perhaps they took into account that the dumb english f**k split himself open and Pole barely flinched haha

https://wwos.nine.com.au/videos/nrl/raiders-enforce-in-trouble-for-headbutt/cmc4s7riq00170hl61rr28rls

 

[Vic Mackey]

I can’t even remember the Smithies one. And seriously, Hudson Young being charged for that is ridiculous. If Seyfarth wasn’t holding down, Young wouldn’t have been thrashing around.

Could say the same for Skelton on Savage then, let go of his leg and dont get your hair pulled.

 

[Vic Mackey]

In all seriousness we need to take a leaf out of Parra and NZs book and start diving at everything. A four week suspension earlier this year was a high shot on a Tigers player that wasnt penalised causee May got up.

 

[Chins]

I can’t even remember the Smithies one. And seriously, Hudson Young being charged for that is ridiculous. If Seyfarth wasn’t holding down, Young wouldn’t have been thrashing around.

What does Young have against eyes? That's his target every time

 

[skeepe]

I didnt notice the Smithies one live either, but having seen the replay... he's very fortunate to only get a fine for that.
Perhaps they took into account that the dumb english f**k split himself open and Pole barely flinched haha

https://wwos.nine.com.au/videos/nrl/raiders-enforce-in-trouble-for-headbutt/cmc4s7riq00170hl61rr28rls

What is it with Englishmen and headbutts?

yeah he needs to buy a lottery ticket, absolutely should be missing a week for that.

 

[Bazal]

Why no suspension for Harry Grant ramming his finger into Nathan Cleary’s arsehole?

I don't think the judiciary should get involved in the recreational activities of two consenting adults

 

[Chins]

I don't think the judiciary should get involved in the recreational activities of two consenting adults

I know you're having a laugh but it is straight up sexual assault. Should be a 12 month ban minimum