3-2-1 v Yvonne's favourites

[shadowboxer]

Katoa was the missing link late last year. He plays the cowboys semi final, we win.

 

[Special K]

Katoa was the missing link late last year. He plays the cowboys semi final, we win.

1000% this

 

[Craigshark]

Williams
Graham
Trindall/Katoa/Ramien/Hiroti

 

[Big Bloke]

What's with the Williams love?
3. Cam
2.Trindall
1. Katoa

You haven't watch many of our games this year mate? Williams has been incredible. And if you turn around and say he's got dick fingers then I reckon you definitely haven't watched many of our games. He is slowly becoming our next powerhouse now he is over his injuries. I'd almost have him in the starting side for Toby.

 

[bluefox68]

You haven't watch many of our games this year mate? Williams has been incredible. And if you turn around and say he's got dick fingers then I reckon you definitely haven't watched many of our games. He is slowly becoming our next powerhouse now he is over his injuries. I'd almost have him in the starting side for Toby.

I have to put my hand up and say that I WAS WRRROOONNNGGG about Williams…

Huge improvement this year.

 

[txta2]

@Big Bloke
You haven't watch many of our games this year mate? all of them
Williams has been incredible. debatable
And if you turn around and say he's got dick fingers...wtf
I'd almost have him in the starting side for Toby. Hes a backrower not a prop.

 

[txta2]

incredible

 

[shadowboxer]

What’s all that about?
Anyway, I agree on Williams and Toby.
One is on the up, the other on the way down. A switch would do them good

 

[DJDL]

Hes a backrower not a prop.

Agreed. But he always gets used as a prop.

 

[Griffoshark66]

Toby's mud.

 

[Weaponhead]

Toby's mud.

Now come on. Let's not be too hasty here.

Sure, he missed 6 tackles, with 2 ineffective, 2 errors, 2 penalties and 1 ruck infringement. That's not pretty, but he ran for 150 metres and has a big personality so it all balances.

 

[bluefox68]

The most rational take is Riccio’s…

The forwards are a work in progress.
The biggest issue is consistency. I reckon all of the younger forwards have improvement in them.
McInnes is playing out of his skin, but he’s the experienced one.
Wade is surely playing his last 5-6 games in the NRL.
Finucane is probably going to be crueled by injury.
The rest still have a lot of upside.

 

[txta2]

Toby's mud.

IM giving him a bit of slack just back from injury, but yeah he needs to toughn up

 

[Mr Angry]

Haha the Jack love is strange.

Last game, reasonable solid, better than most of his work this year.

Then gives away a penalty whilst in possession.

Souths score.

Next set bad front line missed tackle, Souths score again.

Fitz hooks him.

He is good for an error, missed tackle and a penalty every game. Like Ramien, but Jesse gives you some real quality special plays, you just hope Jack will catch the ball.

Can draw a penalty. That is a plus.

 

[Big Bloke]

@Big Bloke
You haven't watch many of our games this year mate? all of them
Williams has been incredible. debatable
And if you turn around and say he's got dick fingers...wtf
I'd almost have him in the starting side for Toby. Hes a backrower not a prop.


View attachment 77834

Mate if you can't see how good he has been this year then I can't help you.
Let's see how he goes on Friday night.

 

[cb4]

@Big Bloke
You haven't watch many of our games this year mate? all of them
Williams has been incredible. debatable
And if you turn around and say he's got dick fingers...wtf
I'd almost have him in the starting side for Toby. Hes a backrower not a prop.


View attachment 77834

He has been playing in the middle all year. Usually comes on for a prop.
Jack has cut the errors out and just runs forward. Came off the bench against a bigger pack than ours and made 154m, 35 shy of Koloamatangi and 20m short of Murray, in 30 minutes less.
He is one of bright spots in our pack and one we should keep in a re-build.

 

[cb4]

The most rational take is Riccio’s…

The forwards are a work in progress.
The biggest issue is consistency. I reckon all of the younger forwards have improvement in them.
McInnes is playing out of his skin, but he’s the experienced one.
Wade is surely playing his last 5-6 games in the NRL.
Finucane is probably going to be crueled by injury.
The rest still have a lot of upside.

Who are the younger forwards though?
BHU is 28
Royce hunt is 28 in 5 days
Toby is 27

These are the peak ages for a prop and they don't seem to be getting any better.
Maybe harsh on Uele, he goes real good in patches but can't keep fit.

I'd happily shift all 3 of them out the door for upgrades though.

 

[bluefox68]

Who are the younger forwards though?
BHU is 28
Royce hunt is 28 in 5 days
Toby is 27

These are the peak ages for a prop and they don't seem to be getting any better.
Maybe harsh on Uele, he goes real good in patches but can't keep fit.

I'd happily shift all 3 of them out the door for upgrades though.

Wow - you got me there! I had no idea they were that old!

I assumed that they were all around the 24-year-old mark…

 

[sladden road]

Thi

The most rational take is Riccio’s…

The forwards are a work in progress.
The biggest issue is consistency. I reckon all of the younger forwards have improvement in them.
McInnes is playing out of his skin, but he’s the experienced one.
Wade is surely playing his last 5-6 games in the NRL.
Finucane is probably going to be crueled by injury.
The rest still have a lot of upside.

This is a league forum.
Take your rational elsewhere .
Heresy.

 

[bubs]

L. Mitchell.. 3 points.
C Smith.. 2 points.
Latrell M.. 45 points.