2025 Origin 2 - Wed 18 Jun - NSW 24-26 QLD @ Optus

[Maximus]

Right. So we agree that the ref was arbitrary in his decision making.

And somehow that resulted in NSW being penalised 8-0.

So out of the eye gouge, the Crichton high tackle straight after, the Lomax elbow and the Stefano obstruction, all 4 of which were part of that 8, which ones shouldn't have been awarded?

 

[Maximus]

30th minute.. lead to a try.. try again

Watch it again. Luai clearly strips it. The penalty was for offside, but Luai was pulling at the ball.

 

[Reflector]

Origin yet again serving as a reminder of how short people's memories can be.

Luai- the guy who set up the try that broke Qld and rattled their captain in the Decider last series, is now apparently rubbish as an Origin-level 5/8th.

His counterpart - the guy who was Stefano's shoulder away from captaining the biggest second-half choke in Origin history - is Man of The Match and apparently stepped up to the captaincy perfectly.

 

[Manu Vatuvei]

Look we all know the true MOTM was Capewell and the true fraud is Edwards

 

[Panther Mike]

Fine if you all want to blame Panthers players then I hope we get dropped to conserve energy for Penrith games.
The scheduling has basically killed our chances of winning or even competing in Auckland.

 

[Apey]

That's the thing, it had nothing to do with Chin that the try was disallowed. I have seen those awarded on other occasions.

Lol no. It was a clear cut obstruction. I'm not convinced Carrigan would have got there but he was denied the opportunity.

Cleary was obviously injured but giving him credit for a try that wasn't a try, is that you Ennis?

 

[Someone2]

Luai should of got a couple of weeks for the eye gouge

 

[bedlam breakout]

again watching the over hyped glamour coated aussiegin here in the UK - another instantly forgettable game with poor handling and questionable defence - origin is dead here in the UK now - its so insular no one is interested anymore - bring on the ashes and proper test matches in the autumn - cmon England !

 

[Penrose Warrior]

again watching the over hyped glamour coated aussiegin here in the UK - another instantly forgettable game with poor handling and questionable defence - origin is dead here in the UK now - its so insular no one is interested anymore - bring on the ashes and proper test matches in the autumn - cmon England !

I was going to say don't take drugs in the morning, but then I realised you are on northern hemisphere time. So it's OK.

I can't imagine top brass at the NRL too worried if 'Origin is dead in the UK'

Take your point about proper Tests though.

 

[Penrose Warrior]

Right. So we agree that the ref was arbitrary in his decision making.

And somehow that resulted in NSW being penalised 8-0.

Surely analysing all 8 penalties would be required to ensure that is a fair comment to make? Like I agree, game management by referees absolutely happens, but I also don't like how coaches will go 'they smashed us in the penalty count' like it's actually meant to be even, no matter how good or bad your discipline is.

 

[King hit]

Origin yet again serving as a reminder of how short people's memories can be.

Luai- the guy who set up the try that broke Qld and rattled their captain in the Decider last series, is now apparently rubbish as an Origin-level 5/8th.

His counterpart - the guy who was Stefano's shoulder away from captaining the biggest second-half choke in Origin history - is Man of The Match and apparently stepped up to the captaincy perfectly.

It’s absolutely comical how often the correct opinion changes. It doesn’t matter what you say as you’re going to be wrong the next week anyway.

 

[_snafu_]

Look we all know the true MOTM was Capewell and the true fraud is Edwards

I thought Ashley Klein of Queensland should have won it.

 

[The Mad Hatter]

Not bad for a non-mainstream sport in a non-mainstream state. Bring on game III.

 

[Generalzod]

8-0 penalty in the first half says a lot about the game, no team is that perfect. Kline should never be given another stat of origin game.

 

[Haffa]

again watching the over hyped glamour coated aussiegin here in the UK - another instantly forgettable game with poor handling and questionable defence - origin is dead here in the UK now - its so insular no one is interested anymore - bring on the ashes and proper test matches in the autumn - cmon England !

Teddy?

 

[Generalzod]

Lol no. It was a clear cut obstruction. I'm not convinced Carrigan would have got there but he was denied the opportunity.

Cleary was obviously injured but giving him credit for a try that wasn't a try, is that you Ennis?

Yeah I don’t think he would of got there, but where exactly was Stefano meant to go, in my opinion it was clear case of milking it by Carrigan.

 

[ColdWetPanther]

but where exactly was Stefano meant to go,

Almost anywhere but the exact place he stood; two steps (or more) forward or back and it would have been a try.

 

[Bazal]

Almost anywhere but the exact place he stood; two steps (or more) forward or back and it would have been a try.

Yeah this. He was getting back behind the play, that's fine and if he kept that up, no issue. But he deliberately took two steps backwards into Carrigan. Super stupid. Tbh he was terrible in general and shouldn't be picked game three.

 

[Canard]

again watching the over hyped glamour coated aussiegin here in the UK - another instantly forgettable game with poor handling and questionable defence - origin is dead here in the UK now - its so insular no one is interested anymore - bring on the ashes and proper test matches in the autumn - cmon England !

 

[Canard]

Yeah I don’t think he would of got there, but where exactly was Stefano meant to go, in my opinion it was clear case of milking it by Carrigan.

Doesn't matter, you can't obstruct a defender.

Unless you're trying to argue, Carrigan should have tried to run around him, but that would be cooked.