Are Kyle Feldt's kickoffs against the spirit of the game?

[Pedge1971]

Only the apex should be allowed the kick off high tees in a game of TopBall

I think we could all agree on that

But what if it was B League and not Topball? What then?

 

[nick87]

But what if it was B League and not Topball? What then?

I’m out here playing tic tac toe and you hit me with some 4D chess questions?

 

[Pedge1971]

With a straight line bust specialist, I suppose.

As opposed to the crooked line specialist when teams like Knights and Manly are defending.

 

[veggiepatch1959]

I just tuned in for the black and white explanation. I'll wait.

I prefer sepia.

 

[Lambretta]

Waaaaah, I don't like something change the rules waaaaaah

Yes, because that's never ended up creating a completely different problem no one thought of the first time around

The constant f**king rule changes to stop one person doing something that would soon go out of fashion anyway is a large part of why Rugby League has gone from a very simple game, to one with a million different rules which can be interpreted a billion different ways

Of course, it does allow us to indulge in our favourite past time of whinging about the f**king refs

Sometimes we need to shut the f**k up and deal

Learn to catch - problem solved

 

[Lambretta]

I love how three quarters of the posters in this thread just assumed that GW's claim that kicking tee heights aren't regulated was legit.

It's right up there with old mate @Lambretta Hall of Fame rant

But that was a quality f**king rant god damn it

 

[Bring back John Fifita]

Feldt's Circus Kicks add plenty of spice to the dynamic of the kick-off. Pat Richards was the original Circus-kick master.. his did too..

And in general play, it's brilliant so see these absolute curveballs raining from the clouds terrorising the opposition fullbacks/wingers. Rather than a mere surrender of possession, they are an attacking weapon..

Against the spirit of the game..... pfft..

Would be like suggesting Warnie please refrain from ripping in flippers, googlies, legbreaks and lob up some gentle nude-balls because the batsman are afraid..

 

[gitano]

Feldt's Circus Kicks add plenty of spice to the dynamic of the kick-off. Pat Richards was the original Circus-kick master.. his did too..

And in general play, it's brilliant so see these absolute curveballs raining from the clouds terrorising the opposition fullbacks/wingers. Rather than a mere surrender of possession, they are an attacking weapon..

Against the spirit of the game..... pfft..

Would be like suggesting Warnie please refrain from ripping in flippers, googlies, legbreaks and lob up some gentle nude-balls because the batsman are afraid..

No.

It is kicking a ball in a way that is outside the original intent of the rule.
To stick with your cricket theme, it's like a batsman switch hitting...or a right arm bowler sending one down left handed or underarm.

 

[Rhino_NQ]

how many weeks suspension should he get?

 

[gitano]

how many weeks suspension should he get?

No weeks. It should be policed like the 15? Degree arm bend in cricket. Meaning a no ball, or penalty on halfway at referee's discretion.

 

[President Trump]

Bring back the sand castles.

 

[gitano]

Bring back the sand castles.

No issue with that. Just no novelty size buckets

 

[BennyV]

Feldt's Circus Kicks add plenty of spice to the dynamic of the kick-off. Pat Richards was the original Circus-kick master.. his did too..

And in general play, it's brilliant so see these absolute curveballs raining from the clouds terrorising the opposition fullbacks/wingers. Rather than a mere surrender of possession, they are an attacking weapon..

Against the spirit of the game..... pfft..

Would be like suggesting Warnie please refrain from ripping in flippers, googlies, legbreaks and lob up some gentle nude-balls because the batsman are afraid..

As much as the game was a box of dicks to watch, Benji's spiral bomb at Kogarah 2 weeks ago was a thing of beauty. I defy any fullback in the comp to catch that. I wouldnt be surprised if its still in the air above Jubilee and someone threw another ball onto the field to hurry the game along.

 

[Bring back John Fifita]

No.

It is kicking a ball in a way that is outside the original intent of the rule.
To stick with your cricket theme, it's like a batsman switch hitting...or a right arm bowler sending one down left handed or underarm.

 

[gitano]

One of your better posts. Probably says more about your other efforts than anything

 

[gitano]

As much as the game was a box of dicks to watch, Benji's spiral bomb at Kogarah 2 weeks ago was a thing of beauty. I defy any fullback in the comp to catch that. I wouldnt be surprised if its still in the air above Jubilee and someone threw another ball onto the field to hurry the game along.

It was wonderful theater. No issue at all with this in general play it was a fantastic kick

 

[Bring back John Fifita]

One of your better posts. Probably says more about your other efforts than anything

 

[blaza88z]

gitano is having a troll here, surely

 

[SBD82]

gitano is having a troll here, surely

Hooked plenty too. We're up to page 6 already.

 

[thorson1987]

Gypsy is just a f**king mong. Surprised he has hooked so many.