What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2026 rumoured and confirmed signings

Iamback

Referee
Messages
22,380
He did have a plan, it just doesn’t match what you believe is a good plan.

You take a player out of any position for 78mins it’s going to cause you issues.

I can’t see how putting Schneider on at lock for stint, is better than giving Papa or Henry the extra minutes. That doesn’t make sense to me.

Wow you really have less idea then I thought.

14 gets 0 mins - That isn't a case of me not agreeing with the use of 14. There is no use to discuss.

Are you really this slow?

When Sorro was ruled out.

The bench was

Schneider
Henry
Papalli

We effectively had a 2 man bench rotation for 78 mins
 

Luke Bowden

First Grade
Messages
8,428
Wow you really have less idea then I thought.

14 gets 0 mins - That isn't a case of me not agreeing with the use of 14. There is no use to discuss.

Are you really this slow?

When Sorro was ruled out.

The bench was

Schneider
Henry
Papalli

We effectively had a 2 man bench rotation for 78 mins
Why are you so aggressively rude on an internet forum? Other than being amusing it’s pretty weird.

We played with a three forward rotation all season, dropping to two forwards on the bench didn’t cost us the game, if it was the issue, Schinder would have gone into the middle.

it’s really not that difficult to understand
 

Iamback

Referee
Messages
22,380
Why are you so aggressively rude on an internet forum? Other than being amusing it’s pretty weird.

We played with a three forward rotation all season, dropping to two forwards on the bench didn’t cost us the game, if it was the issue, Schinder would have gone into the middle.

it’s really not that difficult to understand

Because you are being an idiot for the sake of being an idiot.

We did and it didn't work, hence this conversation started
 

Luke Bowden

First Grade
Messages
8,428
Because you are being an idiot for the sake of being an idiot.

We did and it didn't work, hence this conversation started
We didn’t lose the game because of Ivan’s bench rotation, you don’t know more than an NRL coach. Stop carrying on like you know better.
 

Iamback

Referee
Messages
22,380
We didn’t lose the game because of Ivan’s bench rotation, you don’t know more than an NRL coach. Stop carrying on like you know better.

Where did I say I did?

Ivan did what he thought was right at the time but they would of looked into the season and would be looking for improvement.

Any team that doesn't win the comp, reviews the season and looks for improvement.

You contradict yourself, You say the side run out of steam but yet the bench use across the season had no part in it

We had 5 games we had fade outs that we didn't used to have. We had like 60 games in a row if we led at half time we won.

Last year was a different story

Cowboys at home, we had a 10 point lead at half time. We actually used the full 17, That was probably still because of trying to get over Vegas.

Cowboys up there - we had a 10 point lead run down. Went to extra time and Schneider no game time

Titans we had a huge lead at half time. Again extra time
No Schneider
Patea got 10 mins.

Storm and Canberra

Back to back extra time games. No Schneider used.

So we had to make ground up from our poor start, got through Origin

Then went to GC
Newcastle
Back home
Mudgee

3/4 games in extra time. 3/4 games when we used only 16.

So it was more than just the Prelim that the lack of bench seemed to hurt us late in games.

That is why this conversation started
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
67,715
We didn’t lose the game because of Ivan’s bench rotation, you don’t know more than an NRL coach. Stop carrying on like you know better.

Ive said this before. 4 forwards just means a guy like Leota gets less minutes.
If they are capable of 50mins at a 8/10 level why would you replace it for a 7/10?
Makes no sense.
 

Luke Bowden

First Grade
Messages
8,428
Where did I say I did?

Ivan did what he thought was right at the time but they would of looked into the season and would be looking for improvement.

Any team that doesn't win the comp, reviews the season and looks for improvement.

You contradict yourself, You say the side run out of steam but yet the bench use across the season had no part in it

We had 5 games we had fade outs that we didn't used to have. We had like 60 games in a row if we led at half time we won.

Last year was a different story

Cowboys at home, we had a 10 point lead at half time. We actually used the full 17, That was probably still because of trying to get over Vegas.

Cowboys up there - we had a 10 point lead run down. Went to extra time and Schneider no game time

Titans we had a huge lead at half time. Again extra time
No Schneider
Patea got 10 mins.

Storm and Canberra

Back to back extra time games. No Schneider used.

So we had to make ground up from our poor start, got through Origin

Then went to GC
Newcastle
Back home
Mudgee

3/4 games in extra time. 3/4 games when we used only 16.

So it was more than just the Prelim that the lack of bench seemed to hurt us late in games.

That is why this conversation started
We ran out of steam because the Broncos wrestled the momentum off us, all be it with a few lucky tries and we went searching for points, that’s not our game.

An extra player in the forwards rotation wouldn’t have helped, unless we had gone with no halves or hooker cover.
 

Fangs

Referee
Messages
21,571
In Perth right now just paid $15 for Great Northern mid strength. Pint.
I like Perth comes here at least three times a year to visit daughter but I agree beer prices are outrageous.

That sounds like a horrible drop but I'm sure its better than Emu Export.
 
Top